- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes DuplexBridge, a framework that coordinates the understanding and generation capabilities of unified multimodal models for complex image editing. It introduces a structured bridge that explicitly specifies editing targets, required changes, and preservation constraints, enabling separate supervision of task understanding and editing execution. The framework further employs bidirectional trust gates to selectively route global task rewards to the understanding and generation components while retaining their respective local supervision. Experiments across three unified models demonstrate substantial improvements in complete editing compliance and performance on multiple image editing benchmarks.
Critical strengths
-
The paper identifies a meaningful challenge in complex image editing: distinguishing failures in task understanding from failures in editing execution. The motivation is clearly presented, and the separation of these two responsibilities provides an intuitive perspective on understanding–generation coordination.
-
The paper evaluates DuplexBridge across three unified multimodal models and several image editing benchmarks, demonstrating substantial improvements in overall editing performance. The inclusion of component ablations and human evaluations further strengthens the empirical evaluation.
Critical weaknesses
-
Execution Trust relies on the average execution score, which may allow critical editing requirements to be overlooked. For example, if 8 out of 9 requirements are satisfied and one fails, the gate may still pass if the threshold is below the resulting average score, even when the failed requirement corresponds to the most critical editing operation.
-
DuplexBridge's main contributions lie in its training supervision and feedback routing design, rather than in a fundamentally new model architecture or optimization algorithm. The novelty of the proposed method relative to prior works such as DARS[1] and DDA-Thinker[2] should be more clearly articulated.
-
DuplexBridge aims to ensure that complex image editing tasks simultaneously achieve accurate edits and content preservation. However, Appendix M shows that its performance gains become smaller when a task involves a large number of requirements, and some editing capabilities even deteriorate. This suggests that, although the gating mechanism may improve the overall complete compliance rate on certain complex tasks, it does not consistently improve every aspect of editing performance and may even compromise some editing capabilities.
[1] DARS: Dual-Level Credit Assignment RL with Structured Reasoning for Instruction-Based Image Editing
[2] DDA-Thinker: Decoupled Dual-Atomic Reinforcement Learning for Reasoning-Driven Image Editing
Questions for authors
When both gates pass but the final edited image still fails to satisfy the task, the global reward may provide negative feedback to both U and G. However, the current gating mechanism cannot further distinguish the responsibility for such failures. Please see the Weaknesses section for the remaining concerns.
5 comments
Response to Reviewer C4KF (Part 2/2)
W2. Distinction from DARS and DDA-Thinker
We appreciate this request. Our novelty lies in role-local supervision references and global-feedback eligibility when jointly adapting a unified model's native U/G roles, not a new backbone or GRPO optimizer (General Response, Table C1).
Research setting. DDA-Thinker [2] and DARS [1] use separate Thinker–Editor and Planner–Renderer components, respectively. DuplexBridge uses the unified model's own understanding and generation roles through native prompt enhancement (PE), without an external planner.
Optimization direction. DDA-Thinker freezes its editor and optimizes the thinker with Cognitive/Visual Atomic Rewards. DARS and DuplexBridge both optimize planning/understanding and generation, but differ in how feedback is assigned.
Credit assignment and global-feedback use. DARS estimates relative planner/renderer update weights from between-plan and within-plan reward variability, alongside planner prefix gating. DuplexBridge instead evaluates original-task U-local and received-condition G-local against different references, then uses reciprocal Partner Trust to determine eligibility for additional global losses. It reuses local checks without an additional variance-attribution estimator, retaining valid local losses when global feedback is withheld. Accordingly, DARS primarily weights module updates using reward variability, whereas DuplexBridge decides when task-level feedback is sufficiently grounded to update each native role. We do not claim that structured planning, modular rewards, or gating are themselves new.
