W1 . The reproduction of CentralKV does not match the original configuration. The paper runs Stream-Influence on a single global graph built from attention averaged over all heads, whereas CentralKV builds its graph per head, and its own ablation shows that switching to a global graph costs 4.4 F1; the paper's Appendix E also observes that the score stays bounded with a single head. Conclusions such as "indistinguishable from random eviction", "λ has no effect", and "the recursion diverges" therefore apply only to the paper's variant, and the LongBench results that contradict CentralKV's reported gains are left unexplained. I suggest adding experiments with the per-head version.
W2. Gains from propagation appear only on synthetic data and are unstable. Propagation helps only on BridgeBench-Real and RULER-VT, and the gain varies widely with model and budget: at a 10% budget it is +35 points for Qwen-3B but only +7 for Llama-8B, and on RULER-VT it helps only at a 2% budget. On HotpotQA, MuSiQue, LongBench, and BABILong, propagation brings no gain or even hurts, and full SSP matches or slightly trails SnapKV in F1. The authors attribute this to natural questions "naming every hop", but MuSiQue and bAbI by construction do not name the later hops, and they show no gain either.
W3. The theory contains a misstated result and overstates its scope. The proof of Theorem 7(a) uses the positions of the bridges to bound early background tokens, yet in Figure 1(b) the first few background tokens already score higher than the first bridge, so the theorem needs to be restated. Theorem 9 requires the question's attention to land only on the gold chain, but H2O and SnapKV operate on dense attention and are therefore not covered as stated; moreover, "unseeded scores perform at chance" cannot be distinguished from the trivial explanation that a question-agnostic score cannot know which chain is being asked about. In addition, Prop. 1, Cor. 2, and Prop. 10 are largely restatements and do not support the "Causal-HITS Theory" in the title.
W4. Insufficient scale and cost analysis. All decoding experiments use contexts under 8k tokens. SSP needs the full attention of 32 heads, which the paper obtains with eager attention, making prefill 2–3× slower; memory grows quadratically with length and reaches about 1 TB at 128k. The reported 14% overhead excludes this cost, and the fused kernel mentioned in the paper is not implemented.
W5. Missing related work. HeadKV (ICLR 2025) likewise calibrates heads on synthetic data before compressing the KV cache, and HippoRAG (NeurIPS 2024) seeds multi-hop propagation with question entities. Both are closely related to the proposed method but are neither cited nor compared.
Response to Reviewer
We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment of the theory and experiments. We revised the presentation along the two lines the reviewer raised. All changes are in blue in the revised PDF.
Narrative connecting the contributions. The four contributions are steps of one argument, and the revised introduction now says so before listing them (§1, paragraph "This paper"):
Each subsection of §4 and §6 now opens with one sentence naming which of these steps it serves (§5 and §5.1 already did).
Notation.
We also tightened the statement of Theorem 7(a) and added baselines and analyses in response to the other reviewers (see the general response). We hope the revised version is easier to follow, and we are happy to fix any remaining unclear passage the reviewer points to.