- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents a new method solving the problem that semi-supervised approaches' ability are constrained by static unlabeled datasets and financial and time cost of human labeling, by introducing a generative model improves together with th MLLM.
Critical strengths
The experiments are sufficient to prove that their methods outperform standard supervised and semi-supervised models; The problem they bring out and try to solve is very valuable because the co-evolution paradigm does not need dense human labeling and still achieves fully supervised results. Further, this paradiam may inspire other tasks constrained by labeling.
Critical weaknesses
None
Questions for authors
Do we need to change the critic model when the input video topic changes, during the inferences? Why is the perfomance on several topics significantly lower than the previous SOTA models?
Author Response
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the positive evaluation and the insightful comments. The reviewer's sharp and constructive feedback clearly reflects deep expertise in the problem addressed in this manuscript. We are glad that you recognized the value of our co-evolution paradigm in circumventing dense human labeling.
Below, we address the two questions raised by the reviewer:
Response to Questions for Clarification: Question 1: "Do we need to change the critic model when the input video topic changes, during the inferences?"
Response: Yes. Following common practice in previous WSVHD studies, a critic model is trained for a particular topic or domain. This is consistent with previous WSVHD literature, where models are typically adapted or evaluated per domain/topic.
Question 2: "Why is the performance on several topics significantly lower than the previous SOTA models?"
Response: There are two primary reasons for this performance variation across specific topics:
Uniform Hyperparameters without Overfitting: We opted to use the exact same hyperparameters across all datasets and did not conduct heavy, specialized per-topic optimization of prompts and hyperparameters, prioritizing overall robustness and generalizability over topic-specific tuning.
Efficiency Trade-off in Video Synthesis: To ensure fast training loops during the GRPO phase—where each iteration requires synthesizing a group of videos—we utilized a relatively lightweight video generation model (TurboWan2.1-T2V-1.3B). We found that this model is not as competitive or visually rich as larger video synthesis models, but it was necessary for computational efficiency. We firmly believe that future advancements and improvements in video generative models will bring direct performance gains to our co-evolution framework.
We thank the reviewer once again for their supportive review and valuable time. Please feel free to ask any further questions as we continue to address misunderstandings and concerns raised by other reviewers during this discussion phase.