- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes HeRPO, a hindsight-based framework for step-level credit assignment in long-horizon agentic RL. The method introduces three components: hindsight-pruned grouping to refine step-level comparisons, adaptive GAE based on effective group support, and hindsight self-reweighting to adjust policy updates. Experiments on several agentic benchmarks demonstrate improvements over existing RL methods.
Critical strengths
-
Strong empirical performance. The proposed method achieves consistent improvements over competitive baselines across multiple agentic benchmarks.
-
Reasonable motivation. The paper identifies meaningful limitations in existing step-level credit assignment methods and proposes a systematic framework to address them.
Critical weaknesses
-
Concerns about the reliability of hindsight-based credit assignment. The proposed group filtering removes comparisons between identical actions with different realized futures. However, differences in future observations may arise from environmental stochasticity rather than the actions themselves. For example, in GUI environments, opening the same webpage may lead to different observations due to dynamic advertisements or other external factors. The proposed filtering strategy does not appear to distinguish such environmental variations from action-induced differences, potentially limiting its reliability and generalizability.
-
Limited methodological novelty. Compared with existing step-level credit assignment methods, the proposed framework primarily refines grouping, advantage estimation, and the weighting of policy updates. In particular, HSR appears conceptually related to hindsight-conditioned policy evaluation approaches such as OPSD. The paper does not sufficiently establish the fundamental differences or advantages of its proposed mechanism over related approaches, making the overall methodological contribution somewhat incremental.
Questions for authors
-
Environmental stochasticity in hindsight-pruned grouping. How does the proposed grouping strategy distinguish action-induced differences from environmental stochasticity? For example, in GUI environments, identical actions may produce different observations due to dynamic webpage content. Would such variations cause potentially useful comparisons to be incorrectly removed?
-
Relationship between HSR and OPSD. HSR evaluates executed actions with and without hindsight information and uses the resulting likelihood difference to adjust policy updates. This appears conceptually related to OPSD-style policy distillation. Could the authors clarify the key differences and provide evidence that the proposed preference shift is a reliable indicator of action quality?
-
Methodological novelty. Compared with existing methods such as GiGPO, GraphGPO, and HCAPO, the main modifications appear to involve more refined grouping and advantage weighting. What is the fundamental methodological contribution beyond these refinements?
-
Role and definition of hindsight. The paper emphasizes hindsight as a central contribution. However, existing RL methods with verifiable rewards also retrospectively assign credit based on realized outcomes. What fundamentally distinguishes the proposed hindsight mechanism from conventional outcome-based credit assignment? A clearer conceptual distinction would strengthen the motivation.
4 comments
Response to Reviewer mHQb (Part II)
W2&Q3: Methodological novelty.
Thank you for the opportunity to clarify the novelty. While GiGPO uses state-aligned groups, GraphGPO estimates credit through state-transition graphs, and HCAPO uses hindsight self-scoring to construct step advantages, HeRPO integrates adaptive GAE into critic-free, group-based agentic RL, using group-derived values to propagate credit across action steps. It also uses realized futures as privileged information to refine action comparisons, adapt temporal credit propagation, and calibrate advantage magnitude.
Specifically, HPG removes comparison links between samples that share the same state and action but have inconsistent hindsight. Differences in their subsequent returns may reflect later decisions or environmental variation rather than a difference in the current action. Eq. (4) estimates values from the retained reward returns. AGAE uses these group-derived values to estimate advantage and adjusts its coefficient adaptively according to the effective support of each retained group. Limited support favors longer-horizon Monta Carlo returns, while broader support favors local TD estimates. HSR measures how the realized future changes the old policy's preference for the executed action and converts that shift into a bounded weight on the advantage. This calibrates update magnitude without changing the update direction.
The ablations support the contribution of each component. AGAE yields the largest gains on both overall metrics (ALFWorld: 86.7% → 93.0%; WebShop success: 65.0% → 74.2%), and combining all three components reaches 95.8% and 80.7%, respectively (Table 3). HSR also improves the overall metrics of GRPO, GiGPO, and GraphGPO on both benchmarks (Table 4), supporting its extensibility beyond HeRPO. We will revise the introduction to state these contributions and distinctions more clearly.
Q4: Role and definition of hindsight.
We appreciate the request to define hindsight and explain its role in HeRPO. In HeRPO, hindsight refers to privileged future information available after an action is executed, including the terminal outcome, the immediate next observation, and up to subsequent action–observation pairs (see Eq. 2 and Appendix B.2). Unlike conventional outcome-based RL, where the terminal reward provides a scalar trajectory-level signal for advantage estimation and determines the policy update direction, HeRPO leverages hindsight for two complementary purposes: (1) refining group-based advantage estimation through HPG, and (2) adaptively modulating update magnitudes for distinct actions through HSR. Hindsight does not introduce an additional reward signal or independently determine the policy update direction, it insteadly enables more precise step-level credit assignment.
Thank you for the detailed rebuttal and additional experiments. I appreciate the authors' efforts to address my concerns, particularly the clarification of the HPG mechanism and the additional comparison with OPSD.
However, I believe some of my main concerns remain only partially addressed. First, while the noise-tolerant HPG variant helps mitigate observation noise, the reliability of using realized futures to determine valid action comparisons remains insufficiently established, particularly in environments with complex stochastic transitions and subsequent decisions. Second, although the authors clarify the differences between HSR and OPSD, the connection between hindsight-induced preference shifts and actual action quality remains largely heuristic.
