- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies split computing (SC) in which a neural network is divided into two sub-networks to be executed by the edge device and the cloud server. An intermediate feature z is therefore computed by the edge sub-network and is sent to the cloud sub-network over a noisy link, modeled as a perturbation of z. The paper proposes Fragility-Aware Noise Training (FNT) to make the intermediate features robust. To this end, a lightweight ScoreNet finds the sensitive regions of z by mapping it to per-location scores, which are turned into local SNRs used for robust training. Specifically, during training, heteroscedastic Gaussian noise at these SNRs is added to z. The ScoreNet is later discarded at deployment. The pipeline is framed as a bio-inspired perception–transmission–cognition framework. The framework is evaluated on nine configurations and is compared with Vanilla training, COMSPLIT-style two-level noise training (COM), feature-space FGM, and an adapted DeepJSCC under AWGN. The reported mean gains over the strongest baseline are 8.75% (five-SNR average) and 36.27% (at −10 dB), and 10.75/28.19% in the cross-noise setting.
Critical strengths
- FNT changes only the training procedure and leaves no inference overhead in deployment time. At −10 dB AWGN, it almost maintains its clean accuracy in all nine configurations, while the strongest baseline at that SNR retains only 8% according to Table E.3. The advantage is also clear in packet erasure and colored noise on the two configurations tested based on Table E.2. The testbed covers CNNs and a vision–language transformer on natural, medical, and multimodal data.
- The appendix provides per-SNR means and standard deviations over 10 channel realizations for every method and configuration, baseline formulations and hyperparameters, sensitivity analyses, allocation statistics, and an intervention test. The authors also acknowledge that baselines are comparable or even better under mild noise.
Critical weaknesses
- The main baseline comparison does not study the contribution of fragility-aware noise allocation alone. Specifically, Appendix A states that FNT trains with local SNRs between -14 and -3 dB, while COM uses a two-level SNR schedule, FGM uses a fixed feature-space L2 radius of 0.1, and DeepJSCC uses a 10 dB training SNR with a 1/6 channel ratio. More importantly, FNT minimizes clean plus noisy loss (Equation (12)), while COM, FGM, and DeepJSCC objectives use noisy loss only. Even though the stronger-noise test in Table A.1 is useful, changing each baseline's perturbation strength separately is not considered a matched-budget, matched-loss comparison. Therefore, the large performance gaps cannot be attributed to learned fragility allocation in particular.
- The necessity of input-dependent fragility learning and its difference from existing adaptive feature-noise methods is unclear. For example, the "without ScoreNet" ablation uses a feature-magnitude-based substitute, instead of uniform, randomized, or fixed-mask allocations matched for total noise power. The corresponding results in Table E.4 reports very high cross-sample correlations between learned allocation maps. This means that it is possible that a largely static allocation could have caused much of the benefit. Even though Table E.5 supports the fragility ranking on one configuration, it does not report paired confidence intervals for the top-versus-random differences.
Questions for authors
- Can you report a controlled comparison in which a uniform/random-noise baseline uses FNT's sampled SNR range, matched expected perturbation power, and the same clean-plus-noisy loss, preferably on CIFAR-10 split6 and one larger task? I am curious to see how much of the reported gain remains in this case?
- Does FNT outperform a fixed dataset-average allocation map or a shuffled ScoreNet map when the local-SNR histogram and total noise budget are held constant? Can you also report a paired bootstrap interval for the top-10%-versus-random intervention in Table E.5? These results can clarify whether sample-specific learned fragility is necessary.
3 comments
Thank you for the additional experiments. While the rebuttal establishes a benefit over the tested controls, given the modest average gains on ImageNet and the remaining uncertainty about the added value of per-input allocation over a stronger static baseline, I will maintain my rating.
Clarification of FNT's robustness gains under severe noise and the additional benefits of per-input fragility-aware allocation over shared strategies.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for carefully considering our additional experiments, recognizing FNT's gains over the controlled baselines, and raising a valuable remaining question about stronger static allocation. We appreciate this constructive feedback and would like to clarify two points.
ImageNet performance. First, FNT targets robustness under severe channel noise, rather than maximizing the mean over five SNR levels. In Table 1 of the manuscript (ImageNet / ResNet50 / split3), FNT improves average AWGN accuracy over COM from 73.12% to 74.26% (+1.14 pp), but at dB the gain is much larger: 59.00% to 68.76% (+9.76 pp). Table E.1 further reports 89.23% vs 83.30% Top-5 accuracy at dB. Thus, averaging across SNRs understates the benefit in the severe-noise regime central to our work. Second, ImageNet-1K is a challenging 1,000-class benchmark, where 1–2 pp can be meaningful in context. For perspective, AutoAugment (Cubuk et al., CVPR 2019) reports a 0.4-pp ImageNet Top-1 gain, and RandAugment (Cubuk et al., NeurIPS 2020) reports 1.0 pp with EfficientNet-B7. These results are not directly comparable to FNT, but illustrate why gains on large-scale classification merit contextual evaluation. We will describe the dataset and provide a more detailed analysis of average versus low-SNR performance in the revision.
