acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Functional and aetiological correspondences between natural and artificial intelligence

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

In this article, we present a descriptive framework for analysing natural and artificial intelligence across three dimensions: functional characterisation, developmental aetiology, and inference aetiology. We argue that, despite significant differences in implementation, both forms of intelligence exhibit functional comparability, understood as the capacity to map inputs to outputs through internally mediated transformations. At the same time, we identify fundamental aetiological differences. In terms of development, natural intelligence emerges from endogenous, evolutionarily shaped processes, whereas artificial systems are trained under explicitly defined optimisation regimes. In terms of inference, natural intelligence can be activated both exogenously and endogenously, while artificial systems remain predominantly dependent on externally triggered initiation mechanisms. The proposed framework integrates competing perspectives on the uniqueness of human cognition while preserving its functional analogy to artificial systems. By distinguishing between functional similarity and aetiological difference, it provides a principled basis for comparing natural and artificial intelligence without reducing one to the other.

Primary area:
other topics in machine learning (i.e., none of the above)
Keywords:
artificial intelligence, natural intelligence, functional similarity

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 1%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.00 over 3 reviews, above 0% of the others.
Reviewer_Hjj3OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a framework to compare natural and artificial intelligence across three dimensions, including functional characterization, developmental aetiology, and inference aetiology. From these dimensions, the paper claims to identify aetiological differences between natural and artificial intelligence, such as evolutionary vs. optimization, exogenous vs. endogenous, etc.

Critical strengths

The attempt of this paper that tries to distinguish natural and artificial intelligence is interesting and may trigger some rethinking of the current progress of AI, especially the recent development of foundation models, where many works claim that they have already achieved AGI. The three dimensions integrate many important debates and discussions around human and artificial intelligence from the past to the present.

Critical weaknesses

The novelty of the paper is not clear. First, the proposed three dimensions are not discussed or compared with any existing paper; therefore, it is unclear what is fundamentally new in this paper. Second, the detailed discussions in the three dimensions are also mainly reiterations of well-known knowledge, for example, the evolutionary development of human intelligence. Third, there are many other fundamental differences between natural and artificial intelligence; for example, the human brain is more often regarded as a dynamic system, while an LLM in many cases is static. Thus, it is unclear why the paper only discusses these three dimensions, or what specific perspective these dimensions form.

Questions for authors
  1. Why discuss these three dimensions, and what is fundamentally new? Do they together form a different architecture for differentiating natural and artificial intelligence?
  2. What is the root cause of the differences discussed in the paper?
Reviewer_6ex3OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a framework for comparing natural intelligence with human intelligence. The central idea is to go beyond the functional comparisons that are typically made into a three dimensional approach that also accounts for the system of intelligence development (named aetiological development) as well as inference (aetiological inference).

I enjoyed reading this paper. And it reflected some disparate thoughts I have had about the field. However, I don't think it is ready for publication yet; the treatment of the domain I find too shallow (the paper is very short and did take advantage of the full page limit to go in depth). Here are my main concerns:

  1. Main argument is obfuscated by unnecessary jargon: This paper is trying to address a timely and fundamental problem in modern AI research. The theme of such a paper (if done right) should be read by all the community. The use of the word Aetiological in the title and main text , I would say, acts as a turnoff. It is a word that is unknown, never really explained in the abstract and never defined. This word is entirely new to me and I still could not understand the relevance of its use in the entire paper. After reading, I looked up the definition on line. The only definitions I could find (Cambridge, Miriam Webster) all point to the study of causes of diseases. Aside from this, it seems that the British spelling of the word is used here as opposed to the potential American spelling (where the a is removed). To make this paper accessible to all, I would advise to use plain English and to use spellings that will maximise on global reach. Using keywords with different spellings could at least be helpful.

