- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3(+1)
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces SurgCast, a structured framework for surgical state-change forecasting that predicts how surgical activities evolve from an observed video window to a future window. The task involves predicting four states for each activity of continuity, discontinuity, onset, and background. They are defined according to whether the activity occurs in the observed and future windows. TransitionCast introduces a polar parameterization that decomposes a learned transition representation into magnitude and direction, which are intended to capture transition timing and semantic changes, respectively. A State Composer then integrates these predictions with current-state recognition evidence to construct four-state probabilities. StateRecast refines the predictions through residual logit corrections while keeping the first-stage model frozen. Experiments on CholecT50 and GraSP demonstrate competitive performance.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses an important problem in surgical video understanding by explicitly modeling how activities change between observed and future windows. The proposed State Composer is interesting and looks meaningful by incorporating both current-state recognition and temporal transition predictions into a probabilistic manner.
-
The framework operates on frozen visual foundation model features. It looks applicable to different pretrained representations without requiring backbone fine-tuning.
-
Additional experimental results verify the effect of proposed decompositiion from additional model capacity and residual refinement.
-
The analysis clarify how multiple transitions are handled.
Critical weaknesses
-
The experiments evaluated downstream four-state classification performance instead of directly measuring whether the learned representations successfully capture these distinct factors.
-
Several implementation details including the estimation of the orthogonal basis, computation of subspace allocation weights, certain loss coefficients, residual refinement configuration were missing in the intial version of the paper.
-
It was unclear whether the improvements originate from the intended temporal-semantic decomposition or from additional classification flexibility.
-
The improvement on two-branch design looks not significant.
-
Additional temporal analysis indicates the magnitude representation captures transition occurrence intensity and temporal ordering instead of localizing transition time (It might be better to reduce the claim of the paper according to this).
Questions for authors
- How can the authors demonstrate that the polar parameterization is essential to the improvements?
- How does the model handle multiple activity transitions within a single forecasting window?
- What motivates the different subspace aggregation strategies used during training and inference?
- How robust are the improvements across datasets and forecasting settings?
Sincerely Looking Forward to Your Feedback
Dear Reviewer pGok,
We have uploaded a revised version of the paper. Below we briefly point out where it addresses your three main concerns:
Thank you again for your time. If our responses and the revision have addressed your concerns, we would be grateful if you would consider updating your rating. If anything remains unclear, we would be happy to clarify it before the discussion period ends.