- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CrownGen, a dental crown generation framework that combines margin-aware generative modeling, morphology refinement, and physical-reward adaptation. The method aims to generate anatomically plausible crowns while improving their compatibility with adjacent and opposing teeth. The experiments demonstrate promising geometric accuracy and functional adaptation. Overall, the article has clear ideas, reasonable structure, and sufficient experiments. Although, there are some concerns on the role and evaluation of the predicted margin line.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses a clinically meaningful problem by considering both anatomical morphology and functional constraints in dental crown generation. The proposed framework is technically reasonable, and the integration of morphology generation with physical reward adaptation is well motivated. The experiments are relatively comprehensive, including comparisons with existing methods, ablation studies, geometric evaluations, and expert assessments. The improvements in functional validity metrics, DNT and DTA, are particularly encouraging.
Critical weaknesses
Major: (1) The margin line is jointly predicted during the first DiT training, but is not explicitly used in subsequent mesh reconstruction or refinement. And MLD is computed between the expert annotated margin line and the generated crown surface rather than the directly predicted margin line. Please clarify how the margin branch contributes to the final crown geometry, whether the generated margin shown in Fig. 3(b) comes from the prediction branch or is extracted from the reconstructed mesh, and consider reporting direct margin line prediction accuracy. (2) Although the input and output of the high frequency morphology refinement DiT can be inferred from the overall pipeline, the description in Section 3.1.2 is too brief and not very easy to follow. Please add a few equations, which may be similar to those in the first stage, to make the process clearer, e.g., M^{(2)}=\mathrm{MC}({\mathrm{p}|D_{\psi }(\mathrm{p},\ \mathrm{DiT}(a_{i}))=0}). This is how I understand the process, please correct me if I misunderstood. At least, please provide a detailed explanation in the supplementary material. (3) Some recent dental crown generation methods, such as DentalGEN[1], are not discussed in the paper. Please include these studies in the Related Work to provide a more comprehensive overview of recent developments in this field. [1] Wu J, Liu Y, Chen Y, et al. DentalGEN: a large-scale controllable generative AI framework for automated dental crown restoration[J]. npj Digital Medicine, 2026. Minors: (1) The dataset covers multiple tooth positions, but the current visualizations are relatively limited. Additional examples across different tooth positions would help demonstrate the generalization of the method. (2) Although it is not explicitly mentioned in the paper, the visualizations seem to suggest that the input includes the prepared tooth geometry and labels. If so, how well does the tissue surface of the generated crown fit the preparation surface? Clarifying whether preparation surface clearance is considered would improve the clinical interpretation of the results. (3) Figure 3 contains separate descriptions for its subfigures but lacks a unified figure caption.
Questions for authors
N
Response to Reviewer 7d6j
Response to Reviewer 7d6j
R3-1 · Major 1 · Margin line prediction
At inference, the first-stage DiT jointly generates a crown shape latent and a 256-point preparation margin from the scan-derived context. It learns the relationship between crown geometry and the preparation margin through joint prediction and a dedicated margin loss. Mesh reconstruction uses the crown shape latent, and refinement uses spatial anchors derived from the reconstructed mesh.
The MLD reported in the paper measures the distance from the reference margin to the generated crown surface. We also evaluated the predicted curve directly on the validation set. Its mean symmetric distance to the reference margin was 0.21 ± 0.28 mm (median 0.15 mm). We will add this result to the revised manuscript.
R3-2 · Major 2 · Morphology refinement
We added an equation in Section 3.1.2 to clarify the morphology refinement stage.
R3-3 · Major 3 · DentalGEN
Thank you for the suggestion. We have added DentalGEN (Wu et al., 2026) to the first paragraph of Section 2, discussing its controllable multi-view diffusion framework for joint crown geometry and texture synthesis and its incorporation of clinical constraints.
R3-4 · Minor 1 · Visualizations across tooth positions
We thank the reviewer for pointing this out, and agree that the original gallery did not sufficiently cover different tooth positions. We have rebuilt the gallery with crowns from all seven tooth positions (1–7, central incisor to second molar), so that results across positions can be viewed side by side. The new gallery is in Additional Experiments (Fig. 11 in the appendix).
R3-5 · Minor 2 · Internal Fit and preparation clearance
CrownGen uses the intraoral scan and a target tooth ID at inference, with tooth labels obtained by automatic segmentation. The functional rewards address proximal contact and occlusal clearance. To assess preparation fit, we evaluated the intaglio surfaces of the technician-designed reference crowns (GT), CrownGen, and its ablated variants. We evaluated the unprocessed crowns on 100 cases using area-uniform surface sampling, excluding regions within 0.5 mm of the finish line. We report unsigned intaglio–preparation distances, and local distance-map errors relative to GT. GT incorporates undercut relief, which may contribute to spatial distance variation.
Values are case means ± between-case SD. The unsigned distances quantify geometric proximity. Distinguishing clearance from overlap requires a signed assessment.
R3-6 · Minor 3 · Figure 3 caption
Thank you for the suggestion. We revised Figure 3 to use a single caption with descriptions of both panels.
References