- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a spike-and-slab prior for BNNs hat can switch off whole groups of weights. Each group is turned on or off by comparing a latent variable to a shared threshold. Experiments use synthetic regression data, plus a comparison to MCMC on a small one-hidden-layer network.
The paper is in its current form clearly in an unfinished stage.
Critical strengths
--
Critical weaknesses
The first critical weakness of this paper is that it is incomplete, e.g., the main text points to appendices which are not yet written. I see this alone as a reason for a clear reject and kindly ask to next time please submit a finished paper.
Also, I would highly recommend the authors to a) do a thorough experimental study of the proposed method including on real-world data and also report metrics such as NLL and b) before submission double check all the claims and ground them in theoreticla or empirical results.
Lastly, the current submission only has 7 references. Of course numbers are not everything here but it still shows that a thorough review of related literature on BNNs and relevant subvariants has not taken place.
Questions for authors
I have no further clarifying questions.