- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose DisContact. DisContact jointly generates hand motion and per vertex contact using Gaussian and discrete diffusion, respectively. This formulation lets the model retain it's original representation in each diffusion, while allow each diffusion stream to improve each other. At each denoising step, predicted motion is decoded through MANO to condition contact prediction, and pooled contact features then refine the motion estimate.
Critical strengths
-
Reasonable formulation. Modeling continuous motion and binary contact in their respective state spaces is well motivated and reasonable.
-
Meaningful geometric connection. Vertex aligned MANO geometry provides a clear correspondence between articulated motion and contact variables.
-
Promising experimental results. Improvements on two datasets and several controlled ablations support the overall framework, particularly its contact prediction.
Critical weaknesses
-
Lack video results. A paper on 4D, especially for generation papers, is expected to have extensive qualitative results, especially videos. Reviewers cannot assess a 4D generation paper without seeing the videos.
-
The contribution of contact to motion improvement is not sufficiently isolated. Motion refinement uses hidden contact branch features, which also contain motion geometry and image/text conditioning. Consequently, improved motion accuracy could arise from additional processing capacity or auxiliary supervision, rather than contact specific information. The coupling ablations do not separately isolate the contact motion pathway. A directional ablation and a capacity matched refinement baseline would make this contribution much clearer.
-
Motion and contact consistency does not establish valid hand object interaction. The object free diagnostics assess properties of the generated hand and contact labels, but cannot determine whether contacting vertices touch the actual object or whether penetration occurs. This limitation is acknowledged, but it restricts what the consistency results demonstrate. Object aware evaluation would strengthen the practical significance.
-
The evaluation provides limited evidence about generative quality and robustness. Results emphasize motion error and contact F1, with little analysis of sample diversity or uncertainty. Controlled ablations use a single sampling run, making smaller improvements difficult to assess reliably.
-
Lack of discussion with methods that use continuous contact maps (minor) It would be great to see discussions related to papers using continuous contact maps.
Questions for authors
-
How does motion accuracy change when only contact-to-motion refinement is removed, while motion to contact geometry conditioning is retained?
-
Does refinement still help when the contact branch retains its architecture but receives no contact-state input or contact supervision?
-
Can the generated contact be evaluated against actual object surfaces where geometry is available?
-
If contact is binary, it cannot model the distance between the hand and the object which also could be a very informing signal. Could using continuous, distance based contact maps potentially improve model performance? There is already a line of work that uses distance based continuous contact maps to enhance performance (JointHOI: Jointly Generating Contact Maps Enhances Hand Object Interaction Generation ECCV26, Bimart: A unified approach for the synthesis of 3d bimanual interaction with articulated objects CVPR25). It would be great if there is a discussion on the use of binary contact maps over continuous distance based contact maps, and also comparison to these work.