- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents Any3D-SLAM, a DROID-style SLAM framework that integrates pretrained 3D foundation models into learned correspondence estimation and differentiable bundle adjustment. The main contributions include a memory-efficient warping-based updater and an uncertainty-gated pose prior. Experiments on six benchmarks demonstrate competitive tracking accuracy across different backbones.
Critical strengths
-
The framework achieves competitive results across several challenging benchmarks.
-
The design is compatible with multiple geometry foundation models.
Critical weaknesses
-
The proposed framework shares substantial architectural similarities with WildPose, which already integrates pretrained 3D foundation model features, learned correspondence estimation, motion-aware weighting, depth priors, and differentiable BA. The main differences appear to be the warping-based updater and the uncertainty-gated pose regularization.
Furthermore, the "Any3D" claim is not sufficiently justified. Although WildPose uses MASt3R for feature extraction, its architecture also appears conceptually adaptable to other 3D backbones. Supporting several pretrained models does not necessarily constitute a fundamental methodological contribution, especially when separate training is required for different backbones. The authors should discuss this overlap more explicitly and clarify what makes the proposed framework fundamentally different from WildPose.
-
Insufficient experimental evidence to support the claimed improvements and isolate the proposed contributions. WildPose uses MASt3R features, while the proposed method mainly reports results using DAv3 and Pi3X. It is therefore difficult to determine whether the improvements come from the proposed architecture or simply stronger pretrained representations. Given that WildPose already employs MoGe-2 as its depth prior, in addition to MASt3R features, the proposed MoGe variant does not demonstrate a clear advantage over WildPose. In Table 2, it performs worse on several cases. Although the backbone usage and calibration settings differ, these results raise questions about the benefits of the proposed unified representation. More controlled experiments are needed to demonstrate that the proposed architecture provides improvements beyond the choice of pretrained models.
-
Insufficient isolation of individual architectural contributions. The method introduces several changes simultaneously, including the warping-based updater, depth regularization, motion weighting, and pose priors. While the ablations are useful, they do not fully establish whether the improvements come from the proposed architecture or simply adding more priors to an existing DROID-style framework.
-
The authors state that their results do not use loop closure or hierarchical global optimization, whereas other baselines may include loop closure and global BA. The comparison would benefit from explicitly marked optimization protocols, or an analysis of how these differences affect the reported results.
Questions for authors
See the weaknesses. Overall, I am positive to the strong engineering effort and competitive results. However, given the substantial architectural overlap with WildPose and the lack of sufficiently controlled comparisons, I am not yet convinced that the improvements can be attributed to the proposed methodological contributions. Will consider changing the rating if the concerns can be resolved.
As the discussion period is nearing its end, we would be grateful for your thoughts on our updated responses and manuscript. If any concerns remain, we would welcome the opportunity to clarify them. Thank you again for your time.