- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
see weakness.
Critical strengths
see weakness.
Critical weaknesses
The paper addresses an interesting problem, namely streaming visual grounding under causally arriving image streams, but the literature coverage, technical contribution, empirical rigor, and presentation are insufficient for ICLR.
-
The literature review is inadequate and shows limited knowledge of visual grounding.
The paper cites some VLM and 3D perception works but omits many classic and directly relevant visual grounding studies, including TransVG, MDETR, Grounding DINO, ...... It also lacks discussion of open vocabulary grounding, referring expression comprehension and segmentation, video grounding, and tracking by detection, so the problem positioning and novelty are difficult to assess. -
The technical contribution is largely an engineering combination and the method is not sufficiently interpretable.
TempoGround combines cross frame correspondence, discrete presence states, 2D to 3D lifting, and GRPO with verifiable rewards, but each component is familiar and the paper does not isolate why this state aware design is necessary beyond a simple tracker or a 2D prior baseline. It is also unclear how the correspondence cue, presence states, and SGR rewards jointly affect the final prediction, so the mechanism level behavior remains hard to interpret. -
The empirical workload is thin and feels rushed.
The main evaluation uses only 24 test sequences per dataset and reports no multiple seed variance, confidence intervals, or compute matched comparisons, while SGR is trained on only about 4.1K trajectories for two epochs. Several baselines are not adapted to the causal streaming protocol and the paper lacks parameter matched or training budget matched controls, so the reported gains are difficult to attribute to the proposed framework. -
The evaluation protocol and metrics are not sufficiently justified.
The paper claims that presence and identity stability are central, yet the main tables report only F1D and AP3D without separate presence state, identity switch, or stream level diagnostics. The causal streaming protocol is described too briefly and the choice of 24 sequences plus limited referring samples raises concerns about statistical reliability and coverage of enter and exit events. -
The presentation is difficult to follow and key details are poorly organized.
The manuscript contains long line number blocks, inconsistent table and figure formatting, and several dense tables that are hard to parse. Important data filtering, annotation, and reward computation details are deferred to an appendix that is not self contained, and the writing has a template generated flavor with overclaimed phrasing, which makes the paper feel hastily prepared.
Questions for authors
see weakness.