- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
- LoRA fine-tuning of Qwen-Image-Edit-2509 to insert the person(s) from a source image into a target background.
- HBAF: timestep-adaptive weighting on the human bounding-box region (λ_max = 2.5, T from 900 to 808).
- FFIP: ArcFace loss between Hungarian-matched faces.
- BDP: 529 pairs built from real photographs and Nano Banana Pro composites via forward and reverse pairing.
- Evaluated on 131 pairs against existing editing models, with ablations, a 10-annotator preference study, and transfer to FLUX.2-klein-base-4B.
Critical strengths
- The fine-tuning is data-efficient: 529 training pairs and 2 A100 GPUs, and the effect holds when the base model is switched to FLUX.2-klein-base-4B (Table 4, CA 0.374→0.160).
- Reverse pairing, which places real photographs on the ground-truth side, is a sensible idea, and the forward-only vs. reverse-only comparison in Fig. 9 is convincing.
Critical weaknesses
- The CA metric is inconsistent across tables. Table 1 marks CA as lower-is-better, yet InsHuman has the highest value (96.18) and is marked best; in Tables 2–4 the same model reports 0.1298 (Qwen: 70.99 vs 1.0229). Appendix B gives a single definition (mean absolute error), so it is not possible to tell from the text what Table 1 measures. The Table 3 caption (“FR and IDS”) also does not match its columns.
- The training data is constructed from Nano Banana Pro outputs, and the paper then reports outperforming Nano Banana Pro (IDS 0.55 vs 0.54, LPIPS 0.222 vs 0.264). There is no variance over the 131 pairs, and no description of how the test pairs are separated from the Unsplash images used for training.
Questions for authors
Q1) Does CA in Table 1 use a different definition from Tables 2–4? Could you align the definition, direction, and scale?
Q2) How were the 131 evaluation pairs separated from the 529 training pairs — are identities, source images, and backgrounds disjoint? Could you also report variance for the main comparisons?
Q3) How were the Nano Banana Pro outputs obtained, and did you confirm that using them as training data is permitted under the applicable service terms?