  2. Lack of Embedding with SoA": I am not an expert in this topic but have passing knowledge on some attempts to quantify intelligence. There is very limited discussion of the array of contemporary attempts to measure intelligence. I think the paper needs to discuss more extensively trends in existing literature, what they capture and not. Perhaps a table with a list of works and which ones cover what dimensions deemed important could provide a more compelling case. Here are just a few examples (non-exhaustive):

  • Open-Endedness is Essential for Artificial Superhuman Intelligence: https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04268
  • A. Zadeh, M. Chan, P. P. Liang, E. Tong and L. -P. Morency, "Social-IQ: A Question Answering Benchmark for Artificial Social Intelligence," 2019 IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR), Long Beach, CA, USA, 2019, pp. 8799-8809, doi: 10.1109/CVPR.2019.00901.
  • Beyond the Imitation Game: Quantifying and extrapolating the capabilities of language models: https://arxiv.org/abs/2206.04615
  • Spontaneous Theory of Mind for Artificial Intelligence https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1007/978-3-031-60405-8_5
  1. connection between different frameworks of intelligence measurement. The CHC framework looks interesting. So do the IBM topics. However, I missed a deeper discussion linking these back to the three dimensions mentioned. It seems they are operating on different levels of granularity. And neither are really sufficiently useful to capture functional intelligence let alone the others. So I am not really sure how to link this with the three dimensions.

  2. Argument that artificial systems do not develop in the same way as natural intelligent systems could have more depth. The argument about how AI systems develop differently from NI systems seems to suffer under a burden of proof issue. AI systems have been long trying to simulate natural processes, including how to develop under non pre-defined or fixed reward functions. This seems to be to be a claim on a moving target. And I am not sure why it is described in this way. I would have been more convinced if properties of development in NI systems could be put into a table against various families of AI system types. As it is, very few approach types are discussed. Some examples include: continual learning, curriculum learning, human-in-the-loop or hybrid intelligent systems, policy-dependent reward shaping, evolutionary algorithms, artificial swarm intelligence, multiagent systems, to name but a few.

5 Why do we want to compare the aetiological develop and inference?: Human behaviour is biologically governed by fundamental desires like procreation, a sense of belonging, need for safety, need for fat and sugar... these can lead to undesired outcomes for the same human in extreme environments (e.g. getting overweight from ultra processed food). I struggled to understand why we would want to compare artificial intelligence to these kinds of natural intelligence settings. e.g. are we wanting to compare humans that developed in a bad environment but maintained intelligence level compared to humans that developed in a good environment?

6 Computational models of human behaviour and cognition: I missed a discussion of other forms of computational models that could have some of the required properties for natural intelligence. e.g. there is the whole domain of cooperation games in social psychology (e.g. prisoner's dilemma, public goods game) which have been used to model emergent cooperative behaviour in humans. Evolutionary game theory is another popular one, and multiagent modelling. So computational models exist but their intended purpose can be quite different (e.g. being used to understand and model human behaviour and cognition). The boundary between computational models for social science and AI is starting to blend however, as more complex computational models are being used to model human cognition such as for example the wealth of works on artificial theory of mind. e.g. Machine Theory of Mind, Neil Rabinowitz, Frank Perbet, Francis Song, Chiyuan Zhang, S. M. Ali Eslami, Matthew Botvinick Proceedings of the 35th International Conference on Machine Learning, PMLR 80:4218-4227, 2018.

Critical strengths
  • This is an important topic to discuss how we can quantify artificial intelligence.
  • some literature is provided that provides the main waypoints for the narrative.
Critical weaknesses
  • the arguments, while interesting need more depth to be convincing as a useable framework
  • the use of the word aetiology doesn't align with its definition and none is given in the paper to make that point clearer.
  • link between CHC and IBM topics and the framework needs to be clearly and precisely specified
  • paper is too short to really showcase all aspects of relevant related work and show nuance in how they relate to the dimensions that are important for the various forms of intelligence proposed.
Questions for authors
  • what is aetiology according your paper?
  • How does CHC and the IBM Topics relate with the proposed framework? Is it related work or is it meant to embellish the framework?
  • how do different families of ML/ computational approaches fit into the framework discussed? The discussion seems mostly quite binary. Was that your intention to put across the idea that artificial systems can never capture any of the aetiological characteristics you mentioned?
Reviewer_zMGSOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The study compares natural and artificial intelligence across three dimensions: functional characterization, developmental aetiology, and inference aetiology. The authors argue that natural and artificial intelligence exhibit functional comparability, but they are fundamental different in developmental and inference aetiology. The study is purely theoretical/conceptual, without any experiments, code, or empirical verification.

Critical strengths

1.The paper is well organized and written. 2.The authors brings new perspectives in comparing natural and artificial intelligence.

Critical weaknesses

1.The proposed study is out of the scope of ICLR in my opinion. This work delivers some interesting perspectives, but contains no experiments, no code and no empirical verification.

Questions for authors

None.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.