Per-input allocation. All results are in our anonymous repository. Table R8 (r8.pdf) matches training objectives and perturbation budgets for Uniform, Randomized, and FNT. On CIFAR-10, FNT gains +4.19/+3.54 pp in mean AWGN accuracy over Uniform/Randomized; on ImageNet, it gains +1.41/+1.75 pp on average and +3.88/+4.44 pp at dB. These controlled comparisons show that learned fragility-aware allocation matters beyond overall noise strength. Crucially, Table R9 (r9.pdf) tests two shared strategies that already reuse ScoreNet's task-loss-learned allocation patterns: Fixed-Sample Shared uses a fixed reference sample's map, while Batch-Shared assigns one sample's map to the rest of its training batch. Their retained robustness is itself consistent with FNT's central insight that learning where to allocate noise is useful; however, both break the correspondence between each input and its own fragility map. FNT exceeds the fixed and batch-shared controls by +1.97/+3.83 pp on average and +4.53/+8.76 pp at dB, respectively. Thus, per-input matching provides measurable benefits beyond learning a broadly useful shared pattern.
Mechanistic support and scope. Table R10 (r10.pdf) reports high cross-sample correlations (0.9012–0.9997) but only 55.39%–72.53% overlap among the Top-10% fragile locations, consistent with shared structure plus sample-specific differences. Table R11 (r11.pdf) provides paired bootstrap evidence that ScoreNet-ranked vulnerable locations are more sensitive than random locations (95% loss-difference CIs: at dB and at dB). Together, these results support per-input allocation over the evaluated shared strategies. We agree that a reference-sample map is not a fully optimized global static baseline, so we do not claim superiority over every possible static strategy. We will clarify these distinctions in the revision and consider broader datasets, models, and stronger static controls in future work. We thank the reviewer again for the thoughtful assessment.
Examines the contribution of fragility-aware allocation through uniform, random, fixed, and shared allocation controls, supported by paired statistical analysis, while acknowledging differences among the original baselines.
We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment of experimental controls and performance attribution, particularly the suggestions to match training objectives and noise budgets and to examine shared allocation maps. All supplementary results are available in our Anonymous Repository.
To address W1, W2, Q1, and Q2, we conduct three noise-allocation ablations: uniform, randomized, and fixed-mask allocation. W2 asks for more comprehensive ablations; W1 questions whether fragility-aware allocation itself explains the gains; Q1 requests matched-objective, matched-budget tests on two datasets; and Q2 asks whether sample-specific allocation outperforms fixed or shared maps.
W2 (allocation ablations). Uniform Allocation distributes noise evenly while matching FNT's expected total perturbation power. Randomized Allocation preserves each sample's local-SNR distribution but randomly permutes allocation locations. Fixed-Mask Allocation uses an allocation map generated from a fixed reference sample. Table R8 (r8.pdf) and Table R9 (r9.pdf) show that FNT achieves higher average AWGN accuracy than these controls, with larger gains under severe noise. The results support the contribution of learned fragility-aware allocation beyond the effect of noise strength alone.
W1 (isolating the contribution of allocation). By matching perturbation budgets or preserving local-SNR distributions while using the same training objective, we isolate the contribution of fragility-aware location selection. Table R8 shows that FNT still outperforms uniform and randomized allocation on both CIFAR-10 and ImageNet. Thus, its gains cannot be attributed solely to stronger training noise or the additional clean-loss term; learned allocation contributes independently.
Q1 (strictly controlled comparisons). Following the reviewer's request, we evaluate uniform and randomized allocation on CIFAR-10 and ImageNet, using FNT's training-SNR sampling range, Clean + Noisy Loss, and other training settings. In Table R8 (r8.pdf), FNT improves average AWGN accuracy over Uniform and Randomized Allocation by 4.19 and 3.54 percentage points (pp) on CIFAR-10, and 1.41 and 1.75 pp on ImageNet, respectively. At −10 dB on ImageNet, the corresponding gains are 3.88 and 4.44 pp. These results demonstrate that fragility-aware allocation provides additional robustness benefits under matched experimental conditions.
Q2 (sample specificity). Since Table E.4 shows high cross-sample correlations between allocation maps, we further compare FNT with fixed-mask and batch-shared allocation on ImageNet. Table R9 (r9.pdf) shows that FNT improves average AWGN accuracy over these two controls by 1.97 and 3.83 pp, respectively, with gains of 4.53 and 8.76 pp at −10 dB. Although allocation maps share a common structure, sample-specific learning captures useful differences that fixed or shared allocation does not fully exploit, particularly under severe noise.
We will incorporate these experiments and analyses into Sec. 4.3, Appendix A.1, and Appendix E.3, clarifying the independent contribution and sample specificity of FNT's allocation mechanism.
W1 (fairness of the original baselines). We acknowledge that COM, FGM, and DeepJSCC differ from FNT in training-noise strength, perturbation mechanisms, and loss functions. The original comparisons assess complete methods with their respective mechanisms, rather than strictly matched noise budgets and objectives. We therefore do not attribute the entire baseline gap to fragility-aware allocation; instead, the new controlled experiments isolate its contribution. We will clarify these comparisons in Appendix A.1.
W2 and Q2 (allocation consistency and paired statistics). Table R10 (r10.pdf) reports cross-sample correlations of 0.9012–0.9997, but only 55.39%–72.53% overlap among Top-10% fragile locations. Thus, substantial shared structure coexists with differences in the most fragile locations. To address the request for paired uncertainty in the original Table E.5, we use 256 images, 10 interventions per image, and 50,000 image-level paired bootstrap resamples. Table R11 (r11.pdf) reports 95% confidence intervals for the Top-10%-minus-random loss difference of [0.001799,0.028263] at 0 dB and [0.021137,0.075428] at −5 dB. Both intervals exclude zero, supporting ScoreNet's ability to identify more fragile feature locations. We will add these results and statistical details to Appendix E.3.
We again thank the reviewer for the constructive comments on fairness, allocation mechanisms, and sample specificity. We will incorporate the new experiments and statistical analyses to improve the rigor and clarity of the revised manuscript.