- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies object-centric emotional image generation. It constructs Obj-EmoSet, which augments affective images with object categories and paired basic and emotion-aware descriptions, and proposes a framework comprising an Emotion-Aware Visual Planner, a Visual Realism Refiner, and an Emotion Calibration Adapter to translate target emotions into object-related visual conditions. Validation includes image-level and segmented object-level comparisons, module ablations, and a user study, reporting improved emotional alignment and favorable human preferences over the evaluated baselines.
Critical strengths
The problem has practical significance. Emotional image generators may rely on background atmosphere or implausible object deformation to convey emotions. Achieving emotional control while preserving object semantics and visual plausibility is a valuable and challenging research direction.
Critical weaknesses
W1: The ablation results do not support the necessity of the complete three-module framework. In Table 4, the Planner-only configuration matches the full model in Emo-A and performs better in EC-A, semantic consistency, and generation quality. Moreover, adding Cali worsens MLLM-P and Style. These results do not support the claim that the three modules jointly achieve a better balance between emotional expression and realism. The authors should verify the results, report variability across runs, and clarify the consistent benefits contributed by the Refiner and Adapter.
W2: The validity of object-level emotional supervision remains unclear. Obj-EmoSet augments image-level affective data with object categories and textual descriptions. However, an image-level emotion label cannot be attributed to every object in the image, as the emotion we perceive can also arise from people, background, or events. The data construction procedure does not sufficiently explain how the association between the target object and emotion is verified, and the authors need to demonstrate that the dataset provides valid object-level emotional supervision.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses.