- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces DoubleTakeBench. DoubleTakeBench has ~500 tasks from coding agent traces. They measure the ability for fast judges to determine if there are issues in an action.
Critical strengths
This paper measure classification systems on determining if actions in agent trajectories are correct or not. The authors perform a human analysis of agreement.
Critical weaknesses
A benchmark should tell the reader something about the real world. The traces were collected in a specific way from agent traces that excludes persistent errors. This creates survivorship bias, which is not discussed in the paper in enough detail so that a reader can actually understand what the benchmark is measuring.
Furthermore, the positive/negative split is constructed in a way that systematically introduces biases (negatives are natural agent misjudgements, positives are synthesized corrections).
Questions for authors
N/A
4 comments
Follow-up to Reviewer yU4a: Evidence Controls and Benchmark Coverage
Dear Reviewer yU4a,
We are very grateful for your insightful feedback on trajectory sampling and positive/negative item construction, which also prompted us to evaluate question-only baselines. Your feedback encouraged us to more rigorously test how our benchmark items depend on the provided evidence. Following our initial response, we have completed additional evidence-control and question-only experiments using Jev 1.13.0 and Jev 1.14.0 (both from the same model family) on the released benchmark.
Evidence Controls on Multiple-Choice Items
Across all 179 released multiple-choice items from 91 tasks, each model evaluated the same factual options with full tool evidence and with the tool-evidence field removed. We tested both the original and reversed option orders, mapped reversed selections back to the original labels, and averaged scores across the two presentations per item against the original references.
| Model | Full evidence | Evidence removed | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jev 1.13.0 | 55.6% | 41.9% | +13.7 pp |
| Jev 1.14.0 | 52.8% | 41.3% | +11.5 pp |
Supplying full evidence increases accuracy by +13.7 percentage points for Jev 1.13.0 and +11.5 percentage points for Jev 1.14.0. Using task-cluster bootstrap resampling, the exploratory 95% intervals for the paired differences are +3.2 to +23.7 points for Jev 1.13.0 and +2.3 to +21.0 points for Jev 1.14.0.
As an additional structural control for Jev 1.13.0 in the original option order, we masked all evidence letters and digits while preserving entry IDs, character counts, whitespace, and punctuation. Full evidence achieves 104/179 (58.1%), whereas masked evidence drops to 75/179 (41.9%). Together, these paired tests help clarify the extent to which the supplied tool evidence drives judge performance on the multiple-choice items.
Binary Question-Only Test and Planned Sampling
Prompted by your comments on item construction, we also evaluated both Jev versions on all 346 released binary items using the proposition alone, with background, assumptions, and evidence cleared. Under this question-only condition, Jev 1.13.0 answers 206/346 correctly (59.5%; AUROC 0.639) and Jev 1.14.0 answers 205/346 correctly (59.2%; AUROC 0.629), compared against a 54.3% majority-class baseline. For clarity, the previously reported 71.7% accuracy refers to our separately trained, task-grouped ten-feature diagnostic classifier. We will report both Jev question-only tests alongside that diagnostic in the revised paper so readers have a transparent view of these baselines.
In addition to incorporating these completed evidence controls and releasing the protocols and item-level predictions alongside the benchmark, we are taking your sampling suggestions to heart for our ongoing work. Specifically, we plan to expand benchmark coverage by sampling additional decision points independently from full trajectories—including naturally correct first judgments and persistent errors—and verifying each against the evidence available at the decision point.
Thank you once again for your constructive guidance, which has been invaluable in strengthening our evaluation.
My concerns have not been addressed therefore I will keep my score.
Further Response on Sampling, Item Construction, and the Revised Manuscript
Dear Reviewer yU4a,
Thank you for taking the time to consider our responses and for letting us know that your concerns remain. We appreciate that your review raises two closely related questions: what our revision-cycle sampling reveals about real coding-agent behavior, and how positive/negative item construction affects the measured judgments. We have clarified the former in the revised manuscript and provide an additional binary control below to address the latter.
1. Revision-cycle sampling and the measured task. DoubleTakeBench draws examples from real coding-agent trajectories where an interpretation is subsequently revised. While the revision helps identify a candidate instance, the reference answer is verified against the evidence available at the original decision point. Holding the inputs fixed, the benchmark compares judges on the same local interpretation and evidence. We have clarified this construction and task definition in the revised manuscript.
To further investigate the coverage question you raised, we plan to independently sample decision points from full trajectories—including naturally correct initial judgments and persistent errors—and report results separately by case type.
2. Positive/negative construction and binary controls. We appreciate your concern that original mistakes and constructed corrections may differ in wording. As reported in our initial response, a supervised ten-feature classifier using the proposition alone reached 71.7% accuracy under five-fold task-grouped cross-validation across the 346 binary items. We also evaluated Jev 1.13.0 and 1.14.0 using the proposition alone, obtaining 59.5% and 59.2% accuracy, respectively, compared to a 54.3% majority baseline.
