- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper is about road damage detection. While being an applied problem, it is very important. The authors propose a pipeline built upon a YOLO detector. The authors evaluate several YOLO detectors. The pipeline appears to be straight-forward, without any technical novelty. There is no comparison with prior works, not even the ones cited by the authors.
Critical strengths
The YOLO family offers strong and efficient detectors. The authors correctly chose this family for this task.
Critical weaknesses
technical contribution
It appears that the authors only fine-tuned several YOLO detectors using existing datasets. There is no technical novelty presented to the reader.
Comparison with prior works
Although the authors cited several prior works, there is no comparison with any such work.
Readability
I found this paper a bit hard to understand. There are several technical terms that are not defined in this paper (see questions to authors below).
Questions for authors
- There is a citation to a paper form Buneman et al in line 139. I checked this reference. It appears to be a paper from the database community, ie there is not connection to computer vision or machine learning. What is the purpose of adding such a citation?
- What are field paths, validity conditions, etc in sec 3.2?
- what is the "archived reporting benchmark"? What is its purpose in this paper?
- Fig 1: There are boxes such as "writer verifier", "evidence contracts", etc: What are these?
In order for me to raise my score, I would need to see a clear technical contribution plus a thorough comparison with prior works.