- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies recursive self-improvement, where a model learns from its own outputs (e.g. labels data that is later used for learning, evaluates its own answers, etc). It makes the argument that there are two “mechanisms” that will influence the performance of the learner. The first is what the authors call the “inherited defect” which are errors introduced by the learner in previous stages, and the “environment” which controls things like task or prompt distributions. The paper then shows that if one wants to understand whether the learner will improve in performance over time, or deteriorate, then one must consider both the “inherited defects” and the “environment” together. Treating them as independent entities may lead to misleading evaluations/conclusions.
Critical strengths
-
The math in the paper seems to be correct.
-
The experiments, while small in scale, do support the theory in the paper.
-
The main take-away of the paper is reasonable, and if it improves the way people evaluate complex AI systems then that would be a valuable contribution.
Critical weaknesses
-
While grammatically sound, the writing in this paper is difficult to follow. I think the authors were going for a high level of abstraction and terminology-focus at the cost of explanation. The result is that the "story" is lost.
-
Novelty: The main take-away of the paper is basically (paraphrased) "the whole is different from the sum of its part". This is the core challenge in multi-objective optimization and is certainly known in control theory, which the authors acknowledge since they are using the standard mathematical setups from that field. This raises a question about the novelty or significance of the work.
-
Small scale experiments: The experiments do show that the theory is useful, but they are small and serve more as a proof-of-concept. This can be fine, but the experiments were setup to illustrate the points the theory was making. What would be more useful is either larger scale experiments OR clear evidence of realistic AI deterioration in certain systems. This would help strengthen the argument that the results are significant.
Questions for authors
Do you have examples of realistic AI systems where there is deterioration caused by the interplay of "environment" and "inherited errors"?
2 comments
Response to Reviewer (2/2)
3. Composition-Induced Deterioration in Realistic AI Systems — Concern 3 (W3, Q1)
Concern: The reviewer notes that the experiments are relatively small-scale and primarily designed to illustrate the theory, and suggests that evidence of deterioration in realistic AI systems would strengthen the significance of the work (W3). The reviewer specifically asks for examples of realistic AI systems where deterioration is caused by the interplay between environment feedback and inherited errors (Q1).
Response: Thank you for emphasizing the need for evidence of interacting feedback mechanisms in realistic AI systems. We address this concern by identifying relevant examples from existing AI systems and conducting a new factorial experiment on RoTTA, a published continual test-time adaptation method, to directly measure the interaction between inherited-error and environment feedback. The full analysis is provided in General Response #3.
Examples from existing AI systems. Several published systems exhibit related recursive feedback mechanisms and report deterioration. In self-play reasoning, R-Zero (Huang et al., 2025) combines a challenger that generates questions (environment feedback) with a solver trained on its own majority-vote pseudo-labels (inherited errors), and reports performance degradation after several iterations. In long-horizon test-time adaptation, methods that train on self-generated targets while selecting their own data can fall below the unadapted model on long or recurring streams (PeTTA, Hoang et al., 2024; RDumb, Press et al., 2023). In self-evolving agents, Shao et al. (2025) report that accumulated memory reduces a coding agent's refusal rate on unsafe requests, although the contribution of an environment route has not been tested. These examples illustrate relevant failure modes, but do not independently isolate the contributions of the two feedback mechanisms.
Direct factorial evidence from RoTTA. To directly examine the interaction, we investigate RoTTA (Yuan et al., 2023), an existing continual test-time adaptation method whose deterioration under recurring data corruptions was independently documented by Hoang et al. (2024). Unlike our controlled simulations, this system was not designed to illustrate our theoretical framework. RoTTA contains two feedback routes: inherited errors, through teacher-generated training targets, and environment feedback, through confidence-based memory admission. We conducted a factorial experiment to isolate their individual and joint contributions. The inherited-error route alone causes substantial deterioration (+34.20 percentage points), while the environment route alone has little additional effect relative to the control. When combined, the two routes produce a +21.10 percentage-point factorial interaction (95% CI: [15.70, 26.25]; Table R6), substantially aggravating deterioration.
