acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

A Multidimensional View of LLM Uncertainty Quantification via Scenario Interventions

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Reliable uncertainty quantification for large language models should capture not only whether an answer changes, but whether it changes appropriately when the supporting evidence is altered. We propose Response–Evidence Coupling (REC), a multidimensional framework that estimates answer uncertainty from two coupled dimensions: scenario-conditioned response behavior and scenario-specific evidence support. Starting from an anchor answer, REC constructs evidence-preserving equivalent scenarios and counterfactual replacement scenarios that modify answer-bearing facts. It then evaluates whether the model follows the task-dependent expected response under each intervention and whether the generated answer is supported by the corresponding scenario. These signals are organized into anchor, equivalent-intervention, and counterfactual-intervention risks and aggregated through rank-normalized Fisher fusion. Across four QA benchmarks and four LLMs, REC achieves the best AUROC and AUARC in most settings. Ablation results further show that intervention-aware response behavior and scenario-specific evidence support provide complementary information, supporting a multidimensional view of LLM uncertainty.

Primary area:
probabilistic methods (Bayesian methods, variational inference, sampling, UQ, etc.)
Keywords:
Large Language Models, Uncertainty Quantification, Multidimensional Uncertainty, Scenario Intervention

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_AqcVOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces REC, a method to assign an uncertainty score to answers of LLMs. It tries to create different uncertainty signals, by (0) creating an anchor scenario if not available (1) extracting supporting evidence for a QA pair in the context (2) rewriting into an equivalent context and a counterfactual context (3) deriving some score from answer agreement and evidence support with subsequent aggregation schemes. However, deriving the score hinges on a large and possibly very capable model (much more than the models used to actually answer), while other parts of the pipeline use small and even a task specific model. The method was evaluated on a fairly standard setting (the two main eval strategies, four tasks, four models) and did some ablation on the method's components.

Critical strengths

None

Critical weaknesses
  • The whole pipeline is extremely complex. It relies on multiple models (General LLMs, but also specialized ones like the NER one) and particular prompt templates for different LLMs involved in different roles in the whole pipeline. Also, it assumes some kind of knowledge about the task format, evidenced by the different prompt templates for different tasks. While the method seems to work very well on the selected benchmarks, it appears to be overengineered to those and is likely not applicable to other tasks, see my question below.
  • The whole introduction of different parts of the method are a bit ad-hoc and heuristic. There is no reasoning behind the different types of aggregations, analyses on the quality of LLMs to achieve intermediate steps or the support scoring.
  • The actual score used within the remaining machinery of REC is s_i, a numerical prediction made by DeepSeek-V4-Flash - a very capable and big model (nearly 300B). My guess is that the method hinges completely on that fact and the deepseek model might be a very good judge on its own of whether or not the smaller model's answer is gonna be correct or not.
Questions for authors
  • In the weaknesses I identified that the method seems very engineered towards the particular benchmarks targeted. If you could provide good results for the SVAMP dataset (math questions which is a bit OOD for the method as presented) without changing prompts and stuff, that would illustrate if I am right or wrong about that, even if you just compare against simple baselines such as P(True) or SAR.
  • Did you investigate how well rewriting with the SLM works in practice? Dependent on the types of context it could be very hard to preserve all important information. Also, without the question it is also not clear what information is important? What if the question is "What word in the context features most vowels?". Obviously that is a worst case scenario and mostly its fine, but could you elaborate on possible validation steps, e.g. letting the SLM check equivalence between the two, conditioned on the prompt (and possibly anchor answer) in an intermediate step? Going back to the original question, could you provide numbers on the quality of SLM rewrites using the outlined setup?

Remarks

  • Please remove that "depth" effect in Figure 1 and 2, I know it should symbolize the multidimensionality, but it just makes it hard to parse.
  • Captions for Figure 1 and 2 should explain what we are seing there.
  • 'q' is used for two different things and '\eta' is introduced for no good reason I could identify
Reviewer_sNb5OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

REC estimates answer uncertainty by combining response behavior under evidence interventions with support from the corresponding scenario. It constructs one equivalent rewrite and one deterministic replacement context, compares intervention answers with an anchor answer, and combines support and behavior risks through task-wise ranks and hierarchical Fisher fusion. The expected response to replacement differs between context-grounded and open-domain QA. Evaluation covers four QA datasets and four answer models, with ten baselines, component and fusion ablations, auxiliary-model sensitivity, and judge/intervention validation.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper makes a useful distinction that ordinary response consistency misses. An answer should remain stable under a faithful rewrite, whereas a changed context may call for either a changed or stable answer depending on the task. Coupling this behavior with scenario-specific support is more informative than treating all answer changes as uncertainty. Sections 3.2–3.4 make the construction explicit, and Table 3 provides evidence that both sources matter: the intervention groups add roughly 2.2–3.8 AUROC points over anchor-only scoring, while removing support causes substantially larger losses. This combination of a clear diagnostic idea and targeted ablations is the main conceptual reason I support acceptance.

