acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

SAPO:Sparse-Aware Prompt Optimization

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit activation sparsity that varies with input prompt structure, creating an opportunity to jointly optimize prompts and model computation. We introduce Sparse-Aware Prompt Optimization (SAPO), a framework that combines prompt engineering with reduced-order computation to accelerate both homogeneous and heterogeneous inputs. This is important for physical and embodied AI, where prompts can combine natural language, numerical sensor data, system parameters, and equations. We show that explicitly organizing heterogeneous information induces contextual activation locality, producing more correlated and compressible activation representations across neighboring layers. SAPO exploits this structure through a transformation based on Koopman operator theory and the Mori–Zwanzig formalism, replacing -neuron continuous-depth layers with compact -dimensional Gated Recurrent Unit (GRU)-based blocks () and replacing iterative Ordinary Differential Equation (ODE) solves with parallelizable matrix operations. Experiments on large-scale foundation models show that reduced-order computation accelerates both prompt types, while prompt engineering amplifies its benefit for heterogeneous inputs. SAPO achieves training speedup for structured prompts compared with unstructured prompts, together with approximately lower aggregate test time while maintaining comparable task quality. These results demonstrate the synergy between prompt engineering, which exposes more compressible activation structure, and reduced-order computation.

Primary area:
infrastructure, software libraries, hardware, systems, etc.
Keywords:
LLM, Sparsity, Continuous-depth neural networks, Prompt Engineering

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_3TGNOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes SAPO to accelerate embodied large models incorporating continuous-depth networks through the co-design of structured prompts and low-rank computational modules. It is observed that explicitly partitioning text, sensor data, and queries enhances activation correlation across adjacent layers and reduces effective rank. Based on this, SAPO employs the Koopman–Mori–Zwanzig framework to replace high-dimensional LTC/Neural ODE layers with low-dimensional GRUs, matrix exponentials, and output projections. Experiments report training speedups of up to 3.55x and testing speedups of approximately 2.9x.

Critical strengths
  • The study offers a novel perspective by linking prompt structure to the model's internal computational efficiency.

  • Experiments were conducted across various datasets and architectures, reporting metrics such as wall-clock time, energy consumption, and effective rank.

  • The finding that structured prompts significantly enhance activation locality and reduce effective rank offers valuable insights.

Critical weaknesses
  • The mechanism by which structured prompts accelerate fixed-dimension dense GRU and matrix operations remains unclear.

  • The theoretical results primarily consist of an existence proof regarding the expressive power of GRUs, relying on strong steady-state assumptions. They fail to provide sufficient guarantees for the actual approximation error of finite-dimensional SAPOs.

  • There is an internal inconsistency in the experimental setting. For instance, the main text states that the primary experiment used P=16, yet the main results align with the P=4 values ​​reported in the appendix.

  • The evaluation focuses primarily on specific models incorporating LTC/Neural ODEs and is insufficient to support claims of broad applicability to general LLMs or Transformers.

Questions for authors

Please refer to the Critical Weaknesses part.

1 comment

Thank you reviewer 3TGN08 for giving some comments we can understand!

Response to Reviewer

Q1. The mechanism by which structured prompts accelerate fixed-dimension dense GRU and matrix operations remains unclear.

A1. Section 2 explains how structured and unstructured prompts differ, and shows the mechanism by which the structured prompt leads to accelerated fixed-dimension dense GRU and matrix operations.


Q2. The theoretical results primarily consist of an existence proof regarding the expressive power of GRUs, relying on strong steady-state assumptions. They fail to provide sufficient guarantees for the actual approximation error of finite-dimensional SAPOs.

A2. Section 3 and the Appendix give the full proof of the approximation error when the GRU replaces the LTC, so the result goes beyond an existence statement. The ablation study in Table 3 also measures this empirically: it shows how timing and loss differ under the replacement.


Q3. There is an internal inconsistency in the experimental setting. For instance, the main text states that the primary experiment used P=16, yet the main results align with the P=4 values reported in the appendix.

A3. We found that P=16 gives the best trade-off between accuracy and timing, so we use it for the main experiments. The P=4 setting appears in the Appendix as an extended experiment showing how performance and error change. With P=4 there is less computation, but the error is higher because the forward layer's weights store less information. Please see Table 24 for details.


Q4. The evaluation focuses primarily on specific models incorporating LTC/Neural ODEs and is insufficient to support claims of broad applicability to general LLMs or Transformers.

