- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
In this paper, the authors proposed a secant version of integrator for several numerical integrators utilized in Riemannian Hamiltonian Monte Carlo methods. The approach is motivated by applying variational integration method. The new integrator scheme are tested against three experiments for eight different solver. The empirical studies produce effective outcome.
Critical strengths
The problem under consideration is an important one. The idea proposed in the paper is novel.
Critical weaknesses
There is no solid theoretical results for analysis of validity and complexity of the proposed new method. The numerical experiments are limited, their outcome are not as conclusive as suggested in abstract and conclusion.
Questions for authors
Q1, The term hierarchical model is used several time, but it is not really explained. Q2. The map and have not been properly defined. Related the chart map is given in a unconventional way without explanation. Q3. Line 156 the sentence starts wit "With this setup..." is not very well explained, including why is the representation of with constraint. Q4, please confirm that the variable in (15) also take the value of when applied to equation (9). Q5. The parameters set for the experiments seem to be limited and arbitrary, please explain the logic behind the set up.
Thank you for replying to my comments and questions. Really appreciate the addition to Appendix B. I would like to adjust my score.