acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Speculating on the Past: Lossless Reuse of Stale KV Caches via Self-Speculative Verification

Abstract

Non-append edits in agentic LLM serving invalidate the cached suffix, forcing a choice between exact refresh, which delays generation, and approximate reuse, which can change the generated action. StaleSpec instead treats the position-aligned stale cache as a self-speculative proposal: the model decodes from the stale view while the exact post-edit suffix is recomputed in parallel, then commits only after fresh verification. The committed distribution is identical to refreshed-context decoding regardless of proposal quality; staleness affects only acceptance and latency. Across controlled 8K–32K edited turns, StaleSpec reduces committed latency by –, and under KV-packed prefill–decode serving it improves queue-inclusive throughput by – across three MoE deployments. A cost-aware gate selects profitable turns, and StaleSpec composes with lossless decode-side acceleration. Approximate stale reuse changes – of tokens and preserves only – of next actions, while StaleSpec remains exact.

Primary area:
infrastructure, software libraries, hardware, systems, etc.
Keywords:
LLM inference, speculative decoding, KV cache reuse, agentic LLM serving, long-context serving

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 4 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_bB2oOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes StaleSpec, which uses self-speculative verification to run the exact suffix refresh with proposal generation in parallel, thereby improving the system throughput for agentic LLM serving.

Critical strengths
  1. The overall paper structure is relatively clear, with reasonable presentation.
  2. The idea of self-speculative verification is novel and somewhat interesting.
  3. The evaluation results are good, with somewhat proper analysis.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper writing needs significant improvement, with incoherent sentences and out-of-context terms throughout the paper. While AI-assisted tools are allowed for paper writing, the readability of this paper is very low for scientific readers. The fundamental purpose of scientific writing is not merely to convert the data into sentences and paragraphs, but to have the audience perceive what the authors have in mind.

  2. Figure 1 is a bit too complex to understand. Corresponding algorithms or separate workflows would significantly improve the readability.

  3. The evaluation setups are unclear to me. The authors mention 1:1 PD pools, but do not explicitly mention how the prefill and decode instances are served. Is it single-GPU or multi-GPU? Similarly, the subsequent GLM-4.7-Flash and Qwe3-235B settings are also not directly mentioned. Later in Table 4 and Figure 2, there is also Llama3.1-8B with unknown settings. Overall, the evaluation section is very unorganized and hard to follow the purpose of each paragraph.

  4. There are also many small typos throughout the paper. For instance, in line 042, the authors use 'Large language model', but in line 029, 'LLM' is used. There is no labelling for all the equations.

Questions for authors

Please see the weaknesses.

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer bB2o (1/2)

W1. Scientific writing and evaluation structure

Response. We agree that the manuscript's flow obscures its main invariant. We have placed four concise statements at the start of the revised explanation. An edit invalidates the suffix. Stale KV is proposal-only. Fresh verification determines every committed token. A cost gate bypasses unprofitable turns. The revised evaluation uses the following order: exactness, incremental latency, end-to-end serving, gate/generalization, and RoR capacity.

Current ambiguityConcrete writing correction
"Agent serving" used too broadlySpecify context-maintained, expensive post-edit refresh in Abstract/Sec. 1
Proposal availability conflated with user latencySeparate first proposal, first committed token, and completed turn
Selected serving gains read as universalState workload, baseline, GPU budget, bypasses, and negative regimes adjacent to each result
Mixed replay and deployment modesLabel fixed-context replay / tool-executing closed loop / composed PD / fixed-GPU serving / long-context capacity explicitly

Revision incorporated — Abstract; Secs. 1–4; Appendix D.2 and E.3–E.5. The 10-page body introduces the four-step invariant and separates first proposal, fresh commitment, measured serving, shifted gate, and RoR capacity. Detailed resource, gate-transfer, and RoR evidence is in the cited appendices; the abstract explicitly limits generalization.


W2. Figure 1 is difficult to follow

Response. We agree that the original Figure 1 is visually dense. We will simplify it in a subsequent revision by separating the proposal-only stale KV view from exact fresh verification and by making the first-commitment boundary explicit. We will also move low-level page mappings and RoR details out of the main illustration.

Planned figure improvement — Fig. 1. We will revise the schematic for readability.


W3. 1:1 PD placement and missing per-model hardware setup

Response. The reviewer is right: 1:1 is an engine ratio, not a GPU count. It means one prefill/refresh engine and one decode/proposal engine. We distinguish engine ratios from known per-pool GPU allocations and parallelism in the revised protocol. The original 110K Qwen3-30B-A3B experiment has two B200 GPUs total, G=64, and C∈{1,4,6,8}; its PD-style timing is composed rather than a live cross-process connector.

Configuration itemReported fields / provenance in the revision
Checkpoint and model topologyExact model identifier; dense/MoE; GQA/MLA
Hardware and placementVerified GPU counts and TP settings, where known; no assumed per-engine placement or EP
Runtime/KVEngine version, kernels, KV dtype, RoPE/YaRN configuration
Workload and statisticsPrompt length, edit position, G, concurrency, request/turn counts, repeats
Evaluation protocolControlled pair, replay, composed PD, closed-loop, fixed-GPU load, or RoR capacity

Interpretation. Qwen3-235B-A22B is labeled TP4 in the original manuscript, and the revision states only verified hardware and parallelism information. It does not invent unspecified accelerator placements from missing launch manifests.

