- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This work studies spatial–dynamic interference in current VLMs, where post-training for static 3D and dynamic 4D reasoning can degrade the other capabilities. To address this issue, this paper introduces DynThinker, a framework for jointly enhancing 3D static and 4D dynamic spatial reasoning by Decoupled Exponential Moving Average (D-EMA) and Spatial-Dynamic Fusion (SDF). D-EMA maintains averaged weights for pretrained parameter groups with configurable averaging horizons, while excluding newly introduced modules from averaging. SDF integrates spatial and temporal features through importance-guided gating. Trained on approximately 2.68 million samples comprising 3D spatial reasoning, 4D temporal reasoning, and general video reasoning data, DynThinker achieves an average score of 60.5 across the evaluated static and dynamic reasoning metrics, outperforming the compared baselines.
Critical strengths
-
The paper is well motivated and clearly written. It investigates an important limitation of existing 3D and 4D specialized VLMs: improving spatial/dynamic reasoning capability can come at the expense of the other. These findings motivate preserving pretrained capabilities while learning complementary spatial and dynamic knowledge with D-EMA and SDF.
-
The proposed components are simple and effective for unified spatial reasoning. SDF integrates spatial and temporal features through importance-gated addition and residual injection, and D-EMA supports capability preservation through configurable group-wise temporal averaging. Combined with training on a mixture of static spatial and dynamic reasoning data, DynThinker achieves strong performance across 3D and 4D reasoning benchmarks.
Critical weaknesses
- Component ablations under the main training regime. Tables 3 and Table 10 provide useful component ablations and data scaling, but these experiments do not use the 2.68M-sample, 32-frame configuration underlying the main results. Given the substantial benefits of large-scale 3D spatial and 4D dynamic training data, it is better to evaluate the contributions of D-EMA and SDF under the main training regime.
Questions for authors
Please see the weaknesses above.
3 comments
Reply
Thank you to the authors for the reply. Most of my concerns are addressed. I recommend that the authors incorporate these experiments into the final version, and I maintain my positive score.
Thank You for Your Positive Assessment
We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment and continued support. We are glad that the additional experiments address most of your concerns. Following your suggestion, we will incorporate these experiments into the final version. We appreciate your constructive feedback, which has helped strengthen our paper.
Reply to Reviewer H8Vv
We thank the reviewer for the positive and constructive feedback. We appreciate your recognition of our motivation, the effectiveness of D-EMA and SDF, and DynThinker's strong performance across static 3D and dynamic 4D benchmarks. To address your concern, we provide additional component ablations under the full training regime.
We conduct component ablations under identical training settings (2.68M samples, 32 frames), evaluating the contribution of D-EMA and SDF separately. As shown in Table A, removing D-EMA or SDF individually lowers the ten-metric average from 60.3 to 59.4 and 57.2, respectively.
Table A. Ablations under the main Qwen3-VL-8B training regime.
Removing D-EMA reduces VLM4D by 5.6, DSI-S by 5.6, and DSI-G by 6.7 points. SDF contributes to both static and dynamic reasoning, with its removal reducing MindCube by 9.3, MMSI by 3.7, DSI-S by 7.7, and DSI-G by 12.5 points.
Overall, the full model achieves the highest average, supporting the complementary contributions of D-EMA and SDF under the full training regime. We have added these results to Appendix D.2 (highlighted in red).
Thank you again for your positive assessment of our work and for suggesting this comparison. We hope the new ablations address your concern, and we would be happy to clarify any remaining questions.