A4. Our paper focuses on continuous-time neural networks (CTNNs), and our theory is built on the CTNN formulation. Table 4 also includes several different RNN architectures to show that the approach applies beyond a single model.

Reviewer_4W7hOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The authors present Sparse-Aware Prompt Optimization (SAPO), a method for speeding up LLMs that contain continuous-depth layers, which they call embodied continuous LLMs. SAPO has two components.

(1) A prompt-structuring step reorganizes heterogeneous prompts that mix text, sensor readings and system parameters into labeled sections.

(2) A reduced-order layer replaces each expensive continuous-depth layer with a much smaller recurrent block.

The paper provides the motivation for the design and theoretical support for it. The authors integrate SAPO into LFM2-1.2B and evaluate it mainly on a autonomous insulin delivery task. They also measure the latency effect of prompt structuring alone as well. The authors compare their method across various baselines and apply SAPO outside of just LFM2-1.2B.

Critical strengths

1.The paper raises an interesting and underexplored question. They address whether the way an input is formatted can shape a model’s internal representations enough to make computation cheaper. Using prompt structure to optimize for efficiency is an interesting way to address this paper.

  1. Continuous-depth layers are expensive because they require iterative ODE solves so replacing them with a compact block that has a closed-form update is a sensible direction, and it gives consistent speedups across the settings the paper reports.
Critical weaknesses
  1. SAPO’s per-step cost does not depend on the content of the input. It consists of a P=16P=16 GRU, a 16×1616 \times 16 matrix exponential and a projection. Training runs a fixed 100 epochs (Table 10), and structured prompts are slightly longer than unstructured ones (Table 22). At test time there is no interaction at all. The LTC baseline is already 1.32× faster on structured prompts (569.25 s vs. 431.25 s), which is the same ratio SAPO shows (193.08 s vs. 146.59 s). Table 8 also shows test time barely changing from P=4P=4 to P=32P=32 (146.59 s to 147.74 s), so the SAPO block accounts for a negligible share of it. The only remaining evidence is the 1.53× training-time gap at fixed PP (2766.34 s vs. 1805.50 s). No FLOPs, step counts or per-step times are reported for this gap, and a fixed-size computation offers no mechanism for it. Hence, the speedup can only be attributed to the architectural replacement, and the synergy the method is named for is unsupported.

  2. The paper states that "the student model (LFM2-1.2B) with H=1024H=1024-cell LTC-NN layers is accelerated by replacing each layer with a P=16P=16 GRU-based SAPO block." However, the public LFM2-1.2B has 16 layers, made up of 10 short-convolution blocks and 6 grouped-query attention blocks. Its hidden size is 2048, and it has no mixture-of-experts and no ODE-based layers. The paper’s own description of the model (line 316) mentions only gating, short convolutions and grouped-query attention. Yet Table 1 reports results for "decoder layers" 65--70, and Figure 2 draws LFM2 as a mixture-of-experts model containing "LTC-NN" layers. If the authors built the LTC baseline themselves by inserting LTC layers into LFM2, the reported 2.9× speedup largely undoes a slowdown they introduced. Hence, the headline speedup has no clear reference point, and a comparison against the released model is missing.

  3. The locality comparison in Table 1 measures fixed token positions across the two prompt formats. Because structured prompts insert header tokens, the two prompts hold different tokens at those positions. The reported tt-statistics also correspond to about 50 samples per group rather than the stated 500. The effective-rank data contradict the chosen PP. Even structured prompts need r90=34r_{90}=34 components (Table 28), so a 16-dimensional block captures less than 90% of the activation energy. Table 8 shows no dependence on prompt structure. Unstructured prompts tolerate P=4P=4 about as well as structured ones (5.6e-5 vs. 5.2e-5), and they reach a lower loss at P=8P=8 (4.8e-5 vs. 5.0e-5). For both prompt types, loss worsens as PP grows beyond 8. Table 8’s P=4P=4 row is also identical to the main P=16P=16 results in Table 3, while its own P=16P=16 row reports different values. Hence, the paper’s own sensitivity analysis contradicts the claim that structured prompts are what make aggressive reduction possible.

  4. The method fits in one sentence: a small GRU, then a closed-form linear ODE, then a projection back to HH but the abstract and introduction instead present it through Koopman/Mori–Zwanzig terminology and use concepts more complicated than needed to explain the core idea. "Prompt optimization" refers to a fixed three-header template with no objective and no search. Figure 1 leaves out the prompt-structuring step and draws the module as a generic bottleneck that is indistinguishable from a LoRA adapter. The proof of theorem 1 also requires a constrained GRU with a ReLU update (line 1106, Table 11), while Table 10 lists sigmoid + tanh activations for every experiment. Quality is reported only as undefined losses on the order of 1e-5, and these disagree across tables for the same runs: SAPO has a loss of 5.6e-5 in Table 3 but 8.31e-5 in Table 7, at identical test times. GSM8K, FinQA and SVAMP appear only in a latency table, and the AID outcome metrics defined in Appendix A.5 are never reported. Hence, the "accuracy-preserving" claim rests on a theorem that does not apply to the evaluated model and on losses that contradict each other.

Smaller issues point the same way and suggest the manuscript needs substantial revision: a duplicated "Model: Model:", wrong appendix cross-references, and Tables 17/18 disagreeing with Table 3.

Questions for authors
  1. Which components of LFM2-1.2B are the "H=1024H=1024-cell LTC-NN layers" being replaced? If the LTC baseline was built by inserting LTC layers into LFM2, how was it trained, and how does its task performance and latency compare to the released LFM2?

  2. If prompt structure is what makes activations compressible enough for P≪HP \ll H, why do unstructured prompts tolerate P=4P=4 as well as structured prompts do in Table 8, and reach a lower loss at P=8P=8?

  3. Is the 1.53× training-time gap between structured and unstructured prompts at P=16P=16 a difference in time per step or in number of steps?

  4. Is the trained SAPO block held to the weight structure in Table 11, and with which update activation? What is its output error relative to the original layer, ∥hSAPO−hC∥/∥hC∥\|h_{SAPO} - h_C\| / \|h_C\|, and what are its downstream task metrics (GSM8K/FinQA/SVAMP accuracy, AID time in range and time below range)?

1 comment

I recommend next time the reviewer can shorten the weaknesses from AI; otherwise, we cannot understand what you want to express.

Response to Reviewer

Q1. Which components of LFM2-1.2B are the "-cell LTC-NN layers" being replaced? If the LTC baseline was built by inserting LTC layers into LFM2, how was it trained, and how does its task performance and latency compare to the released LFM2?

A1. We replace the forward-pass layers. The LTC layers are not inserted by us: they are the original layers of the LFM2 foundation model, and that unmodified model is our LTC baseline. The baseline therefore matches the released LFM2 in both task performance and latency. The SAPO replacement is trained by knowledge distillation from LLaMA, as described in the paper.


Q2. If prompt structure is what makes activations compressible enough for [P = ?], why do unstructured prompts tolerate [P = ?] as well as structured prompts do in Table 8, and reach a lower loss at [P = ?]?

A2. Table 8 is meant to show the timing benefit of applying SAPO to structured prompts rather than unstructured ones. Across settings, the loss values for structured and unstructured prompts are very close, so accuracy is comparable between the two. The advantage of structured prompts shows up mainly in efficiency.


Q3. Is the 1.53× training-time gap between structured and unstructured prompts at [P = ?] a difference in time per step or in number of steps?

A3. The 1.53× figure is the total training time on the same input prompt.

Reviewer_sb33OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes SAPO, which uses activation locality induced by structured prompts to support a reduced-order replacement of LTC/CDLV layers: the H=1024 LTC layers in LFM2-1.2B are compressed into a P=16 GRU, low-dimensional matrix evolution, and output projection. The paper reports training and inference speedups and evaluates the method through prompt comparisons, ablations, sensitivity to P, and other dynamical-system benchmarks. The method is somewhat novel, but the theory–architecture correspondence, training protocol, task-quality evidence, and acceleration mechanism still require clarification.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses a clear engineering problem concerning the iterative computation cost of ODE/LTC-type models and attempts to connect prompt structure and activation locality with reduced-order dynamics. This direction is novel and potentially useful.
  2. The experiments cover structured and unstructured prompts, ablations, multiple dynamical baselines, and several scenarios, and report means and standard deviations for some results. The experimental coverage is relatively broad.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The correspondence between the theoretical formulation and the concrete architecture is not clear. The current theorem does not clearly support the complete dynamical approximation of the proposed architecture or the strong “accuracy-preserving” claim.
  2. The training setup and capability evaluation are unclear. The main experiments do not specify whether SAPO is a post-training replacement/self-distillation procedure or a newly trained architecture; under structured and unstructured prompts, the paper mainly reports loss and speed rather than direct task metrics, and mechanism for the speedup of structured prompts is unclear.
Questions for authors
  1. Please check why the right-hand coupling block in the memory term is written as K_MI in Eq. (3) and Appendix Eqs. (13)–(16), and why the appendix directly states K_IM=K_MI. Based on my current reading of this theory, their shapes are different and their roles are also different, so they cannot be directly treated as symmetric or equal. Also, could you explain why the initial-condition residual in Eqs. (14)/(15) can be neglected for the finite sequences used in practice?

