acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Learning Generative Motion Manifolds for World Models

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

We introduce Parameterized Latent Motions for Model-Based Reinforcement Learning (PaLMR), a framework that learns generative motion manifolds as reusable action interfaces for world models. From task-independent motion experience, PaLMR learns behavior-aligned latent coordinates and a parameterized flow model for executing and interpolating motions. The learned interface remains fixed during model-based RL, providing shared coordinates for predicting motion outcomes and composing motion sequences. We establish conditions for predictive generalization and show how denser motion coverage tightens planning-error bounds, supported by controlled experiments demonstrating more accurate prediction and effective use of interpolated motions. Across navigation and robotic manipulation benchmarks, PaLMR outperforms primitive-action and generative-policy RL baselines in overall task performance and online sample efficiency.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
Model-Based Reinforcement Learning, Skill Discovery, Flow Matching Policy

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_2CbdOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The authors first learn a latent motion space from task-independent motion data, encouraging distances between motion codes to reflect differences between the corresponding physical trajectories. They then train a flow-matching model, conditioned on the motion code and the current execution context, to generate executable action sequences. With the motion encoder and executor frozen, they use model-based reinforcement learning to learn a separate world model and high-level controller for each downstream task. The world model predicts motion outcomes and rewards, and the controller uses these predictions to select and compose motions. They evaluate the framework on Meta-World and PointMaze, with additional experiments examining motion prediction and interpolation.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses an interesting question: how should latent motion coordinates be organized, and what should distances between them represent to support world-model prediction and planning? This is a topic well worth exploring.

The authors provide a theoretical analysis of how execution regularity and motion coverage relate to prediction and planning errors under stated assumptions. This helps explain the motivation behind the proposed design.

The separation between reusable motion execution and task-specific world-model learning is a useful design choice. Within each domain, the same pretrained motion encoder and executor remain frozen and are reused across downstream tasks.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Although PaLMR improves over the reported baselines, the experiments do not clearly establish how much of the downstream gain comes from the proposed geometric representation.
  2. The experiments do not isolate the additional benefit of model-based planning when using the proposed motion interface.
  3. All evaluations are conducted in simulation. The current evidence therefore leaves the method’s applicability to physical robots unverified.
  4. The reported variability does not capture the sensitivity of motion-interface learning to initialization.
Questions for authors

See Weakness.

Reviewer_6EAgOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The submission presents a mechanism for learning latent-space world models in the space of (latent) action chunks. The process uses reconstruction + contrastive learning to learn the representations, an action decoder that maps latent codes to generated action sequences via flow matching, and a task-specific transition/reward model used for planning.

Critical strengths
  • The general idea seems interesting. The authors propose to learn latent-action-chunk embeddings, learn a mapping from the latent action space to action sequences, and then learn transition/reward models for task-specific high-level action planning. Overall, the idea sounds interesting.
Critical weaknesses
  • The writing of the manuscript is far from sufficiently clear to understand the proposed approach. The explanations are terse and do not flow cohesively, and many (most) symbols are either not defined or not explained. As currently written, it would be impossible to replicate the approach after carefully reading through Sections 3 and 4. See detailed notes below.

Sec 3

  • The paragraph "Motion requests and execution" leaves too many underspecified descriptions:
    • What is a representative-point position? I don't understand this notation: (pk−p0)k=0H−1(p_k-p_0)_{k=0}^{H-1}. Is it a set? Why do we want the differences relative to the initial point in the segment?
    • What is the set S\mathcal{S}? Is raising it to dz−1d_z-1 the Cartesian product of the set dz−1d_z-1 times? What is "chord distance"? How do we measure distance in the space Sdz−1\mathcal{S}^{d_z-1}?
    • What is the execution context? What does it represent and how do we compute it? Is it a scalar, a vector? Is it learned, given?
    • What is an "auxiliary command η\eta"? What is a "per-decision discount β\beta"?
    • I don't understand the notations PGP_G and RGR_G. The subscript GG appears to be related to the decoder GθG_\theta, but it is unclear what this indexing means. Does the indexing somehow account for the context cc or is context somehow not tied to the transition and reward?
  • The paragraph on flow matching should really use the same notation as the previous paragraph to connect things together. The action chunk yy had no notation previously, it's unclear how vθv_\theta relates to GθG_\theta, it's unclear if the ξ\xi from the previous paragraph is the same as here.
  • The same problem persists throughout model-based planning: how do these notations connect to the previous ones? The reader really shouldn't have to piece together the various elements here but rather be told how to connect them; that should be the whole point of a background section bringing together various elements.
  • Overall, this section reads like a list of partially-provided definitions, rather than a means for providing the reader with the necessary context for understanding the contributions presented in subsequent sections.