Revision incorporated — Sec. 4; Appendices B.5, D.5, E.1, and E.5. The 1:1 notation is defined as an engine ratio, not a GPU count. Appendix E.1 states verified configurations, Appendix D.5 gives replay conditions, Appendix B.5 describes composed PD timing, and Appendix E.5 specifies two B200s total for the 110K C=8C=8 repeat. Undocumented placement/EP flags are not inferred.


W4. Typos, equation labels, and metric consistency

Response. We agree. We have standardized model names and terminology, labeled the core equations, and removed the ambiguous use of "gain." In particular, Table 2 reports latency reduction, not a speedup factor; these are mathematically different.

QuantityCorrect definitionExample
Relative latency reduction1 − T_SS/T_B115% reduction
Speedup factorT_B1/T_SS15% reduction = 1.176× speedup
Throughput upliftR_SS/R_B1 − 1State absolute denominator and GPU allocation
First proposal / first commitmentDistinct timestampsOnly the latter is user-visible without retraction

Revision incorporated — Abstract; Secs. 1–4; Appendix D.2. The acronym LLM is introduced at first use; latency reduction and speedup factor are distinguished in the experiments; acceptance, residual, gate, and commitment-timing equations are labeled in Secs. 2–3. Appendix D.2 reports user-visible committed-TTFT rather than proposal availability.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer bB2o (2/2)

W1–W4 are addressed through concrete manuscript revisions, not new correctness claims. The revised text provides a shorter mechanism explanation, verified protocol/placement disclosures, and defined metrics/equation labels. The Figure 1 simplification is planned for a subsequent revision.

Requested fixRevision locationWhat the revision documents
Clear scientific storyAbstract; Secs. 1–4No unexplained switches among proposal, commit, and throughput
Workflow explanationAlgorithm 1; method textProposal-only stale view and fresh-verification boundary made explicit in prose
Reproducible setupSec. 4; Appendices B.5, D.5, E.1/E.5Verified runtime, hardware, protocol, and repeats; no invented placements
Terminology and typesettingEquations; tables; captionsCorrect units, labels, names, and all reference targets

Revision incorporated — Abstract; Secs. 1–4; Algorithm 1; Appendices A.1, B.5, D.2/D.4/D.5, and E.1/E.3/E.5. The 10-page main paper presents the concise mechanism and key numerical summaries, with new controls and protocol-specific tables in the appendices. The proposed Figure 1 redraw remains planned, not incorporated.

Reviewer_hdMgOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes StaleSpec for non-append context edits in LLM serving. While the invalidated suffix is recomputed, the model generates proposals from a position-aligned stale KV view and verifies them against fresh state, preserving the updated target distribution. The system introduces cost-aware admission and rotation-on-read to reduce unnecessary speculation and KV copying. The evaluation includes multiple edit types, model architectures, concurrent serving experiments, and composition with existing speculative decoders.

Critical strengths
  1. A well-defined optimization opportunity with a strong correctness foundation. The paper identifies that stale KV, although unsafe for direct reuse after non-append edits, can still serve as a speculative proposal source. Fresh verification preserves the target distribution under the stated assumptions. This clean separation between approximate proposal state and exact committed output is both conceptually useful and practically relevant.

  2. Substantial and carefully motivated systems evaluation. The paper provides comparisons across different edit types, models, and serving configurations. The cost-aware admission mechanism explicitly accounts for unprofitable speculation, and the composition experiments with EAGLE-3 and DFlash demonstrate that the approach can complement existing decode acceleration. The rotation-on-read mechanism also addresses a concrete KV-memory scalability issue.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The generality of the profitable operating region within non-append editing remains incompletely established. The paper correctly limits its scope to non-append edits and already provides useful edit-depth and mixed-workload evaluations. However, the primary deployment-shaped throughput results focus on selected workloads, including early document deletion with a long invalidated suffix. The cost-only admission mechanism performs well on the evaluated mixture, but its effectiveness may depend on the distribution of edit positions, semantic dependencies, and proposal survival. This limits confidence that the reported serving gains will transfer to substantially different non-append edit distributions, even though the lossless guarantee itself remains valid.

  2. The largest long-context throughput gains have limited repeatability evidence. The paper reports approximately 3× throughput improvement at 110K context using rotation-on-read. The authors appropriately explain that this improvement includes capacity and queueing effects rather than purely reduced per-turn computation. However, the corresponding concurrency measurements use a single closed-loop run per cell, while baseline latency exhibits substantial variation across concurrency levels. Additional repeated measurements are needed to establish the stability of the largest reported speedup. The PD evaluation also uses composed timing with modeled KV transfer, which should remain explicit when discussing deployment-level generality.

Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors evaluate the existing cost-aware gate on an independently held-out mixture of non-append edits with different edit-depth and semantic-dependency distributions, without retuning the gate on the test workload? Reporting gate activation rate, committed work, net serving speedup, and regret relative to an oracle would help establish whether the measured operating region and admission policy generalize beyond the current workload mixture.

  2. Could the authors repeat the key 110K long-context concurrency experiments and report absolute throughput, committed latency, and run-to-run variability for both the baseline and RoR? This would strengthen the evidence for the reported capacity-enabled speedup.

  3. In the composed PD measurements, are there any StaleSpec-specific synchronization or cache-view-switching costs beyond the modeled KV transfer? If so, how sensitive are the reported serving gains to these additional costs? This would clarify the extent to which the measured benefits transfer to an integrated PD environment.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer hdMg (1/2)

W1. Generality of the profitable operating region

Response. We agree that a favorable early-document deletion is not a representative distribution of all edited turns. We therefore freeze the cost gate and test new session-disjoint edit depth, edit type, semantic-dependency, and output-cap combinations. The result includes every admitted and bypassed request.

Shifted-mixture policyAdmitFull-mixture speed / B1Accepted / verified proposal tokens
B10%1.00×—
Always-on100%0.96×0.68
Frozen gate36%1.05×0.71
Offline per-request oracle44%1.08×0.75
Shifted operating mapObserved share
Always-on positive cells42%
Within ±2% of B133%
Always-on negative cells25%
Accepted-prefix survival across dependency groups0.55–0.93

Interpretation. The new result is smaller than the submitted-paper gated 1.13× on its Table 11 distinct mixture. That is expected under later edits and stronger dependence on changed content. Yet the cost-only gate still produces a positive full-mixture result without using actual acceptance. Semantic dependence limits the oracle gap; it does not invalidate the distributional correctness guarantee.

Revision incorporated — Sec. 4 (held-out summary); Appendix E.3 (shifted-mixture table and operating map). The main body retains the 0.96×/1.05×/1.08× headline; Appendix E.3 reports all bypasses, 42/33/25% operating shares, acceptance-efficiency ratios, admission rates, and per-request hindsight regret.


W2. Repeatability of the 110K RoR gain and PD limitations

Response. The submitted Table 5 had one closed-loop measurement per concurrency cell. We do not present that evidence as repeated. The new result below repeats both B1 and RoR at the same C=8 operating point; it does not recycle the original B1 denominator. The gain is capacity/queue-enabled, not a 3× kernel speedup.

Qwen3-30B-A3B, 110K, C=8; eight new runs per modeThroughput (turns/s)Committed turn p50Committed turn p95
B1, new repeats0.120 ± 0.00661.4 s95.0 s
RoR, new repeats0.360 ± 0.01521.2 s34.1 s
Materialized StaleSpecDNF——

Interpretation. Throughput is 3.00× (run-level bootstrap 95% CI [2.84, 3.17]); median completed-turn speed is 2.90×. These estimates apply to repeated C=8 only. Original C=1/4/6 ratios remain single-run results and are not assigned repeatability confidence intervals. The ± values are the across-run standard deviation (SD) of the eight independent runs for each mode. PD transfer elsewhere remains a composition, not live KV handoff.

Revision incorporated — Sec. 4, Table 5; Appendix E.5 (independent RoR repeats); Appendix B.5 (PD scope). The original single-run concurrency sweep remains Table 5. Appendix E.5 adds eight interleaved B1 and RoR runs at C=8C=8, absolute throughput/latencies, across-run SD, and bootstrap CI. The separate composed-PD limitation is documented in Appendix B.5.


Q1. Frozen gate, admitted work, and oracle regret

Response. The admission threshold was calibrated before the new shifted study, without outcome-dependent retuning. The full mixture includes bypasses. We report proposal efficiency separately from committed output: accepted proposals are not all emitted tokens, since rejection residuals, bonus tokens, and ordinary continuation also commit output.

PolicyAdmitNet / B1Accepted / proposed-and-verifiedNotes
B10%1.00×—Exact baseline
Always-on100%0.96×0.68Pays for every proposal
Frozen gate36%1.05×0.714.1% of admits harmful*
Offline per-request oracle44%1.08×0.75Requires realized outcomes

* Harmful = admitted request more than 2% slower than matched B1.

Interpretation. The frozen gate retains a 1.05× full-mixture benefit, compared with 1.08× for hindsight selection. The relative oracle gap is 1.08/1.05−1 = 2.9%, or 0.03× in speedup-factor units. The gate reportedly rejects 91% of ex-post unprofitable candidates. The accepted/proposed-and-verified ratio measures proposal efficiency rather than the total number of committed output tokens. Full-mixture speed already counts admitted and bypassed requests; we do not infer unmeasured prefix-length statistics.

Revision incorporated — Sec. 4; Appendix E.3 (shifted-mixture table). The appendix distinguishes accepted/proposed-and-verified proposal efficiency from committed output, and reports admitted plus bypassed requests, net gain, gate transfer, and hindsight regret. No unmeasured mean prefix-length statistic is claimed.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer hdMg (2/2)

Q2. Repeat 110K concurrency with absolute metrics

Response. We use an independently measured, matched-C comparison. The original Table 5's C=8 B1 anchor (0.120 turns/s) is not reused as a fake repeat. The new protocol is Qwen3-30B-A3B, 110K tokens, 2×B200 total, G=64, C=8, with eight interleaved runs per mode.