More importantly, I remain concerned about the methodological novelty. The rebuttal mainly clarifies the motivations and roles of the three proposed components, but does not sufficiently demonstrate a fundamental methodological distinction from existing approaches to step-level credit assignment and hindsight-based learning.
Overall, I acknowledge the additional empirical evidence and clarifications, but these do not fully resolve my concerns regarding the reliability and novelty of the proposed approach. Therefore, I maintain my original score of 2 (Weak Reject).
Thank you for your follow-up. We further address the remaining concerns below.
HPG reliability.
HPG starts from state-aligned action groups, following the grouping principle validated in GiGPO. Realized futures are then used only to prune links between samples with the same state and action but inconsistent hindsight. Policy improvement in reinforcement learning relies on distinguishing the values of different actions within the same state, rather than attributing differences in subsequent outcomes to identical actions taken in that state. Moreover, in our statistics, the specific noise-induced false-pruning cases affected only approximately 0.1% of all samples. In Table 3, HPG also improves both benchmarks in the component ablation.
Interpretation of HSR.
The reward-derived advantage determines whether an action is reinforced or penalized. Hindsight only scales that advantage through a action-level weight bounded in [0.8,1.2]. HSR improves GRPO, GiGPO, and GraphGPO on both benchmarks (Table 4).
Methodological novelty.
The main novelty lies in AGAE and HSR. AGAE brings GAE-style advantage propagation mechanism into critic-free group-based agentic RL. The state-aligned action groups provide value estimates at intermediate actions, creating local TD signals that propagate forward to earlier actions rather than relying only on a terminal-outcome advantage. The propagation coefficient is also designed to adapt to each action group's effective support.
HSR uses hindsight differently from other hindsight-based learning approaches, such as token-level self-distillation. The advantage computed on reward returns determines whether an action is reinforced or penalized. The hindsight-induced preference shift supplies only a bounded weight on that action's update. HSR therefore keeps the per-action update sign anchored to task feedback while adjusting its magnitude.
Response to Reviewer mHQb (Part I)
Thank you for the detailed review. We appreciate your recognition of the empirical results and agree that the paper needs a clearer description of hindsight reliability and its relationship to prior hindsight-conditioned learning. Below, we provide a detailed, point-by-point response to each listed weakness and question. For clarity, "W" denotes a numbered Critical Weakness and "Q" denotes a numbered Question for Authors from your review. When a weakness and a question address the same issue, we combine their labels (e.g., "W1&Q1").
W1&Q1: HPG reliability.
Thank you for this valuable concern. We agree that a change in observation does not necessarily reflect a different effect of the current action. HPG focuses step-level credit assignment on comparisons between different actions taken at the same state. For samples with the same state and action, it removes their comparison link when their realized hindsight differs, since a difference in return may arise from later decisions or environmental variation and should not be attributed to a difference in the current action.
When the outcome or subsequent actions genuinely differ, the sample links should be pruned regardless of observation noise. The potential for false pruning arises when two such samples have the same hindsight but superficial noise exists. In our experimental analysis, samples sharing the same state, action, and hindsight account for only approximately 0.1% of all samples due to randomness. Considering the diversity of real environments and potential noise issues, we constructed a noise-tolerant HPG variant that compares key hindsight fields, including the outcome reward and subsequent actions, separately, while applying a similarity threshold of 0.95 to environmental observations. In the evaluated mild-noise cases, the variant reduced the false-pruning rate to 0% and preserved the original pruning decisions for other pairs.
Our HPG estimates a group value from the retained samples' reward returns, and AGAE uses that value to compute step-level advantages. In the ablation study, adding HPG improves ALFWorld overall success from 86.7% to 90.6% and WebShop success from 65.0% to 70.6% (Table 3). We will elaborate the design rationale of HPG in the revised manuscript.
Q2: Relationship to OPSD.
Thank you for highlighting this connection. While both OPSD and HSR leverage privileged hindsight information to reassess a policy's own sampled outputs, they differ fundamentally in how hindsight guides policy optimization. OPSD directly distills the privileged teacher's distribution into the student through token-level distillation gradients. In contrast, HSR quantifies the impact of hindsight by aggregating the old policy's log-likelihood differences with and without hindsight over an executed action (Eq. 9). This signal is then transformed into a detached, bounded weight that adaptively scales the action's original advantage (Eqs. 10–11). Crucially, HSR introduces no additional distillation objective and preserves the sign of the original advantage, modulating the strength of advantage-based policy updates rather than modifying the optimization direction.
To further substantiate this distinction, we evaluated GiGPO+OPSD under the same GiGPO training setting. GiGPO+OPSD achieved 87.5±1.3% on ALFWorld and 63.4±2.9% on WebShop, compared with 89.1±1.1% and 68.0±2.1% for GiGPO+HSR, respectively. These results highlight two key methodological differences. (1) HSR operates at the executed-action level, aligning hindsight feedback with the granularity of agent decisions, whereas OPSD's token-level distillation can produce heterogeneous guidance across tokens within the same action. (2) Optimization alignment: OPSD's distillation gradients may conflict with advantage-based policy gradients, while HSR applies bounded, positive reweighting directly to the advantages, preserving their optimization directions. Together, these distinctions explain how HSR integrates hindsight information more effectively into advantage-based policy optimization for agentic tasks. The consistent improvements across both benchmarks further demonstrate the effectiveness of action-level granularity and direction-preserving reweighting. We will incorporate the GiGPO+OPSD results and clarify these distinctions in the revised manuscript.