- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents ReKinetics, a diffusion-based framework for synthesizing dynamic contrast-enhanced MRI from non-enhanced inputs and acquisition times. The method learns corrective interventions through three components: CCAL constructs structured failure cards from training-time prediction discrepancies to supervise action routing; FCTL injects learned corrective residuals into denoising through state-dependent activation and spatial support; and RGCO reweights subsequent training according to changes in reconstruction-based reliability. Diagnostic supervision is distilled into internal routing and kinetic-state modules, enabling inference without an external diagnostic model or reference trajectory.
Critical strengths
- Kinetic evaluation: The paper evaluates regional enhancement trajectories alongside frame fidelity. Figure 3 and the target-referenced crSSIM metric help assess whether generated sequences reproduce enhancement changes beyond plausible individual images.
- Explicit corrective mechanism: Sections 3.1–3.2 connect structured diagnostic supervision to action activation, spatial support, and learned residual transformations. This makes corrective execution concrete and allows inference without the external diagnostic model used during training.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper proposes too many modules and losses and lacks sufficient ablation experiments to demonstrate the effectiveness of each component design. The paper introduces seven losses and three modules, but not every loss or module has a corresponding ablation study.
- Why not implement the self-correction idea using a large model? Implementing a small routing component inside a diffusion model makes it difficult to truly "understand" what the error is. Even if improved generation is observed, describing the effect as "self-correction" is somewhat forced and overstates the model's capability.
- Taking Figure 3(a) as an example, the cumulative error metric also decreases at points not labeled as self-correction. Does this indicate that Figure 3(a) alone cannot confirm that the effect is due to self-correction?
- Table 1 shows inconsistent trends across the two datasets; perhaps more datasets are needed to validate the framework's effectiveness.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses
We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment. We corrected Table 3 and provided checkpoints for the ablations. The new controls show gains from VLM-composed supervision and factorized corrective execution under matched comparisons. We also report results for all seven hand test patients and clarify how the router updates corrections during inference without ground truth or a VLM.
1. Answer:
Thank you for identifying this issue, and we apologize for the oversight. During manuscript assembly, an obsolete intermediate version of Table 3 was inadvertently retained. The identical interpolation fractions were a table-preparation artifact and did not represent independent experimental measurements. We have replaced Table 3 with the corrected results. We also provide the corresponding checkpoints. The corrected results support our conclusion.
2. Answer:
We replaced VLM-composed Failure Cards with a rule-only version:
3. Answer:
The inference-time deviation from the non-enhanced image describes predicted enhancement; it does not directly measure error or trigger correction on its own. The router combines it with acquisition timing, regional intensity trajectories, and latent features to select actions learned from target-referenced Failure Cards during training. At inference, ReKinetics extracts kinetic context from a preliminary trajectory and keeps it fixed during refinement. At each denoising step, the router uses the current latent state to update action strengths and spatial support. Those actions change the latent state, which informs the next step. No ground truth or VLM is used at inference.
4. Answer:
To separate factorized execution from supervision and auxiliary regularization, we trained a parameter-matched, fully supervised monolithic residual with the full supervision and training budget. We also removed the three temporal and spatial auxiliary losses jointly while retaining the complete ReKinetics architecture. The correction mechanism makes a measurable contribution. Moreover, turning the learned actions on improves ROI MAE in 71.4% of trajectories. Thus, the simpler model does not match ReKinetics.
Matched architecture and auxiliary-loss ablations.
5. Answer:
We report below the patient-level results from the same evaluation used for the main table. We computed all five metrics separately for each patient, averaging that patient’s slices and acquisitions first. We calculated a two-sided 95% Student’s t interval (df=6). As shown in the table below, performance varies across patients, with Cases 24 and 29 presenting the greatest difficulty on several metrics.