- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper claims to propose a method that is able to identify reusable descriptions of the feedback behavior of controllers based nonlinear echo state networks. This is supposed to enable the same controller to support new task queries without retraining. The method is evaluated on a cart-pole and robotic arm control tasks.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
- The paper is extremely poorly written and badly presented. This seems to be mainly due to the fact that the most if not all content and text seems AI-generated without substantial revision by the authors. This makes it as a reader extremely hard to follow and, therefore, the paper does not provide any meaningful value to the research community even if the method could potentially be promising (the reviewer is not able to assess the research idea due to the poor presentation).
Questions for authors
None
2 comments
Currently, the PDF does not show any highlighted changes to allow me to assess potential improvements in presentation and writing quality. Therefore, I will keep my rating of the paper.
Response to Reviewer uc95
Thank you for the review.
You ask whether we checked and revised the AI-assisted content. We have read the manuscript, its mathematical formulation, and the code ourselves, and we take responsibility for the work. AI assistance was disclosed in the submitted manuscript; the revised statement will further specify its scope and our checks.
We recognise that the paper was hard to follow. We are revising the presentation, including background before the method, a table defining the tasks, a consolidated arm-results section, and clearer, shorter explanations. We plan to upload the revised PDF by 18 November 2026.
Could you identify the passages that prevented you from assessing the method? Do your soundness assessment and ethics flag stem from the presentation and your concern about whether we checked the AI-assisted content, or have you identified additional problems with the mathematics, experiments, or reported results?
We will address these points directly and would appreciate a technical assessment of the method and evidence in the revised version.