Sec 4

  • The main paper should say a little bit more than "details are given in Appendix F.2" about data collection. Even the appendix is not clear. "All 5939 collection attempts passed the fixed acceptance criteria." What criteria? This only describes exact motions executed in PoitMaze. What would be a generalization of these choices? Are the eight directions and 3 distances the target positions that the controller seeks to stabilize to?

Sec 4.1

  • Is μϕ\mu_\phi a vanilla transformer, or what? What is normalize(⋅)\mathrm{normalize(\cdot)}? What is the form of the decoder?
  • dτd_\tau is a dissimilarity between which traces? In Eq. 5, what are zz and z′z'? What variable(s) in Eq. 5 relate to the encoder μϕ\mu_\phi? What is the reasoning behind separating the warm-up stage and the subsequent minimization?
  • How does geometry come into play here? Is it physical-world geometry (in the state space) or geometry of the latent space?
  • Based on the description after Eq. 5, it seems that the loss is a sort of contrastive objective, but there are not nearly enough details to understand how the objective is set up or how it works.

Sec 4.2

  • "context c(s)c(s) supplies the current kinematic conditions" — It is not clear what this means, especially since we don't know what c(s)c(s) is. Also is this approach specific to robotics? This would be the first hint of that.
  • One single paragraph mentions all the following: "action-proxy distillation", "request-cycle consistency", "local action-sensitivity", "inverse head", "shuffled contexts", "local action changes". From this paragraph, it is not possible to parse what any of these mean.

After 4.2, it no longer made sense to continue reviewing the manuscript. The notation at this point was still unclear, and the crux of the approach, which was learning the embedding space and mapping to action sequences, was completely lost on the reader. Overall, I don't believe that a human reader can understand what the algorithm defined throughout Section 3 and 4 does, and certainly could not replicate it. Therefore, it is impossible to extract meaningful insights from the contribution.

Questions for authors

Given the state of the manuscript at submission time, materially affecting my assessment would require a completely new reviewing round, which is out of scope during the discussion process.

Reviewer_dEGrOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes PaLMR, a framework that pre-trains a latent action space for model-based RL on scripted, task-agnostic motion data, which is then frozen and reused across many downstream tasks. An encoder is trained so that physically similar motions map to nearby latent codes (geometry aligned), and a conditional flow-matching decoder generates actions from a latent code and the robot's current state. The main experiments ask whether model-based RL learns more effectively over these latent actions than over raw actions. This is evaluated on all 50 Meta-World tasks and three PointMaze layouts. PaLMR is compared against model-based RL over raw actions (flat TD-MPC2), model-free SAC, and RL methods that fine-tune or steer pre-trained generative policies, and in aggregate it achieves higher success rates and better sample efficiency than these baselines. Supplementary experiments support various design choices. These show that the geometry-aligned latent space makes outcomes of unseen motions easier to predict, interpolated codes lead to more efficient plans, and that the flow decoder executes them more reliably than a regression decoder.

Critical strengths
  1. The latent action space is thoughtfully designed: nearby codes correspond to similar motions, and the state-conditioned flow decoder can execute codes that interpolate between recorded motions. The supplementary experiments show that these design choices improve prediction and planning.

  2. The improvements over RL with raw actions are significant and consistent: 79.7% vs 67.9% success for flat TD-MPC2 across all 50 Meta-World tasks, with one frozen latent space reused for every task.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The latent motion manifold is trained only on free-space end-effector reaching motions (a fixed set of directions and distances), with no object interaction and no end-effector rotation. It is unclear whether this approach would extend to more challenging tasks, such as dexterous or contact-rich manipulation, where useful task-agnostic primitives are much harder to script.

  2. It is not clear that the learned latent space is responsible for the improved performance. Planning directly over the short scripted motion primitives used to collect the training data could be just as effective. The main comparison, flat TD-MPC2, plans over raw single-step actions, so it does not separate the benefit of the learned latent space from the benefit of simply planning over well-structured, temporally extended motion primitives.

Questions for authors
  1. How much is the latent space contributing compared with planning over short-horizon action primitives? For example, how would TD-MPC2 perform if it searched directly over the scripted motions used to train the latent space?

  2. How would you collect training data for the motion manifold when targeting a dexterous hand, or more contact-rich tasks with a parallel-jaw gripper (Meta-World does not even involve end-effector rotation)? Task-agnostic scripted motions seem much harder to define in these settings.

  3. The generative-policy baselines (DPPO, ReinFlow, FPO++, DSRL) perform poorly when pretrained on the same reaching data, which leaves flat TD-MPC2 as the only strong comparison. Are these the most appropriate baselines? Could you compare against any of the skill-learning methods cited in your related work (e.g., SkiMo, SPiRL, SeCTAR, OPAL)?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.