Interpretation and scope. The RoTTA results provide direct evidence that the interplay between inherited errors and adaptive data selection contributes to deterioration in a published AI system, beyond the individual effects of the two mechanisms. Since the inherited-error route already deteriorates alone, the experiment demonstrates composition-aggravated deterioration rather than the failure of two individually harmless mechanisms. The experiment measures the realized factorial interaction, not the spectral amplification boundary. Together with the other published examples, these findings demonstrate the relevance of interacting feedback mechanisms in realistic AI systems, while distinguishing observed deterioration from experimentally isolated interaction effects. The complete results and limitations are presented in General Response #3 (Appendix N.3, Table 20 and Figure 11).
Response to Reviewer (1/2)
We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful assessment and constructive feedback.
1. Storyline and Presentation — Concern 1 (W1)
Concern: The reviewer finds the paper difficult to follow despite its grammatical clarity, noting that the high level of abstraction and emphasis on terminology obscure the central scientific storyline (W1).
Response: Thank you for highlighting the need for a clearer scientific motivation and storyline. To improve the clarity of the narrative, we have reorganized the Introduction to establish the central problem before developing the theoretical framework and its terminology.
A clearer storyline. The revised Introduction follows a more natural progression. It begins by explaining how self-improving systems learn from their own outputs and how multiple feedback mechanisms act on the same learner, despite usually being studied separately. This motivates the central question: can mechanisms that are harmless individually cause deterioration when combined, and would the system recognize such deterioration? We then introduce an everyday example, discuss what existing work establishes and leaves open, and develop the correction-budget insight before presenting the formal model and three main findings.
An intuitive example. To make the interaction concrete, we added an everyday analogy involving a person using sleeping pills and coffee to manage poor sleep. Although each remedy may be harmless alone, their interaction can create a reinforcing feedback loop that worsens sleep quality while the person feels fine. This example illustrates three central ideas: individually harmless mechanisms can fail together, their combined feedback can exceed the learner's correction budget, and internal evaluation may miss deterioration revealed by an external measure. The analogy provides an intuitive foundation for the theoretical concepts introduced later.
More accessible terminology. We also explain key concepts in plain language before introducing their mathematical formulations. For example, we introduce the correction budget as the fraction of a deviation that the learner removes by itself each round. To further improve accessibility, we added a terminology and notation table (Appendix C, Table 2) that provides definitions of the main concepts and symbols used throughout the paper.
Finally, we reorganized the discussion of prior work into a separate Related Work section (Section 2), allowing the Introduction to focus on the scientific motivation, central insight, and main contributions.
Manuscript changes
2. Novelty and Scientific Significance — Concern 2 (W2)
Concern: The reviewer questions the novelty and scientific significance of the work, arguing that the central observation that interacting mechanisms can behave differently from their individual components is already well established in classical control theory and related fields (W2).
Response: Thank you for raising the important question of how our work differs from classical control theory and existing research. We clarify our mechanism-level contributions and their relationship to classical stability theory in General Response #4.
The possibility that interacting mechanisms behave differently from isolated ones is a familiar starting point. Our contribution is to identify how feedback mechanisms interact through the learner, inherited defect, and adaptive environment, using an exact decomposition of primitive feedback paths. This reveals joint contributions that can arise even without direct coupling between the mechanisms.
In a structured model, we further characterize how the mediated effects of these mechanisms jointly determine the amplification boundary, including regimes where individually attenuating mechanisms amplify when combined or opposing feedback restores attenuation. The resulting framework connects these interactions to recursive system design parameters, providing a quantitative explanation of how different mechanisms affect the combined dynamics.
These contributions, together with their relationship to classical stability theory and representative related work, are detailed in General Response #4 (Table R7).