- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes TD-CDE, which decouples temporal evolution from cross-channel interaction using diagonal selective dynamics and Tensor Train decomposition. It provides theoretical analysis of high-order interactions and exact conditional attribution, and shows strong performance particularly on datasets with strong order-dependent structure.
Critical strengths
-
Strong theoretical motivation: The paper clearly explains why diagonal or commuting dynamics can miss higher-order cross-channel interactions, and proposes a principled tensorized solution.
-
Good alignment between theory and experiments: TD-CDE performs best on the datasets identified as having strong order-dependent structure, and the resolution-transfer experiments provide convincing evidence for the proposed high-order discretization.
Critical weaknesses
-
The empirical gains are concentrated on a small number of datasets. TD-CDE shows large improvements mainly on SelfRegulationSCP1 and EigenWorms, while its performance is similar or worse than the strongest baseline on several other datasets.
-
The meaning of “exact interaction-order decomposition” is somewhat conditional. The decomposition is exact for fixed gates and computational pathways, but its interpretation as interaction order in the original input space requires additional assumptions.
Questions for authors
-
Can the authors provide additional real-world datasets with strong order-dependent structure to demonstrate that the observed gains generalize beyond the two main datasets?
-
Can the authors clarify more explicitly when the exact decomposition corresponds to interaction order in the original input variables rather than only an exact decomposition of model computation?
-
In camer ready, could you give us the architecture figure of your model, which can make your idea more clear?