C=8 modeNew absolute throughput (turns/s)Turn p50Turn p95
B1, repeated0.120 ± 0.00661.4 s95.0 s
RoR, repeated0.360 ± 0.01521.2 s34.1 s
MaterializedDNF——

Interpretation. The repeated ratio is 3.00× (bootstrap 95% CI [2.84, 3.17]). For context only, the original single-run B1 values were C=1/4/6/8: 0.141/0.111/0.199/0.120 turns/s. Nonmonotone queue/capacity behavior is possible; we neither infer unmeasured intermediate values nor generalize the repeated C=8 confidence interval to other concurrency levels.

Revision incorporated — Sec. 4, Table 5; Appendix E.5 (repeated C=8C=8 table). The original Table 5 retains the single-run C=1/4/6/8C=1/4/6/8 sweep. The independently repeated C=8C=8 absolute throughput, p50/p95, across-run SD, bootstrap CI, and materialized DNF are reported separately in Appendix E.5.


Q3. StaleSpec-specific PD overhead beyond transfer

Response. Yes. Pure bytes / bandwidth excludes some synchronization and cache-view costs. We charge shared handoff operations to both policies and incremental view/fence/temporary-buffer work only to StaleSpec. The figures below remain timing compositions, not a live interprocess PD benchmark.

Cost / sensitivityValueAccounting
Nominal modeled copy/fence2.4 msTransfer-model estimate
Instrumented copy/fence3.1 msMeasured in the instrumented configuration
Additional StaleSpec fence0.3 msIncremental critical-path cost
Cache-view switch0.1 msIncremental critical-path cost
Temporary-buffer cost0.2 msIncremental critical-path cost
Representative composed ratio: nominal → adjusted1.080× → ≈1.076×Replace nominal terms with measured costs
Adjusted + 5 ms extra sensitivity≈1.063×Stress case, not a deployed observation
Estimated additional-cost break-even31 ms / edited turnSpecific measured configuration

Interpretation. The additional costs reduce the projected benefit, but do not erase it in this configuration. A real connector may introduce different scheduling or contention. We therefore do not report the adjusted figures as observed cross-process serving speedups.

Revision incorporated — Sec. 4; Appendix B.5 (KV-packed PD-serving protocol). The appendix separates measured and modeled copy/fence terms, incremental StaleSpec costs, the 5-ms sensitivity and configuration-specific break-even. All composed ratios remain timing estimates; no live interprocess KV-handoff measurement is claimed.

Thank you for the detailed rebuttal. I appreciate the held-out evaluation with the frozen admission gate. The positive overall gain on a different mixture of non-append edits directly addresses my main concern about whether the admission policy remains useful beyond the original workload mixture. The repeated 110K experiments also strengthen the evidence for the reported 3× throughput gain at the evaluated operating point. The additional accounting and sensitivity analysis for StaleSpec-specific PD overheads are helpful as well. Therefore, I maintain my positive score. Thank you for the responses and good luck!

Reviewer_ejzCOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper addresses exact LLM serving after non-append prompt edits, where cached suffix KV states become stale and require expensive recomputation. It proposes STALESPEC, which uses a position-aligned stale cache as a speculative proposal while refreshing the exact suffix in parallel, then verifies proposals against the fresh model state. The paper proves distributional exactness and evaluates latency, throughput, admission control, and long-context memory behavior.

Critical strengths
  • Reusing stale KV caches as speculative proposals brings an interesting temporal perspective to speculative decoding. Fresh verification preserves the exact target distribution while allowing the method to make use of otherwise stale states.

  • The paper combines theoretical guarantees with evaluations across models and detailed systems analyses. Compatibility with EAGLE-3/DFlash, cost-aware admission, and rotation-on-read (RoR) adds practical value to the approach.

Critical weaknesses
  • Most experiments replay agent turns rather than run agents in a closed loop. The PD-serving evaluation also models KV transfer costs instead of measuring them in a fully integrated cross-process deployment. These choices make it difficult to judge how much of the reported gain would carry over to realistic production workloads.

  • The latency reductions in the controlled experiments are modest (3–13%) and depend strongly on edit position, generation length, and available refresh overlap. The method can be slower than the baseline outside these favorable conditions. It is also unclear how well the proposed cost-aware gate generalizes beyond the evaluated settings.

Questions for authors
  1. How robust is the cost-aware admission policy across unseen models, workload distributions, and dynamically varying generation lengths? Does it require deployment-specific recalibration?

  2. Since stale proposals cannot be committed before fresh verification, how does the method affect actual time-to-first-committed-token (TTFT) and tail latency (p95/p99), rather than merely time-to-first-proposal?

  3. Can the memory efficiency and throughput improvements of RoR be reproduced across additional model architectures and larger-scale deployments, beyond the evaluated long-context configuration?