Controlled evidence (General Response, Table C2). Across three seeds on Wan-Image-7B, Full exceeds DARS-style Routing by 3.39 pp (95% CI: [2.06, 4.72] pp), Original-task G-local by 2.19 pp, Ungated Joint RL by 6.64 pp, and Group-matched Random Gate by 4.97 pp. In the matched Wan-Image setup, DARS-style Routing requires 1,227 GPU-hours to convergence, versus 416 GPU-hours for DuplexBridge (−66.1%). This is a mechanism transplant, not a reproduction of DARS's native complete system; we do not attribute the entire cost gap to variance estimation alone. We will make these differences and their controlled evidence more explicit in the revision.
W3. High Requirement Load and Editing Evaluation
Requirement load is not equivalent to task complexity, and component-wise all-pass metrics differ from Complete Compliance Rate (CCR).
In Appendix M, requirement load is defined as , the total number of change and preservation requirement groups that must jointly hold. Larger means more obligations, not necessarily more editing operations, nor does it capture target grounding, visual reasoning, operation dependencies, or scene relations. Category composition also differs across strata. Thus is not a direct measure of overall difficulty.
Change All-pass and Preservation All-pass diagnose which requirement type is satisfied; CCR requires both to pass for the same task. Completing every requested change while damaging protected source content is not a successful edit. Hence the two component metrics help diagnose errors, while CCR directly measures the paper's primary objective: complete instruction compliance.
The original Appendix M, Tables 31–32, reports both component and joint outcomes. Across all 1,200 tasks, Full versus Ungated improves Change All-pass from 80.42% to 83.50%, Preservation All-pass from 76.75% to 81.25%, and CCR from 70.92% to 77.08% (+6.17 pp). For the 180 tasks with , Change All-pass declines from 73.33% to 60.56%, whereas Preservation All-pass and CCR increase from 49.44% to 52.78% (+3.33 pp CCR point estimate). While individual diagnostic metrics may fluctuate under extreme loads, the central goal is joint satisfaction of changes and preservation, not monotonic gains in each marginal measure. We will clarify these definitions and transparently report this load-specific behavior in the revision.
We thank the reviewer for these constructive concerns. The critical-failure analysis, stricter-gate ablations, and three-seed controls further support the proposed supervision and feedback design. Human CCR evaluation on all three backbones also favors Full over Ungated (General Response, Table C6).
References
[1] Cao et al. DARS: Dual-Level Credit Assignment RL with Structured Reasoning for Instruction-Based Image Editing. 2026.
[2] Yang et al. DDA-Thinker: Decoupled Dual-Atomic Reinforcement Learning for Reasoning-Driven Image Editing. 2026.
Revision Update for Reviewer C4KF
We thank the reviewer for highlighting the limitations of mean-based execution trust, the need to distinguish DuplexBridge from prior credit-assignment methods, and the challenges of high-requirement-load editing. We have revised the manuscript to address these concerns through additional analysis and controlled experiments.
First, Section 6.3 (pp. 8–9) and Appendix S.2 (Tables 40–42) now provide a human analysis of 200 deliberately selected mean-gate-accepted training rollouts and compare alternative execution gates. Five annotators achieved 93.5% unanimous critical-requirement agreement, while the automatic selector obtained 61.7% micro-F1 and 34.0% exact-set agreement. The new main-text Table 4 shows that Mean Gate achieves 77.08% CCR, compared with 74.33% for Rubric Critical Hard Gate and 68.92% for All-pass Gate. These experiments demonstrate the empirical tradeoff between filtering unreliable feedback and retaining learning signals.
Second, Section 2 and Appendix O.2 (Table 38) clarify that, unlike DARS's variance-based module weighting, DuplexBridge combines original-task U-local supervision, received-condition G-local supervision, and reciprocal global-feedback eligibility. Section 6.2 (Table 3) adds three-seed comparisons supporting this distinction.
Third, we explicitly report the high-load results in Section 6.3 and Table 4. At , the CCR difference interval includes zero, while Change All-pass declines from 73.33% to 60.56%. We do not claim uniform improvement across all editing requirements.
Regarding the question of ambiguous failures when both gates pass, Sections 4.3–4.4 and Appendix E.4 clarify that Partner Trust selects eligible global feedback; it does not uniquely identify counterfactual responsibility for every failure. The revised Limitations (Appendix R) further discusses improving task-critical requirement identification.
We hope these revisions make both the contribution and the empirical boundaries of the method clearer.
Response to Reviewer C4KF (Part 1/2)
We thank the reviewer for recognizing our motivation and results across unified models. We address the concerns using new critical-requirement diagnoses, stricter-gate ablations, and three-seed experiments summarized in our General Response.
W1 & Q1. Execution Trust Reliability and Bidirectional Credit Assignment
We agree that mean Execution Trust does not guarantee that every critical requirement is met, and that passing both Partner Trust gates does not establish unique causal responsibility for a final failure. DuplexBridge instead separates role-local supervision and selectively admits global task feedback; the mean score is neither task success nor a causal responsibility label.
(1) Distinct supervision references. U-local evaluates prompt fidelity of the predicted condition C^ against the original task (X,u) without viewing the edited image. G-local evaluates execution fidelity and local quality against the condition actually received by G, (X,C^), rather than the original instruction. The global reward assesses task fulfillment, preservation, and visual quality under (X,u), using fixed reference edits. Prompt Trust controls G-global eligibility; Execution Trust controls U-global eligibility. Neither gate disables independently valid local supervision. Thus, mean Execution Trust screens cross-role feedback for reliable execution evidence; it does not determine complete task success.
(2) Empirical evidence on mean gating and critical failures. In the original Appendix H, Table 25, applying selectors to the same 6,000 frozen rollouts reduces the unexecuted-prompt error rate among U-global-eligible samples from 27.41% to 4.60%, while retaining 64.80% U-global coverage. This directly measures error prevalence in selected feedback, not recall over all critical failures.
To probe the reviewer's "8 of 9 requirements pass" example, we additionally annotated 200 challenging training rollouts that passed the Mean Gate despite at least one failed execution-check group (General Response, Tables C3–C4). Five human annotators achieved 93.5% unanimous agreement on critical-requirement sets. The automatic rubric selector achieved 61.7% requirement-level micro-F1 and 34.0% exact-set match. Only 8/200 (4.0%) of these selected, mean-gate-accepted cases exhibited a human-confirmed critical failure. A failed requirement group therefore need not imply a failed critical edit. Co-occurring execution errors could lower mean scores, but these accepted-only cases cannot establish the overall rejection rate of critical failures.
An additional Rubric Critical Hard Gate rejected 68/200 of these cases; only 3 had human-confirmed critical failures. Critical-failure rates among rejected and retained cases were 4.4% and 3.8%, respectively. The added gate thus excluded many candidates without confirmed critical failures and showed limited selectivity.
We also trained two stricter alternatives (General Response, Table C5): Mean + Rubric Critical Hard Gate requires both the mean threshold and all selected critical checks; All-pass Gate requires every execution group to pass. Their CE-Bench CCRs were 74.33% and 68.92%, respectively, versus 77.08% for Mean Gate and 70.92% for Ungated Joint RL. Thus, stricter eligibility does not necessarily improve joint learning. Mean Execution Trust offers a more favorable observed trade-off between removing unreliable global feedback and retaining useful learning signals.
(3) What if both gates pass but the final task fails? Passing both gates means that global losses are eligible, not that the edit succeeds or that U and G receive an identical failure attribution. As specified in Section 4.4 and Appendices E.4–E.5: (i) U-local and G-local remain distinct, task- and received-condition-based objectives; (ii) U-local, U-global, G-local, and G-global normalize group-relative advantages on separate eligible sets. The global RM provides continuous relative preference scores, not binary success labels, so a low absolute score need not yield the same negative advantage for both roles; and (iii) updates alternate, freezing G during U updates and U during G updates. Thus, the roles follow distinct sampling groups, losses, and gradients.
This reduces unreliable cross-role updates without claiming counterfactual causal attribution. Imperfect automatic checks can leave residual ambiguity; the goal is an empirically effective conditional-feedback objective, consistent with Appendix E.4. We will clarify this scope and the separate optimization mechanisms in the revision.