We would also like to share a length-matched binary analysis not included in our previous responses. Using only lengths and labels (without model predictions), we retrospectively selected 114 positive/negative pairs (228 items across 106 tasks) with a maximum difference of 10 characters within each pair. On this matched set, a character-count-only classifier achieved 47.4%–50.9% accuracy across three task-grouped cross-validation splits, while a character TF-IDF classifier achieved 58.3%–61.4%.
Furthermore, we evaluated Jev 1.13.0 on these same length-matched items across different input conditions:
| Input | Correct | Accuracy |
|---|---|---|
| Full input, including tool evidence | 143/228 | 62.7% |
| Tool evidence removed; background and assumptions retained | 130/228 | 57.0% |
| Proposition only | 133/228 | 58.3% |
The difference between the full-input and evidence-removed conditions is +5.7 percentage points, with an exploratory task-cluster bootstrap 95% confidence interval of approximately −3.0 to +14.6 points. Using the proposition alone, Jev 1.14.0 also answered 133/228 items correctly. Alongside the text-only diagnostics, this control helps examine how models use evidence on length-matched binary items.
As a complementary test across all 179 multiple-choice items, we compared full versus removed tool evidence for both Jev versions, averaging across original and reversed option orders. When full evidence was supplied, accuracy increased from 41.9% to 55.6% for Jev 1.13.0 and from 41.3% to 52.8% for Jev 1.14.0.
3. Reference answers and presentation. Two annotators independently reviewed the same 60 items blind to the reference answers. They agreed with the references on 58/60 and 56/60 items, respectively, and with one another on 54/60 items. In the revised manuscript, we have also added a worked Go/Git example and further clarified the task inputs and construction process.
Thank you again for your careful feedback. We hope that the additional binary control and manuscript revisions clarify our evaluation and its intended scope, and we would be grateful if you could take these results into consideration.
Response to Reviewer yU4a: Sampling, Construction, and Human Audit
Dear Reviewer yU4a,
Thank you for examining the sampling and construction choices closely. Below, we clarify what revision-cycle selection measures and directly examine the wording cues raised by the positive/negative construction. We also distinguish those findings from the human audit of reference validity.
Reply to W1: Revision-Cycle Selection and Survivorship Bias
Thank you for identifying this limitation. We agree that revision-cycle selection excludes persistent errors and cannot represent all execution judgments.
What the benchmark measures. It asks whether a judge can evaluate a local interpretation using the evidence available before the agent acts on it. The source cases come from real execution traces, and holding the proposition and evidence fixed allows comparison of judges without changing retrieval or agent policies. This is a conditional diagnostic of an execution failure mode, rather than an estimate of its prevalence.
Why use revision cycles. A revision identifies a concrete disputed interpretation that can be checked against earlier raw evidence. It is a discovery cue, not sufficient proof of the answer. Items require evidence supporting the answer at the original state; later discoveries or environmental changes cannot establish earlier answerability.
Coverage and revision. Persistent errors and naturally correct first judgments are absent from this sampling frame. Converted positives do not restore that coverage. Their inclusion could change difficulty and rankings, and the direction remains unmeasured. We will make this sampling frame explicit in the abstract and construction section.
We will also describe routing as an offline accuracy-versus-escalation result. The benchmark does not establish tool calls saved or task-success gains from intervention.
Reply to W2: Positive/Negative Construction and Validation
Thank you for highlighting this asymmetry. The release contains label-associated wording cues, so class balance and human agreement cannot by themselves resolve your concern.
Direct diagnostic of construction cues. On 346 public binary items from 120 tasks, a ten-feature proposition-only classifier achieves 71.7% accuracy in five-fold task-grouped cross-validation. Two other split seeds give 69.4% and 68.5%, versus a 54.3% majority baseline. Character count alone gives 69.4%–69.7%. Correct and incorrect propositions have median lengths of 129 and 179.5 characters. Preprocessing is fitted on training folds only. These are exploratory supervised probes, without an independent final test.
What this changes. The signal supports your concern about shortcuts. Its causal attribution to a particular construction step and each evaluated judge's reliance remain unmeasured. We will disclose it in the construction analysis and qualify binary accuracy as evidence of using execution context. The probe cannot be ranked directly against the archived judge scores. Independently verified natural positives or symmetric-writing controls are needed to test whether model comparisons persist; that robustness has not been established.
Separate reference-validity check. Corrections were used to formulate true propositions that should be supported by the same earlier evidence. To assess reference validity, two annotators independently reviewed the same 60 items without seeing the reference answers: 20 binary-positive, 20 binary-negative, and 20 multiple-choice items. Their agreement with the reference and with each other is:
Across all 60 items, A and B agreed with the reference on 58 and 56 items, respectively, and agreed with each other on 54 items. We will include the detailed review tables in the project repository. This audit assesses reference validity; the proposition-only diagnostic above addresses the separate question of wording cues.
Thank you again for your time and the opportunity to address your concerns.
Best regards, The Authors