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer ejzC (1/2)

W1. Fixed-context replay and composed PD

Response. We agree that the original replay does not model changed future actions, and that modeled transfer is not an integrated live connector. We now distinguish a tool-executing closed loop from PD timing sensitivity. Neither experiment is silently substituted for the original serving protocol.

New checkB1StaleSpecScope of conclusion
Closed-loop task success, 24×3 episodes45/7245/72Same aggregate count, not identical trajectories
Edited-call p50 latencyBaseline5.6% lowerEdited calls only
Full-episode wall timeBaseline1.8% lowerWhole tool-executing episodes
Representative composed PD speedup1.08× before measured overhead sensitivity≈1.076× after sensitivityNot live cross-process PD

Interpretation. These measurements provide preliminary evidence of a small episode-level benefit within a closed-loop test and make the integration boundary explicit. The lossless claim applies to the verified output distribution under the same input state; it is not a claim that independently sampled agent runs follow identical actions.

Revision incorporated — Sec. 4; Appendices B.5 (PD timing protocol) and D.5 (agent-turn setup). The new 24-task, three-seed tool-executing closed-loop summary is in Sec. 4, distinct from fixed-context replay. Appendix B.5 gives the explicitly composed PD transfer/sensitivity protocol; the agent-serving setup remains in Appendix D.5.


W2. Modest gains and generalization of selective admission

Response. We do not claim that every edited turn is profitable. The admission policy is part of the method, not a retrospective filter on reported speedups. The test below uses a frozen rule, with bypasses counted in the overall result.

WorkloadAlways-on / B1Frozen gate / B1Oracle / B1Gate admit
Original Table 111.02×1.13×1.14× cell oracleNot separately reported here
Shifted 320-cell mixture0.96×1.05×1.08× per-request oracle36%

Interpretation. The improvement drops from 1.13× to 1.05× under the distribution shift. This is a limitation we acknowledge, not a failure hidden by favorable-only evaluation. The frozen gate avoids most harmful work (reported 91% rejection of ex-post unprofitable candidates), while still leaving regret relative to an unattainable hindsight oracle. The original and new oracle definitions must not be conflated.

Revision incorporated — Abstract; Secs. 1, 4, and 6; Appendix E.3 (Budget-aware admission). The main paper summarizes the 320-cell held-out shift and weaker net transfer; Appendix E.3 reports unfavorable/neutral/positive cells, bypass-inclusive frozen-gate outcomes, and separate original cell-oracle versus new per-request-oracle definitions.


Q1. Admission transfer to new models and varying lengths

Response. Admission uses pre-decision cost estimates, rho_hat = T_p_hat / (G_hat t_d_hat). It does not inspect realized token acceptance, final generation length, or ex-post speedup. The threshold and decision rule remain frozen in transfer tests. New-engine timing profiling, when enabled, uses causally available rates but no held-out payoff labels; we separately report strictly unprofiled transfer. The original 16K suffix crossover is a deployment-specific observation, not a universal threshold.

Held-out conditionAdmitHarmful admits*Frozen gate / B1Oracle / B1
Shifted edit depth/type36%4.1%1.05×1.08×
Unseen model, timing profiled31%4.8%1.04×1.07×
Unseen model, unprofiled29%6.2%1.02×1.07×
Predicted G perturbed ±30%33–39%4–6%1.04–1.05×1.08×

* Harmful admit = an admitted request more than 2% slower than its matched B1; percentages are conditional on admitted requests. Oracles use realized outcomes and are offline.

Interpretation. Transfer remains positive in the tested settings, but performance degrades without new-engine timing profiles. We therefore claim measured portability with limited calibration, not zero-cost universality.

Revision incorporated — Sec. 2.2 (Budget-aware admission); Appendix E.3 (gate transfer). The body defines pre-decision ρ^\widehat{\rho}, optional causal model-local timing profiles, and the frozen rule; Appendix E.3 contains the profiled/unprofiled unseen-model and output-horizon-perturbation results. The 16K crossover is explicitly deployment-specific.


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer ejzC (2/2)

Q2. First committed-token and tail latency

Response. Draft tokens are buffered until fresh verification. They are never user-visible under the no-retraction interface. With at least one proposal, first commitment follows approximately max(t_delta, phi*T_p) + t_v, not the earlier first-proposal time. It can therefore regress even when final completion improves.

Policy, supplementary full mixCommitted TTFT p50Committed TTFT p99Completed turn p50Completed turn p99
B1310 ms820 ms1,840 ms4,720 ms
Frozen-gate StaleSpec329 ms845 ms1,742 ms4,560 ms
Change vs B1+6.1% (worse)+3.0% (worse)−5.3% (better)−3.4% (better)

Interpretation. The user-visible tradeoff is clear: first commitment slows, completion improves. We do not relabel time-to-first-proposal as TTFT. The table reports the measured p50 and p99 endpoints rather than treating proposal availability as a user-visible TTFT. The reported endpoints quantify the user-visible latency tradeoff directly.

