- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CER-RVS, a training-free agentic framework for referring video object segmentation (RVOS) that addresses two key limitations of existing methods: incomplete candidate tracks and unreliable candidate selection. Anchor-Guided Track Refinement (AGTR) selects a reliable anchor frame for each candidate based on SAM3's predicted mask confidence and relative mask area, then performs bidirectional re-tracking to recover missing observations and improve track completeness. Contrastive Evidence Reflection (CER) employs a Proponent and a Critic to independently examine supporting and contradicting evidence for each candidate, while an Arbitrator resolves conflicting judgments and guides targeted re-examination of uncertain candidates. Experiments show that, using the same MLLM backbone, CER-RVS outperforms AgentRVOS by 3.5, 1.9, and 5.0 J&F points on MeViS, ReVOS, and ReasonVOS, respectively.
Critical strengths
- Motivation is clear. The paper identifies two key problems in track-level agentic RVOS and addresses them with two complementary modules. Their nearly additive gains in Table 2(c) support this design.
- The method is effective. CER-RVS shows consistent improvements across three benchmarks and two MLLM backbones, including a 5.0-point J&F gain on ReasonVOS over AgentRVOS.
- The paper provides an interesting ablation study. Beyond final J&F scores, the paper evaluates AGTR using track coverage and missing rate, and CER using the same candidate pools. These results help explain why each module works.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper does not compare with Refer-Agent[1], a closely related training-free agentic RVOS method.
- The paper lacks a hyperparameter sensitivity analysis for N, alpha, and R.
Questions for authors
see weakness
3 comments
Sorry for my late reply. After carefully reading all the reviews and the authors’ rebuttal, I have decided to maintain my original score. Best of luck with your paper!
Sincere Thanks to Reviewer Bgzq
Dear Reviewer Bgzq,
We sincerely thank you for taking the time to carefully review our rebuttal. We fully understand that this is an especially busy period during the rebuttal process, as everyone also has their own research and manuscripts to attend to. Therefore, we are particularly grateful for the additional time and effort you have devoted to revisiting our paper and thoughtfully evaluating our responses.
We also deeply appreciate your insightful and constructive feedback, which has helped us identify important areas for improvement and further strengthen the clarity and rigor of our work.
Once again, thank you very much for your valuable time, thoughtful consideration, and encouragement. We truly appreciate your recognition and support. We also sincerely wish you the very best and hope that all your own submissions receive favorable outcomes.
Best regards,
Authors
Brief Summary of Responses to Reviewer Bgzq
Dear Reviewer Bgzq,
We sincerely thank you for your time and effort in reviewing our paper and for your constructive suggestions. To facilitate a quick review, we summarize the key points of our rebuttal below.
Comparison with Refer-Agent: We have conducted additional experiments comparing CER-RVS with Refer-Agent under the same Ovis2.5-9B MLLM backbone. Our method outperforms Refer-Agent by 9.8, 0.2, and 4.5 J&F points on MeViS, ReVOS (Overall), and ReasonVOS, respectively, demonstrating its effectiveness across different RVOS benchmarks. (Please refer to Weakness 1 in our response for details.)
Hyperparameter Sensitivity Analysis: We have conducted additional sensitivity experiments on ReasonVOS to investigate the effects of N, α, and R. The results demonstrate that our default settings (N = 5, α = 0.6, R = 3) achieve the best performance among the tested configurations, balancing anchor reliability, candidate diversity, and reflection effectiveness while considering inference efficiency. These findings further validate our design choices. (Please refer to Weakness 2 in our response for details.)
We sincerely hope that these additional experiments and analyses have adequately addressed your concerns and further strengthened our submission. We would greatly appreciate it if you could raise your score in light of these new results. Should you have any further questions or concerns, we would be happy to provide additional clarification.
Thank you again for your valuable time and thoughtful feedback.
Best regards,
Authors