- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This study investigates diversity collapse in VAR models and proposes DiverseVAR, a training-free approach to address this issue during inference. The core idea is to identify early-scale components that are most closely associated with structure formation and modulate them through soft suppression and soft amplification. The paper presents a series of analyses and visualizations to illustrate the method and evaluates it on multiple benchmarks. However, a key concern is that the paper does not provide sufficient analysis to establish whether VAR itself suffers from diversity problems, as its experiments are conducted only on Infinity, a variant of VAR. Therefore, there is a potential problem of analytical errors.
Critical strengths
1.The paper is well written and easy to understand.
2.The experiments are rich, and the paper reports results on multiple benchmarks.
Critical weaknesses
I am very familiar with VAR models and various VAR-based text-to-image models.
1.The analysis of why VAR models lack diversity is insufficient. The paper only presents the phenomenon, but does not explain why VAR models lack diversity. In fact, the original VAR [1] and HART models do not lack diversity. The authors can check Table 1 of VAR [1], where VAR achieves the highest IS score, which does not suggest a lack of diversity. In addition, the authors can show the Figure 8 of the VAR and HART, and compare the diversity of HART with diffusion models (e.g., SD3) or AR models (e.g., Emu3 or Show-o). These additional results would show that the diversity issue may not come from the VAR model itself, but rather from other reasons, such as the drawback of Infinity. Therefore, there may be a factual error in the paper.
2.I suspect that the diversity examples of HART shown in Fig. 1 were carefully cherry-picked. This is a completely unreasonable comparison, because according to my own experimental results, HART exhibits very rich diversity.
[1] Tian et al. Visual Autoregressive Modeling: Scalable Image Generation via Next-Scale Prediction. NeurIPS 2024.
Questions for authors
None
9 comments
Response to Reviewer EEaS (2/2)
W2: The HART examples in Fig. 1 appear cherry-picked; in the reviewer's experiments HART shows rich diversity.
The samples in Fig. 1 are not cherry-picked: they are randomly drawn, all prompts are listed in the caption, and the vanilla model and DiverseVAR use identical random seeds, differing only in whether SSR/SAR is enabled. The HART rows are intended to illustrate the relative improvement brought by our method under the same seeds, not to claim that HART lacks diversity entirely. In the revision, the Fig. 1 caption states that both methods use identical seeds and no longer describes HART as collapsed. In addition, Fig. S6 provides sample grids with fixed seeds 0–7 for the vanilla model and DiverseVAR (Infinity-2B), without any selection within each prompt. We would also be glad to compare on the specific prompts and settings under which you observed rich diversity for HART.
Ethics flag.
We discuss potential risks (e.g., deepfakes, privacy and bias) in the Broader Impacts and Ethical Statement of App. B. All models and datasets are publicly available, and no sensitive personal data are used. We would appreciate it if the reviewer could point out any specific ethical concern so that we can address it.
We hope these responses address your concerns, and we are happy to provide further clarification.
Official Comment by Authors
Dear Reviewer EEaS,
Thank you once again for your constructive comments. We would like to know if our responses have adequately addressed your concerns. We are also eager to hear any additional concerns or suggestions from you that could help us further strengthen our paper. Your feedback would be invaluable in making this work even more compelling and worthy of acceptance.
As the rebuttal window is closing soon, we genuinely appreciate your feedback. We hope our response has addressed your concerns.
Best Regards, Authors of submission 745
Response to Reviewer EEaS (1/2)
We appreciate your comments and would like to clarify the following points.
W1: VAR and HART do not lack diversity (highest IS in VAR, Fig. 8 of VAR/HART); the issue may come from Infinity rather than the VAR paradigm, implying a factual error.
Accordingly, we have revised the paper (highlighted): the Abstract and Introduction now restrict the claim to "mainstream text-to-image VAR models such as Infinity" and to per-prompt diversity and cite [3, 4] as independent evidence; Sec. 2 discusses [3, 4]; and the Fig. 1 caption now states that the vanilla Infinity models exhibit limited per-prompt diversity and that our method produces more diverse outputs for both Infinity and HART, no longer stating that HART suffers from diversity collapse.
[1] Tian et al., Visual Autoregressive Modeling, NeurIPS 2024.
[2] Sadat et al., CADS, ICLR 2024.
[3] Park et al., DiverseVAR, ECCV 2026.
[4] Yang et al., DiverseAR, arXiv 2025.