- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Structura, a training-free inference-time refinement method to reduce structural and anatomical hallucinations (eg, distorted limbs, morphing objects) in flow-matching video generators.
Critical strengths
(1) this paper presents a interesting analysis of decoupling of energy magnitude and signed direction. Accumulating scalar energy separately from vector displacement is a nice design if a region oscillates in direction across steps, cancels out (falling back to isotropic exploration) while remains high to keep flagging the region as structurally unstable.
(2) connecting low-noise reconstruction residuals to local manifold projection and deriving an unbiased variance-corrected energy estimator is mathematically clean and well-motivated.
Critical weaknesses
(1) table 1 shows the method severely reduces the dynamic degree compared to baselines, can authors elaborate more on this effect? How do this method prevent the probe from mistaking legitimate fast motion for structural hallucinations?
(2) how is the 10,000-video editing dataset collected and processed, and why are 10000 samples needed if Structura is purely training-free and only evaluated on 100 samples?
(3) What are the exact values of , total NFEs, and wall-clock runtime per video for Structura vs. SRVS, NFE×2, and Best-of-4 in Table 1? How does Structura perform against Best-of-N under a strictly matched NFE budget?
Questions for authors
see above, I'm willing to discuss and raise my score
2 comments
Gentle follow-up on our discussion and revisions
Dear Reviewer 28Wb,
Thank you again for your insightful feedback and your encouraging remark that you are "willing to discuss and raise your score."
With the discussion deadline approaching, we wanted to kindly check in and see if our detailed responses and additional experiments have resolved your concerns—particularly regarding the analysis on dynamic degree/fast motion, the clarification on the 10k dataset, and the strictly matched NFE/runtime comparisons against Best-of-N.
If these clarifications and new results satisfactorily address your points, we kindly invite you to consider adjusting your rating accordingly. We remain fully available and eager to address any further thoughts you might have during the remaining time!
Best regards, The Authors
Response to 28Wb: motion, paired editing data and inference cost
Thank you for highlighting the separate energy/direction memories and the geometric motivation.
1. Dynamic Degree and rapid motion. Structura lowers Dynamic Degree relative to some baselines; SRVS shows the same refinement trade-off. When a backbone struggles to reconstruct complex motion consistently, repeated refinement can favor more conservative movement. Dynamic Degree measures motion prevalence, which can also reflect jitter and inconsistent deformation. Relative to SRVS, Structura improves both motion prevalence and structure in original Table 1:
Dynamic-Bench
Structura Bench
Our probe measures reconstruction response rather than motion speed. Figure 8 juxtaposes a turning dancer, inter-frame motion and accumulated response: an extra limb with relatively little displacement still elicits response during clear body motion. The example shows response to a structural anomaly during substantial body motion. See Appendix E, p. 22, Table 26, Figure 8.
2. The approximately 10k editing resource. We carefully curate an internal collection of high-quality paired video-editing data involving hand–object contact, occlusion and manipulation. It contains 10,634 video pairs and 20,987 editing instructions, with object references and temporal target localization. The full collection is a reusable resource; Structura uses frozen models at inference time. Own-100 is a subset covering every domain in the collection. Its 100 cases retain that coverage at an evaluation scale comparable to our DAVIS-2017 protocol (61 validation object instances). We will release the data and its processing and evaluation protocols. Appendix F, pp. 23–25, Tables 27–29, Figures 9/10 documents the construction and statistics.
3. Cost of the original configurations. The complete measured mean NFE list for original Table 1 is:
Appendix A, p. 13, Table 6 records the submitted configurations; the matched-budget experiment is reported separately.
For the strict-budget question, our general response compares Lite160, Native80 and Best-of-2 at exactly 160 denoiser NFEs. Lite160 improves structure/anatomy on both cohorts, with wall time close to Native80 and below Best-of-2. Both Lite configurations use K=2; their exact refinement schedules and measured runtimes are given in Appendix A. The K ablation is in Appendix D.