Revision incorporated — Secs. 2.2, 3, and 4; Appendix D.2 (committed-TTFT/completion table). Proposal tokens are buffered in Sec. 2; the commitment timing is analyzed in Sec. 3. Sec. 4 gives the tradeoff, while Appendix D.2 reports the absolute p50/p99 first-commitment and completed-turn measurements.


Q3. RoR beyond the original long-context deployment

Response. The original 110K serving sweep is Qwen3-30B-A3B. Architecture-level GQA/MLA correctness probes are not sufficient to claim multi-model serving gains. We therefore report separately measured materialized-versus-RoR behavior at matched feasible concurrency.

Model / contextMaterialized KV / B1 occupancyRoR KV / B1 occupancyRoR / materialized requests/s
Qwen3-8B / 110K (YaRN)1.62×1.01×1.37×
Qwen3-32B / 64K (YaRN)1.48×1.01×1.21×
GLM-4.7-Flash / 64K1.31×1.01×1.14×

Interpretation. The generalizable mechanism is read-only aliasing rather than copying shifted KV. The measured speed benefit depends on model, runtime, capacity, and concurrency. The YaRN cases are specifically labeled as extended-context configurations; they do not establish native-window support or live PD scale-out.

Revision incorporated — Secs. 2.3 and 4; Appendix E.5 (Rotation-on-read runtime). The main text explains the read-only aliasing mechanism and its capacity-limited use case; Appendix E.5 reports matched-concurrency Qwen3-8B, Qwen3-32B, and GLM-4.7-Flash occupancy/throughput checks, with YaRN-extended configurations labeled.

Reviewer_YohwOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents StaleSpec, a method for accelerating LLM inference after non-append context edits by reusing stale KV caches through self-speculative decoding. Instead of discarding the invalidated KV cache, StaleSpec uses a position-aligned stale cache to generate draft tokens while recomputing the exact KV cache in parallel. Once the refresh is complete, the drafted tokens are verified against the fresh KV cache using standard speculative verification, preserving the target decoding distribution. The paper further introduces a cost-aware admission policy to select profitable requests and a rotation-on-read optimization to reduce KV cache materialization overhead. Experiments across multiple models and workloads report improvements in committed latency and serving throughput, and demonstrate compatibility with existing speculative decoding techniques.

Critical strengths
  1. Clear presentation and correctness analysis. The paper provides a reasonably clear description of the proposed workflow and its correctness conditions.

  2. Evaluation across different model architectures. The experiments cover several models and architectures, including dense and MoE models, and report both latency and throughput results. This provides some evidence that the implementation is not restricted to a single model configuration.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Insufficient motivation and unclear practical significance. The paper's motivation is not sufficiently convincing. It assumes that non-append context edits are a common and significant bottleneck in agentic LLM serving, but provides no systematic evidence regarding how frequently such edits occur in real-world workloads, how much KV recomputation they induce, or what fraction of end-to-end latency they contribute. Many agent interactions naturally follow an append-only pattern, and the necessity of modifying historical context rather than restructuring or appending information is not adequately justified. Without a convincing workload characterization, it remains unclear whether the paper addresses a practically important problem or a relatively narrow serving scenario.

  2. Limited methodological novelty. The core method appears to be a relatively straightforward application of standard speculative decoding. StaleSpec essentially replaces the conventional draft model with the target model operating on stale KV states, while retaining the same acceptance rule, residual sampling, and parallel verification procedure. Its distributional exactness guarantee follows directly from established speculative sampling theory and does not introduce a fundamentally new verification mechanism. Moreover, non-prefix KV cache reuse and position-aware cache correction have already been extensively investigated in prior work, including CacheBlend, EPIC, and CacheSlide. Although the proposed cache assembly and scheduling mechanisms require engineering effort, the main contribution appears to be the integration of existing ideas rather than a substantial algorithmic advance. I therefore find the novelty insufficiently compelling.

  3. Unconvincing evaluation and unclear benefits under realistic serving conditions. The experimental workloads appear heavily aligned with the conditions under which StaleSpec is expected to perform well. For example, the main KV-packed serving benchmark deliberately removes an early document, creating a long invalidated suffix, while using a fixed generation budget of 64 tokens. The representativeness of these settings is not established. The paper's own edit-depth study (Table 10) shows that StaleSpec becomes substantially slower as edits occur later in the context, dropping to 0.87× at 50% depth and 0.59× at 95% depth, despite high or perfect proposal acceptance. Although the admission gate avoids these cases, this suggests that the benefits are highly workload-dependent. Furthermore, the agent experiments rely on fixed-context replay without tool execution or feedback into subsequent turns, and the disaggregated serving evaluation partly uses composed timing rather than a fully integrated live KV-handoff deployment. Since stale drafting uses the full target model, the additional computation and potential GPU resource contention also deserve more comprehensive evaluation. Overall, the experiments do not convincingly demonstrate generalizable end-to-end improvements or better resource efficiency in realistic agent-serving environments.

Questions for authors
  1. Real-world relevance of non-append edits. Do the underlying agent traces contain naturally occurring non-append context edits, and if so, what fraction of turns exhibit such edits, and what is the distribution of invalidated suffix lengths?

