acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Who Acts, to Whom, and What They Say: Action-Aware Social Simulation at Scale

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Behavioural foundation models answer what a given person would say: the speaker is an input. A population simulator must also decide who acts, when, and to whom, and today these decisions are typically left to hand-written rules. We pose full-event simulation, a task in which the speaker is an output: from a platform's history, a model emits the next events (how many, when, who, to whom, and what they say) and continues from its own output. We build ACT-AWARE, which learns who acts and whom they answer, and writes what they say with a post-trained behavioural foundation model. On a single-step version of the task, ACT-AWARE names real actors with 49.6% precision, against 36.6% for the best of fifteen language models prompted zero-shot. Rolled out the natural way, such a simulator meets a limit no model can lift. If it draws actors from a trailing window of recent posters and feeds on its own output, its coverage, the share of real actors it selects, has a ceiling fixed before its first step. A controller lets ACT-AWARE widen that window to seven days with no observed drop in precision. Over five held-out days, its coverage reaches 2.35× the ceiling of a six-hour window, against 1.27× for random ranking and 1.85× for ranking by lifetime post count, both under the same controller and seven-day pool. Structurally, its output also becomes the world later events come from: 82.4% of its simulated replies attach to posts it generated, against 85.2% in real data. In short, who acts is a learnable factor rather than a scheduling convention.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Social simulation, User behavior modeling, Behavioral foundation models, Population simulation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_iVC7OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes "full-event simulation", in which a model generates, in closed loop, not only what users say but also who acts, when, and to whom. Its system, ACT-AWARE, combines a learned actor ranker and reply-target head, an OSim-4B text model, and a data-calibrated controller, and the paper shows that trailing-window simulators face a model-independent coverage ceiling (Proposition 1). On Reddit data, it outperforms 15 zero-shot LLMs at picking real actors and reaches 2.35× the coverage ceiling of a 6 h pool using a 7 d pool.

Critical strengths

1. An interesting perspective. Existing LLM-agent simulators mostly delegate "who acts and when" to mechanisms outside the model. The paper proposes treating it as an output rather than an input of the model, and formalises this as the six-factor decomposition. This perspective is a useful contribution to the social simulation community.

2. Solid engineering analysis of closed-loop dynamics. The loop-gain analysis of the rate model, the use of DAgger to handle feature-distribution drift, the diagnosis of the reply-target head's "support failure", and the analysis of how composition drives aggregate precision are all convincing and reusable insights.

Critical weaknesses

1. Text does not enter the structural dynamics, so the core element of social simulation is missing. Section 2.1 states explicitly that x_e only affects the text of events replying to it, and that structure can be sampled first with text filled in afterwards; none of the ten features of the reply-target head carry any textual information either. This means that what a post says has no influence at all on who replies to it, how many reply, or whether a long chain forms. This contradicts content-driven dynamics observed in practice (such as topic diffusion, opinion evolution). At least the authors should (a) state this limitation clearly in the abstract and introduction, and (b) provide an ablation in which text affects structure, or argue why the decoupling does not harm fidelity.

2. Lack of the macro-level distributional and counterfactual evaluation that social simulation actually cares about. The goal of social simulation is usually fidelity of distributions and mechanisms, not merely predicting specific users. Yet the evaluation focuses on identity-level coverage and precision, reports almost no distributional metrics such as cascade/thread size, inter-event times or the heavy tail of posts per user, and includes no intervention or counterfactual experiment. The few macro-level metrics that are reported show clear deviations that go undiscussed.

3. Insufficient comparison with and discussion of related work. The authors claim that existing LLM-agent simulators leave "who acts and when" to hand-written rules, but some existing work lets agents themselves decide whether to act and which action to take. Moreover, rules or priors are often a deliberate trade-off between fidelity, cost and controllability: they are cheap at the scale of millions of agents, transparent, and make it easy to specify scenarios, drive synthetic populations and run interventions. The paper does not discuss these trade-offs: it gives no runtime or scaling data, and its controller targets numerical stability rather than scenario control. The authors should discuss and compare against this line of work.

4. Overclaiming: the claim that "who acts is learnable" does not match the actual system. Only candidate ranking and reply targets are learned. Most quantities that determine population dynamics are fixed or hand-tuned: the total D̂_t depends only on the clock, the recency composition is fixed to its measured value, per-actor event counts come from an empirical table, and τ, ρ and K are tuned on validation. In other words, the system still has an external scheduler (the controller), only more finely calibrated.