  2. Please consistently define the dimensions and reconstruction relationships of h_G, h_N, h, G_M, K_M, and A. The paper describes G_M as a P-dimensional observable and K_M as the dynamical block, while also writing h=K_MG_M. My understanding is that h˙G=KMhG,hG=GM\dot h_G = K_M h_G, h_G = G_M; please explain specifically how dimensionality reduction is performed inside the GRU block, and check or clarify the meaning of Theorem 1’s ||\dot h_G-\dot G_M-K_MG_M|| expression. I believe that G˙M\dot G_M is already KMGM+memory convolutionK_MG_M+\text{memory convolution}, so KMGMK_MG_M should not be subtracted one more time.

  3. Figure 2 only explicitly shows the GRU generating G_M, followed by matrix-exponential evolution using A and a P→H projection. Please give the correspondence between the hidden state of Block 2, the GRU recurrence axis (a GRU would normally recur over the token axis, while your architecture uses matrix exponentiation to solve one step exactly, which seems not to involve additional ODE integration steps or an independent memory axis), and the memory convolution in Eq. (3). Please provide intermediate-state evidence, memory-kernel evidence, or an ablation removing Block 2. If SAPO is only a new architecture inspired by the MZ approximation and obtained through retraining, rather than a post-training self-distillation approximation of the original network, please adjust the “equivalent” and “accuracy-preserving” wording and the theoretical claims accordingly.

  4. Please clarify whether the training in Table 3, as well as the experiments on the other RNNs and different models, performs post-training/fine-tuning/self-distillation after replacing the LTC layer in existing model weights, or performs distillation training from scratch after reinitialization (I note the many claims concerning “training efficiency”). Please specify what supervision signal the LLaMA3-8B teacher provides and whether all baselines use the same training budget. If the models are retrained, SAPO should be regarded as a new architecture inspired by the theory rather than a post-training approximation; the approximation theory cannot imply that the trained capabilities also remain approximately equivalent. The authors should also report the parameter scale and training cost required to achieve the same performance, rather than only changes in throughput. If the method is indeed a self-distillation or fine-tuning approximation of an existing model, please provide experimental data showing the approximation error of the modeled object to support the stated claims.

  5. Please explain why both Table 2 and Table 3 show a speed benefit for structured prompts. With the same P=16, and with the appendix showing that structured prompts are slightly longer, which operations, solver steps, cache behavior, sparse kernels, or convergence steps produce the benefit? Are there dynamic step sizes? The current results appear to imply a causal claim that “structured prompts lead to acceleration,” which is unclear to me.

  6. Please explain the discrepancy between the SAPO-LODE+sparse test times in Table 3 and Appendix Tables 17–18.

  7. Please add direct task metrics for the main LFM2 experiments on AID, FinQA, GSM8K, and SVAMP rather than only loss. Table 2 reports only latency, while Tables 3 and 7 mainly report loss; these results do not establish “accuracy-preserving” behavior or “comparable task quality.” Please also compare the structured and unstructured prompt settings separately, because they currently show substantial efficiency differences, and the paper explicitly motivates the method by the reduced-order potential induced by structured prompts. However, the reason for the efficiency difference and its effect on outcomes are unclear. In addition, the claim about structured prompts should concern the quality of SAPO’s reduced-order approximation, but the current results do not appear to show a significant effect on loss. Prompt engineering may simply produce a generally small loss reduction. If so, the authors may need to reconsider the reasoning chain that links prompt structuring to the feasibility of SAPO.

  8. Please clarify whether the +SAPO results in Table 4 use same-weight replacement or retraining, and provide task quality, parameter counts, training budgets, and replacement locations. Please provide complete efficiency–quality sensitivity results for P=4, 8, 16, etc. to justify the efficiency–quality tradeoff for P=16. If only loss and speed are reported, please narrow the claims of “accuracy-preserving,” “no architecture-specific tuning,” and cross-model generalization, and provide complexity and operation counts based on the actual ODE solver.

1 comment

This reviewer did not give any specific answer, only AI-generated weakness. I cannot understand those weaknesses.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.