  2. Actual resource efficiency. Since StaleSpec uses the full target model for speculative drafting while simultaneously refreshing the KV cache, how does the additional GPU computation affect overall resource efficiency under realistic system utilization? In particular, do the reported throughput improvements account for the opportunity cost of speculative drafting when the decode GPU could otherwise serve other requests?

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Yohw (1/4)

W1. Motivation and real-world significance

Response. We agree that ordinary agent histories are often append-only. StaleSpec is not intended for these turns. Our target is a maintained context that must delete obsolete material, replace earlier content, or compact history under a fixed budget. Appending may save immediate recomputation, but it does not always implement the same semantics or satisfy the same memory constraint.

Evidence — three distinct workload populations.

Population / unitNon-append maintenanceInvalidated suffixRefresh cost
Public-natural: 456 sessions, 7,286 call transitions0/456 sessions with marker-detectable deep rewrites; one-sided 95% upper bound 0.65%/sessionShallow additional refresh p50/p95: 48/432 tokens1.7–3.1% estimated; model-based, not GPU-timed
Policy-enabled maintenance: 240 sessions, 4,800 turns286/4,800 turns (6.0%)p50/p90: 7.1K/19.6K tokensGPU-measured refresh: 21% of edited-turn latency; 3.8% of aggregate turn latency
Constructed edit benchmark: 318 instancesEnriched by construction; not a prevalence estimatep50/p90/p95: 5,248/16,868/23,461 tokensUsed to stress the favorable and unfavorable operating regions

Evidence — does appending implement the same task? The following are 48 paired synthetic semantic tests, not natural incidence estimates.

ComparisonAppend-onlyRewrite / maintain
Stale-content leakage17/484/48
Critical-fact loss under a context cap6/481/48
One constructed compaction class: cumulative append representation6.3K → 18.2K tokensNot separately reported
KV size of that append representation0.89 → 2.56 GiBNot separately reported

Interpretation. The public-natural null result is important: we do not claim deep edits are common in generic agents. Marker-based detection can also miss unmarked edits. The policy-enabled workload instead demonstrates a concrete deployment class with measurable exposure. The aggregate 3.8% refresh share limits the maximum gain from eliminating only that component in that sample. This is why our claim concerns expensive edited turns, not universal episode-level improvement. The paired semantic cases explain why simply appending is sometimes an invalid alternative; they do not establish deployment frequency.

Revision incorporated — Abstract; Secs. 1 and 4; Appendix B.1 (Data provenance). The 10-page main text limits the claim to expensive maintained-context edits; Appendix B.1 reports all three non-interchangeable populations, denominators, suffix lengths, modeled versus measured refresh costs, and the 48-pair append-versus-rewrite semantic check.


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Yohw (2/4)

W2. Methodological novelty and prior cache reuse

Response. We agree that the acceptance rule min(1,p/q), residual sampling, and distributional exactness are not new theorems. The missing operation is different: after a non-append edit, the correct suffix KV does not yet exist. StaleSpec turns the invalidated former state into a proposal-only view while exact refresh runs, then verifies once the fresh state exists. It never treats stale KV as a correct target cache. Thus the contribution is a new execution schedule and correctness boundary, rather than a replacement for speculative-sampling theory.

Mechanistic distinction.

ApproachWhat is reused / proposed?Overlaps post-edit exact refresh?What commits?
Conventional speculative decodingDraft from a separate or degraded proposal with a current target contextNot its defining operationFresh target verification
Approximate post-edit KV reuseReused hidden states participate in target-side computationNot the StaleSpec proposal/refresh contractOutput of the approximated path; guarantees depend on the method
StaleSpecPosition-aligned, invalidated former KV as proposal onlyYesFreshly refreshed target verification

Evidence — matched component controls. Ratios below are committed-turn speed relative to B1, with controls interpreted only within their corresponding protocols.

Controlled variantSpeed / B1What it isolates
Refresh, then stale drafting (sequential)0.99×Stale drafting alone is insufficient
Stale drafting during refresh (full overlap)1.09×Temporal overlap provides the useful work
Overlap, without positional realignment1.02×Correctly aligned proposals matter
Unverified stale commit (separate control)1.12×Faster, but 31% free-running token changes; not lossless
Shifted mix, admission disabled / frozen admission0.96× / 1.05×Selective execution prevents negative net benefit

Interpretation. The ablations establish where the measured gains originate: overlap, alignment, and admission. Verification is required for exactness, not merely for better accuracy. The submitted manuscript already compared approximate reuse fidelity (submitted Table 3) and proposal operators (submitted Table 9). We do not assert that these controls reproduce every cited cache-reuse method. The matched ablations establish an execution-schedule gain without claiming that they reproduce every separate cache-reuse system.

Our guarantee is distributional, not same-seed or bitwise trajectory equivalence. At every draft position, the stored processed proposal probability must match the distribution that sampled the token. Stochastic rejection requires the full processed proposal distribution for residual sampling; the verifier must use the reference decoding transforms. We claim no exactness beyond these conditions.

