- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes DSF² for multimodal knowledge graph completion (MMKGC). The method combines entity relations, images, and textual descriptions to predict missing triples in a knowledge graph.
Critical strengths
- The paper provides clear and well-designed visualizations that help explain the proposed method.
- The relation-conditioned fusion design is reasonable. Different relations may require information from different modalities and at different scales, which fits the nature of the task.
- According to the reported results, the improvements are fairly consistent. The main ranking metrics improve across all three datasets, with particularly noticeable gains on DB15K.
Critical weaknesses
- It is unclear how useful multimodal knowledge graph completion remains in real-world applications today. The paper does not provide enough case studies to demonstrate its practical value.
- The authors should carefully check whether the released code is consistent with the model described in the paper. For example, it is worth verifying whether the implementation of DSFD actually includes the proposed energy grouping, hyperbolic space mapping, and dual-space contrastive learning components.
- On pages 7–8, SNAG is categorized as an "LLM-based MMKGC" method, while on page 13, it is grouped with generative or hybrid completion methods. However, the original SNAG is a representation learning framework that uses modality noise, Transformer-based interactions, and RotatE for completion scoring. These classifications do not seem accurate.
- The discussion and comparison with existing work on hyperbolic representations and multimodal knowledge graph completion are not sufficiently comprehensive.
- The paper seems to be largely incremental, building on relatively conventional techniques.
- The performance improvements are relatively limited.
Questions for authors
- Given the rapid development of multimodal large language models (MLLMs), can these models also perform multimodal knowledge graph completion? What advantages might they offer compared with the proposed method?
Reply to W1:Thank you for raising this concern. We agree that benchmark link-prediction results alone do not sufficiently illustrate the practical value of multimodal knowledge graph completion. In e-commerce, MPKGAC formulates missing product attributes as a multimodal KG completion task and reports a 2.14% relative increase in click-through rate in an Alibaba application (Wang et al., 2023). In biomedicine, Xiao et al. (2026) study the completion of multimodal biomedical KGs, where missing relations are relevant to scientific investigation. In cultural heritage, ArtKGC examines how completed artwork facts can provide evidence for artwork question answering and explanation (Zhou et al., 2026). These studies demonstrate the value of recovering missing facts when structured knowledge is incomplete but complementary evidence is available.
Reply to W2:Thank you for raising this concern. We agree that consistency between the released code and the described model should be verified explicitly. The energy-based grouping is examined in Appendices C and L, the hyperbolic mapping is evaluated in Section 4.5 and Appendix H, with additional before-and-after DSFD analysis in Appendix I, and the dual-space objective is examined in the ablation study and Appendix H. To address the implementation concern directly, we will also check the released code against the corresponding equations and provide a clear mapping to the functions implementing energy grouping, Poincaré mapping, and the Euclidean and hyperbolic loss terms.
Reply to W3:We thank the reviewer for pointing out this misclassification. We agree that SNAG uses pretrained models for feature extraction but is not an LLM-based MMKGC method. We have corrected its classification in the appendix related work and replaced SNAG with LBMKGC in the main comparison table.
Reply to W4:We thank the reviewer for highlighting this gap. We have expanded the discussion of prior work on hyperbolic representations and MMKGC, and added further analyses in Appendices H, I, J, and K. These additions clarify the motivation for our geometric design and provide additional empirical evidence for its behavior.
Reply to W5:First, very few studies in the field of knowledge graphs have taken a frequency-domain perspective. In our review of the past three years, we found only about four or five such papers, and WFF is the only one published at a top-tier conference. Moreover, WFF directly transfers spatial-domain processing logic to the frequency domain without treating low- and high-frequency components separately according to their distinct characteristics.
Reply to W6:Frequency-domain methods show a clear advantage on DB15K, whose richer relation types and denser graph connectivity provide informative structural patterns for modeling smooth shared semantics and relation-specific local variations, which semantic enhancement relying mainly on large pretrained models struggles to fully capture. LLM-based methods achieve several best or second- best results on MKG-W and MKG-Y, but their performance drops on DB15K, with some metrics below those of conventional multimodal KGC methods. DSF2 outperforms most LLM-based results on MKG-W and MKG-Y and improves over the frequency-domain baseline on DB15K, demonstrating its ability to model both shared smooth semantics and local discriminative variations.
Reply to Q1:Yes, MLLMs can perform multimodal knowledge graph completion. HFR-MKGC, which is included in our main comparison, uses LLaVA to process visual information and incorporates the reasoning output of a fine-tuned MLLM into completion scoring. MLLMs can draw on broad pretrained visual–language knowledge and support flexible, triple-specific reasoning. HFR-MKGC performs competitively on MKG-W and MKG-Y, but its results on DB15K are weaker, with some metrics below conventional MMKGC methods. In Table 1, DSF² achieves higher MRR, Hits@1, and Hits@3 than the LLM-based comparators on MKG-W and MKG-Y, and outperforms the frequency-domain baselines on DB15K. These results support the effectiveness of explicitly modeling shared low-frequency semantics and relation-discriminative high-frequency variations, while recognizing the complementary strengths of MLLM-based reasoning.In future work, we will also explore how multimodal large language models can be integrated into our framework.