- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces CellDisc, a virtual staining framework for computational pathology that addresses pathological semantic degradation, a limitation of existing methods that produce visually convincing but clinically inaccurate images. This is addressed by introducing dense cellular supervision into adversarial learning.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
I don't see much interest in the paper outside the computational pathology field. The proposed solution adds application-specific loss terms to the learning problem, which don't introduce novelty to the broader algorithms field.
The use of the DAB channel, the counting of stained cells, or downstream tasks have already been considered [A]. These works should be better put into context.
The BCI dataset is known to contain many artifacts, such as doubling of the image sections or dark/black shade. [B] manually assessed all tiles and cleaned the dataset, resulting in the BCI-clean version. Why only the original dataset, and not the cleaned version? Why not other datasets, such as the HER2match dataset [B]. So, the assumption that there are no publicly available datasets is questionable.
Citations are almost all in the wrong format (citet vs citep).
References [A] Peng, Q. et al. Advancing H&E-to-IHC virtual staining with task-specific domain knowledge for HER2 scoring. In Medical Image Computing and Computer Assisted Intervention—MICCAI, 2024.
[B] Klöckner, P., Teixeira, J., Montezuma, D., Cardoso, J.S., Horlings, H.M., Oliveira, S.P.: Gans vs. diffusion models for virtual staining with the her2match dataset. In: MICCAI Workshop on Deep Generative Models. pp. 120–130. Springer (2025)
[C] Attention-guided and MIL-constrained CycleGAN for high-fidelity virtual p16 and Ki-67 staining Lei et all, 2026.
Questions for authors
do you plan to make code and datasets public?