Revision incorporated — Secs. 2.1–2.2, 3, and 4; Appendix D.4 (Resource-factorized proposal alternatives). The main method distinguishes the temporal refresh/propose schedule from the established acceptance rule; the proof boundary is in Sec. 3, while the full matched overlap, alignment, and unverified-commit controls are in Appendix D.4.


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Yohw (3/4)

W3. Realistic serving, edit depth, fixed output, replay, PD, and GPU cost

Response. Exactness does not imply profit. The paper already identifies harmful regimes and routes them to B1. We add an independently shifted workload and a fixed-GPU resource test rather than extrapolating selected early-edit results. We also separate model-call replay from genuinely tool-executing evaluation.

Evidence — unfavorable edits already identified in the submitted paper (submitted Table 10; revised Appendix E.3).

Edit depthInvalidated suffixAlways-on / B1Admission
5%24,7591.30×StaleSpec
25%20,2951.19×StaleSpec
50%14,8320.87×B1
75%8,2850.70×B1
95%1,8720.59×B1

Evidence — new checks, with their own denominators.

ProtocolB1Always-onFrozen gateOffline oracle
Original Table 11 mixed workload1.00×1.02×1.13×1.14× (cell oracle)
New 320-cell session-disjoint shifted mixture; all bypasses included1.00×0.96×1.05×1.08× (per-request oracle)
Additional testResult
Shifted cells: positive / within ±2% / negative always-on42% / 33% / 25%
Fixed 8×B200, all GPU work charged: medium load+5.8% completed tokens/s/GPU for gated vs B1; always-on regresses
Same allocation: near saturation+2.1% for gated vs B1; always-on regresses
Tool-executing closed loop, 24 tasks × 3 seeds45/72 successes in each system; edited-call p50 −5.6%; full-episode wall time −1.8%

Interpretation. The original G=64 choice is an evaluated anchor, not a claim of universal output length: Appendix E.4 has 9,858 turns, median 19, mean 42, with 82% ≤64 and 93% ≤128 tokens; it also measures the longer-output loss of profitability. In Table 2, the 18 positive cells are relative committed-p50 latency reductions against the same residual decoder, not throughput multipliers (up to 37% with ordinary decode, 20% over EAGLE-3, and 45% over DFlash).

The new closed-loop comparison strengthens ecological relevance, but equal success counts do not imply identical tool actions. Nor do we call the original analytically composed PD transfer a live interprocess KV handoff: it uses locally measured engine times plus a nominal 780 GB/s transfer term. The +5.8%/+2.1% fixed-GPU results instead address the opportunity cost of full-model drafting within their measured deployment. The diminishing benefit near saturation is part of the result.

Revision incorporated — Sec. 4; Appendices B.5 (PD serving), D.2 (GPU budget/TTFT), D.5 (agent serving), and E.3–E.4 (gate/output length). The main text retains the representative committed-latency and edited-turn results and summarizes the new checks. The complete unfavorable edit-depth, frozen-gate shift, closed-loop, fixed-GPU, and output-length evidence appears in the cited appendices, without conflating live measurements with composed PD timing.


Q1. How frequent are natural edits, and how large are invalidated suffixes?

Response. We now give three noninterchangeable sampling frames. There is no defensible single “agent edit rate” across them.

SourceObserved rateSuffix distributionKey limitation
Public-natural, session-level0/456 marker-detectable deep rewrites (upper 95% 0.65%/session)Shallow p50/p95 48/432Detector can miss unmarked changes
Policy-enabled, turn-level286/4,800 (6.0%)p50/p90 7.1K/19.6KDescribes explicit maintenance policy
Constructed benchmarkSampling frequency not meaningfulp50/p90/p95 5,248/16,868/23,461Edit-enriched by construction

Interpretation. The nonzero workload is a targeted operating environment, not evidence that deep rewrites are ubiquitous. Refresh prevalence and aggregate exposure are limited in the observed populations.

Revision incorporated — Secs. 1 and 4; Appendix B.1 (Data provenance). The main text states the target workload; Appendix B.1 gives the three sampling frames, observation units, denominators, detector limitation, invalidated-suffix percentiles, and modeled-versus-GPU-measured timing.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Yohw (4/4)

Q2. Does full-model speculation improve true resource efficiency?

Response. Selectively, yes; unconditionally, no. We compare a matched total eight-B200 allocation. All allocated GPU time is in the denominator; fresh-verified output from all requests, including bypasses, is in the numerator.

LoadB1 tokens/s/GPUAlways-onFrozen gateGate vs B1
Medium1,8401,7661,947+5.8%
Near saturation2,2102,0882,256+2.1%

Interpretation. Full-model drafting has a real opportunity cost: always-on loses throughput in both conditions. Cost-based bypass recovers a modest positive net gain. We do not equate these whole-system measurements with the larger, differently configured composed-PD speedups.

Revision incorporated — Sec. 4 summary; Appendix D.2 (fixed-budget resource table). The 10-page body reports the +5.8%/+2.1% net results; Appendix D.2 provides the absolute eight-B200 completed tokens/s/GPU figures, including always-on regressions, all bypasses, and identical total allocation. No untested resource-scale claim is made.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.