- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes FluidJEPA as a latent model to evaluate the field prediction, latent recurrence, and action-family transfer for the fluid dynamics.
Critical strengths
The strength is that the author introduces sufficient benchmark datasets to test and compare. Ablation study is also done to support the main claim.
Critical weaknesses
My biggest concern is that the proposed framework simply uses previous methods (architecture, loss design, action-conditioned modeling) and technical innovations are limited.
Questions for authors
- Some notations in Fig. 1 are used but not explained. E.g., A, B, q_t, F_i.
- The technical contributions are quite limited as the model architectures, loss designs, and action-conditioned modeling are all already there.
- The gap between accurate decoded predictions and reliable latent recurrence is a known issue. The reported results only partially address it, as latent rollout remains less accurate than decoding and re-encoding in the main experiments.
- The baseline comparison is too limited, with only FNO and U-NO as external baselines. Please include methods supporting direct latent recurrence, such as Learning to Accelerate Partial Differential Equations via Latent Global Evolution (Wu et al., 2022) and Toward Goal-Agnostic Joint-Embedding Predictive Control of Partial Differential Equations (Gallagher & Guglielmi, 2026), under matched training and evaluation settings.
- There is no drawback discussion and the future work is limited.