  2. The empirical evaluation is reasonably broad for this question. REC leads AUROC in 14 of the 16 dataset–model settings in Table 1 and AUARC in 15 of 16 settings in Table 2. It performs particularly well on NQ and TriviaQA across all four answer models. The paper also includes alternative fusion rules, auxiliary-model capacity analysis, a 200-answer human calibration of the correctness judge, and a separate intervention-validity check (Appendices A.1–A.4). These checks do not settle every concern, but they go beyond a single benchmark or an unvalidated model judge.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The uncertainty interpretation depends on intervention and support assumptions that are only partially validated. For open-domain QA, a context generated by the same answer model can repeat the model’s mistaken belief even without being conditioned on its candidate answer. Conversely, replacement can remove support for a correct parametric answer, as the Kilimanjaro and Bob Dylan cases in Figure 4 illustrate. Low scenario support therefore need not mean the anchor answer is factually wrong. Appendix A.2 is useful, but an approximately 92% successful alteration rate does not guarantee that every context-grounded item should change its answer, as Equation 4 assumes. These limitations narrow the interpretation to an empirically useful error-ranking signal. The paper should identify how unchanged or invalid replacements are handled and distinguish constructed-context support from factual correctness.

  2. The open-domain anchor procedure needs to be stated consistently. Section 3.1 defines the anchor answer as generated with the anchor context, whereas Appendix B.1 explicitly says that NQ and TriviaQA answers are generated without context and then reused after pseudo-context construction. This distinction matters: otherwise, answer changes between the anchor and intervention scenarios could reflect the addition of context as well as the intervention itself. Appendix B.1 provides a concrete implementation description, so this appears to be a fixable methodological clarification rather than evidence that the results are invalid. I would like the authors to align the main text with that description and confirm that all methods rank the same anchor predictions. Table 3 already includes anchor-only and support-retaining controls, and Figure 3 examines judge capacity; these should be acknowledged as evidence addressing the auxiliary-judge concern rather than treated as missing experiments.

Questions for authors
  1. Protocol clarification: Which open-domain anchor procedure produced Tables 1–3: answering with the pseudo-context as in Section 3.1, or answering without context and reusing that answer as in Appendix B.1? Were all compared methods evaluated against the same anchor predictions and correctness labels?

  2. Intervention clarification: What happens when replacement produces no eligible spans or leaves the answer inferable? Equation 4 assigns an expected answer change to context-grounded replacements, while Appendix A.2 acknowledges that some replacements miss decisive evidence. Please explain how such cases enter the behavior risk. This concerns the definition of the reported method, rather than a request for additional experiments.

  3. Result interpretation: On CoQA with Llama-3.1-8B, REC achieves 81.9 AUROC but 81.3 AUARC, while SAR and SESDLG achieve 90.7 AUARC (Tables 1 and 2). Please confirm that the AUARC entry uses the same evaluation protocol and briefly discuss why REC is less effective for selective prediction in this setting. The exception does not overturn the broader gains, but it is worth explaining.

Reviewer_qVy3OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces a framework for estimating LLM answer uncertainty. For a given question, they propose: (1) Automatically generating equivalent and counterfactual scenarios and (2) Creating different subsets of the available evidence. The model’s behaviors when shown the different resulting prompts is measured and these measurements are combined into an overarching uncertainty risk score.

Critical strengths

Uncertainty quantification is an important problem and the outlined approach does well when evaluated using the paper's methodology.

Critical weaknesses

I found this paper to be difficult to understand; the writing is opaque and hard to follow. When I ran the intro through the Pangram labs AI text generator, it was marked as 100% AI-generated.

Moreover, the method presented seems complex and it's not clear that the complexity is justified since the support judge is what drives most of the performance benefits in the ablations.

Questions for authors

What do key anchors get replaced with in the counterfactual replacement scenario?

What is the meaning and purpose of the task-aware expected direction?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.