- Rating
- 1(−1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1(−1)
Read review
Paper summary
A new framework is proposed to work on encrypted face data. The authors propose HELite-ResNet a residual network architecture designed with CKKS in mind. Empirically the work is verified using three datasets, CIFAR-10, FERPlus, and RAF-DB.
Critical strengths
The method is empirically verified on multiple datasets.
The combination of a new model architecture and some form of knowledge distillation seems to be novel. However, this is not my area of expertise so I cannot claim this with certainty.
Critical weaknesses
I will fully admit that as a reviewer, this paper is not in my main area of expertise. Therefore, please consider my critique lightly as I am not intimately familiar with much of the literature in this domain. For example, I could not verify much of the mathematics used in this work.
Issue #1: The threat model is kind of sparsely described. I don’t know if this is normal for this type of literature but I did not have a good understanding of the attacker or the defender from reading what the authors wrote in this subsection. It would be much better if this section was further clarified.
Issue #2: Data alignment. The authors claim their work is targeted for facial expression recognition. However, one of the datasets they use is CIFAR-10. This makes no sense at all. I would like to see the CIFAR-10 dataset removed from the experimental results. In addition, when they do comparisons to other methods, this is done on CIFAR-10 (for example in table 2). I would much prefer that the authors use less method and instead only test on datasets for the given application they are concerned with (faces). Right now, the way the paper reads it is like they say they said they have a new fast horse that is great on land. However, when they run this horse in a race, the race takes place in the ocean. I can kind of see the strength of the “HELite-ResNet” in the results, but it is not abundantly clear (as it should be for an ICLR paper).
Questions for authors
- Can you fix the writing of the threat model section?
- Can you do a comparison between your architecture and competitors on an actual face dataset?
Response to Reviewer 5yjZ
Thank you for your constructive comments. Detailed point-by-point responses are provided below.
1. Revision of the Threat Model Description
Thank you for this suggestion. The corresponding revisions to the threat model have already been addressed in our response to Reviewer 1, Comment 2, and incorporated into Sec. 2.3 of the revised manuscript. In addition, we further clarify the scope and limitations of the threat model, including the exclusion of malicious computation, side-channel attacks, and secret-key compromise.
2. Evaluation on Facial Expression Recognition Datasets
Thank you for this suggestion.
(1) Experimental comparison and performance evaluation. The relevant experimental comparisons and performance evaluations have been addressed in our response to Reviewer 1, Comment 3.
(2) Dataset selection. FERPlus and RAF-DB serve as our primary evaluation datasets, while CIFAR-10 is used only as a supplementary encrypted-inference benchmark for comparison with existing homomorphic encryption inference methods. Therefore, our primary experimental conclusions are based on the results on FERPlus and RAF-DB.