- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes PFedMA, a fixed-width extension of the neuron-matching aggregation framework used in FedMA. It discards unmatched units from non-donor clients and fills vacant positions using a randomly selected donor client. The authors also coordinate channel assignments across Batch Normalization layers and residual connections to support ResNet architectures. Experiments cover four image-classification datasets under different levels of data heterogeneity. The reported accuracy gains are strongest on ResNet-18, while results on the other architectures are mixed.
Critical strengths
Maintaining a fixed architecture while respecting channel consistency across residual connections is a practically meaningful extension of matched aggregation. The design avoids matching-induced model growth and accommodates networks with stronger structural constraints. The reported accuracy improvements over the evaluated baselines on ResNet-18 provide encouraging empirical evidence for this direction.
Critical weaknesses
- The scope of the method’s applicability remains unclear. The strongest gains are observed on ResNet-18, while results across other architectures and heterogeneity settings are mixed. The evaluation primarily focuses on convolutional networks and does not establish whether the proposed fixed-width matching and donor strategy provide similar benefits for other network architectures. This limits my assessment of the method’s generality and broader practical value.
- The reliability of random donor selection is insufficiently validated. Since the donor determines which unmatched units are retained, different choices may lead to different accuracy, especially when client data distributions differ substantially. The paper does not report this sensitivity, leaving the stability of the reported gains unclear.
Questions for authors
- Which parts of PFedMA depend on the structure of CNNs or residual networks? What modifications or constraints would be needed to apply it to non-CNN architectures, such as Transformers?
- How sensitive is the final accuracy to donor selection? Could the authors quantify the variation across runs that change only the donor-selection seed while keeping other settings fixed?