Questions for authors
  1. What is the cost of a full rollout? Please report per-step runtime, throughput, and scaling with candidate-pool size and number of actors. What would it cost to generate text for all events, and how does this compare with LLM-agent simulators that use rule-based scheduling?
  2. How would a researcher specify scenarios in this framework, such as adjusting the activity of a particular group, or injecting new agents or a synthetic population? Does the method still apply where real historical trajectories are unavailable?
  3. Is the decoupling of text and structure a deliberate modelling choice or a compute constraint? If the actor head and reply-target head read a representation of post text, how would closed-loop coverage, attachment rate and the reply-chain depth distribution change? Without such a change, can you provide evidence that the decoupling does not harm fidelity?
Reviewer_kKVXOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a framework combining learned actor, reply-target selection, and a calibrated controller for full-event social simulation. Through experiments on Reddit, the authors show that their proposed frameworks improve the performance of actor selection and population coverage.

Critical strengths
  • This paper addresses an important question of how to perform a full-event social simulation,
  • The authors perform substantial experiments to evaluate the proposed framework, which, to some extent, supports the claims and framing.
Critical weaknesses
  • Generated content cannot influence subsequent interaction dynamics. This excludes an important mechanism in social simulation: what people say would change who participates and whom they engage with. Although this separation enables efficient structural rollouts, it limits the framework's behavioral fidelity.
  • The evaluation provides insufficient evidence of population-level fidelity. Some behavioral statistics remain largely mismatched (e.g., post per actor and mean reply-chain depth).
Questions for authors
  • Would the authors compare user-network degree distributions, reciprocity, and reply-tree size/depth distributions against real data and baselines?
  • How do the authors justify excluding generated content from future actor and reply-target selection, and what limitations does this introduce to the intended applications?
Reviewer_zqKwOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces ACT-AWARE, a framework for population-scale social simulation that aims to model not only what users say, but also who acts, when they act, and whom they respond to. The proposed system decomposes event generation into several components, including an activity-rate model, an actor selection model, a reply-target predictor, and a post-trained language model for text generation. A controller is further introduced to regulate actor selection and maintain the activity distribution during closed-loop simulation.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses an important but often overlooked problem in LLM-based social simulation: selecting which user acts next, rather than simply generating responses for a given speaker. The analysis of candidate-pool limitations is useful. Although the population-closure result is mathematically straightforward, it illustrates how restricting selection to recently active users can limit population coverage in long-running simulations. The experiments also provide meaningful comparisons with activity-based heuristics, uniform selection, and a gradient-boosted forest. In particular, the matched-controller results suggest that the learned actor scorer performs better than simple activity-based selection rules.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper presents ACT-AWARE as a unified framework. However, the population-scale experiment generates 2.49 million structural events, while full text is generated for only 1,575 events, with just 116 used for text-quality evaluation. Moreover, generated text does not influence subsequent actor or target selection. Thus, the experiments mainly demonstrate large-scale structural simulation rather than fully integrated closed-loop simulation.
  2. Although the paper aims to replace rule-based scheduling with learned decisions, several key components remain manually controlled, including activity rates, recency-based actor allocation, event multiplicity, and event timing. As a result, some reported improvements in population-level statistics may come from these predefined constraints rather than learned behavioral patterns. The paper should better distinguish the contribution of the learned components from that of the controller.
  3. Table 4 reports actor coverage of 0.1996 and selection precision of 0.0345. Despite improvements over baselines, these values remain relatively low. The generated posts per actor also differ from real data. Furthermore, the evaluation covers only five 24-hour windows and focuses mainly on aggregate statistics. More evidence is needed to show that the simulator captures realistic interaction patterns and population dynamics.
Questions for authors
  1. Since generated text does not influence subsequent actor or reply-target selection, to what extent does the proposed system actually model the feedback between conversational content and future user behavior?
  2. Several population-level properties, including activity volume and actor-recency composition, are explicitly constrained by the controller. How should we distinguish the contribution of learned behavioral dynamics from the properties enforced by these constraints?
  3. I am confused why is the main coverage improvement framed relative to the theoretical ceiling of a six-hour candidate window when the proposed method operates with a seven-day window?
  4. Table 1 evaluates a joint-objective model rather than the separately trained components used in the final simulator. How directly do these likelihood improvements support the performance claims of the deployed system? I am willing to raise my score to 3 if these concerns address well during rebuttal.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.