- Rating
- 1(−1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose PROFF, which uses distillation to construct lightweight FF replacement modules and dynamically selects their capacity based on structured prompts. The framework aims to reduce computational overhead in agent inference and accelerate prefill, decoding, and end-to-end execution while largely preserving task quality.
Critical strengths
The work provides a clear and convincing motivation, establishing the value and significance of the work. In particular, the introduction is well written.
Critical weaknesses
This paper is far from sufficiently developed. It lacks a clear overview or component diagram that presents the technical details. Insufficient attention has been paid to the figures. The organization and coverage of the main text are also incomplete. I do not believe the main text adequately conveys what readers need to understand the paper. It lacks a critical assessment and discussion of the proposed approach, as well as a related-work discussion that supports and contextualizes the contribution. As a result, I cannot sufficiently understand the work from the main text alone.
The experimental evaluation is insufficient, and the paper does not even provide a well-organized ablation study. The incremental benefits are not adequately explained or substantiated, so I maintain my original assessment and concerns. Table 4 lacks corresponding online-latency measurements for the fixed and adaptive configurations, making it impossible to determine whether adaptation improves the quality–latency tradeoff. The exact architectures of the alternative modules in Table 2 and whether their parameter and training budgets are matched also require clarification.
Questions for authors
At least you need to address the weaknesses I identified in the “Critical Weaknesses” section.