- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes ViGa-SR, a multimodal framework for symbolic regression that uses an MLLM to extract structural cues from visualizations of observed data and injects the resulting priors into an LLM-guided evolutionary search. Candidate visual structures are numerically screened before being used, and the extraction process is applied hierarchically by removing identified components and re-rendering the residual signal. The method is evaluated on Feynman, LLM-SRBench, and several additional case studies, where it achieves competitive symbolic recovery performance and shows that visual priors can substantially influence downstream search.
Critical strengths
1.The paper proposes an interesting system-level mechanism for incorporating multimodal information into symbolic regression.
2.Hierarchical residual re-visualization is a promising idea.
Critical weaknesses
1.The experiments do not sufficiently isolate the mechanisms underlying the paper’s central claims. The paper argues that numerical verification makes the visual channel reliable and that hierarchical identification reveals structures missed by one-shot extraction. However, the evaluation does not include the most direct controls needed to establish these claims, and the contributions of these components are therefore not disentangled. The current experiments do not convincingly establish why the method works or which of the proposed mechanisms are necessary.
2.Variable anonymization removes semantic and name-based shortcuts, but it does not prevent the MLLM from recognizing familiar mathematical shapes or function families that may have appeared during pretraining. This distinction is particularly important here because the core contribution is precisely the use of a pretrained multimodal model to infer structure from rendered data. The paper itself acknowledges that anonymization does not eliminate shape recall, and its LSR-Synth experiment is described as a descriptive self-check rather than a measurement of memorization resistance. Therefore, the current evidence does not support the stronger interpretation that ViGa-SR demonstrates general visual structure discovery on equations that are genuinely outside the MLLM’s prior knowledge.
3.Missing closely related work. The related-work discussion appears incomplete with respect to recent structure-aware evolutionary symbolic regression. In particular, Symbolic Regression with Physics-Informed Residual and Structural Sensitivity Pruning (IEEE TEVC, 2026) introduces structural priors and fine-grained sensitivity-based evaluation of symbolic substructures during evolutionary search. While RSSP differs substantially from ViGa-SR in that its priors are physics-derived rather than visually proposed by an MLLM, both works use structured prior information and numerical criteria to guide local structural decisions during symbolic evolution. This work should therefore be discussed explicitly, and the novelty claim should be narrowed from generic “verified/adaptive structure-guided evolutionary search” to the more specific contribution of visually acquired, coordinate-level priors with numerical admission and hierarchical residual re-reading.
4.The paper also has several presentation and writing issues. First, the core research gaps are not mapped one-to-one to the subsequent experiments. Second, the Introduction overgeneralizes the limitations of prior work, which makes the stated research gap appear broader than the actual scope of the contribution. In addition, the Methodology still reads somewhat like a module-by-module system description, and several nontrivial design choices lack sufficient rationale connecting the underlying difficulty to the proposed mechanism.
Questions for authors
1.Could the authors provide a controlled comparison, under the same computational budget, among the following settings: no visual prior, unverified MLLM prior, numerically verified MLLM prior, one-shot extraction, and hierarchical extraction? Without such controls, it is difficult to determine which mechanism is actually responsible for the observed performance gains.
2.How do the authors position ViGa-SR relative to recent structure-aware evolutionary symbolic regression methods such as Symbolic Regression with Physics-Informed Residual and Structural Sensitivity Pruning? Although the two methods differ substantially in the source of structural information, both use fine-grained structural signals and numerical criteria to guide symbolic evolution. A clearer comparison would help determine whether the main novelty lies in visual prior acquisition, numerical admission, hierarchical residual re-reading, or a broader claim of structure-guided search.