- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates hallucination risk in LVLMs from the perspective of prefill representations. It introduces a plausibility-aware concept taxonomy that distinguishes plausible absent concepts (PACs) from implausible absent concepts (imPACs), and constructs the PAC³ benchmark for controlled analysis. The authors compare PACs and matched imPACs at the behavioral, representation, and generation levels, and report that PACs are more likely to be falsely recognized, receive stronger image-conditioned support in intermediate prefill layers, and are more likely to appear in subsequent generations. They refer to this phenomenon as “visual overinterpretation” and argue that it provides a concept-level interpretation of pre-generation hallucination risk.
Critical strengths
The paper studies an interesting and relatively underexplored question regarding hallucination risk before generation. Focusing on prefill representations provides a potentially useful perspective complementary to analyses centered on decoding behavior.
Critical weaknesses
The paper does not clearly distinguish “visual overinterpretation” from normal context-conditioned semantic inference. Since PACs are defined precisely as absent concepts that are plausible given the image context, it is expected that a VLM assigns them higher support than implausible absent concepts. The reported ordering S(c_g)>S(c_p)>S(c_n) can therefore be interpreted as a reasonable evidence hierarchy rather than a hallucination-specific failure mode.
The interpretation of intermediate-layer logits as “concept-level representations” is insufficiently justified. The proposed concept support is essentially a Yes–No logit margin obtained by projecting the final prompt representation at each layer. A larger intermediate-layer logit for “Yes” does not necessarily imply that the corresponding concept is explicitly represented or misrepresented internally, leaving a substantial gap between the measurement and the claimed representational interpretation.
The visual-null baseline is central to the method but is not adequately validated. The entire POG analysis relies on subtracting a model-specific visual-null response from the image-conditioned response. However, removing or replacing visual input can itself induce architecture-dependent distribution shifts. Without careful ablations over alternative null constructions, it is unclear whether the measured gap reflects visual evidence or artifacts introduced by the chosen baseline.
The PAC–imPAC matching procedure does not sufficiently control semantic confounders. Matching is mainly based on concept frequency and token length, while PACs and imPACs may still differ systematically in semantic category, lexical familiarity, visual recognizability, or prompt difficulty. Therefore, the observed PAC–imPAC gap cannot be cleanly attributed to plausibility alone.
The evidence connecting prefill overinterpretation to downstream hallucination is weak. The paper establishes correlation rather than causation, and the association is strongly model dependent. In particular, Qwen3-VL shows only a weak POG–GOG correlation, while many PAC–imPAC pairs have zero generation difference. This substantially weakens the claim that the identified prefill phenomenon is a meaningful precursor of hallucination.
The current manuscript has significant reproducibility and completeness issues. Appendix A claims to provide the benchmark construction, prompts, model-specific visual-null implementations, discovery/confirmation split, and statistical procedures, but these details are not actually included in the provided manuscript. These missing details concern several core components of the proposed analysis and make the main results difficult to independently assess or reproduce.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.
Thank you for your valuable feedback. We have uploaded the revised manuscript (changes in blue) and supplementary materials with additional experiments. Our responses are as follows:
1. Visual Overinterpretation vs. Normal Semantic Inference.
We acknowledge that higher support for PACs may reflect reasonable contextual inference. However, our findings extend beyond such preferences. Visual overinterpretation encompasses two complementary levels:
2. Interpretation of Intermediate-Layer Concept Support.
Following layer-wise probing studies [1,2], we use concept-specific queries and binary logit readouts to probe existence judgments across layers (Sec. 3.3). Concept-level interpretability arises from semantically defined queries and controlled contrasts, rather than assuming explicit concept encodings. This approach reveals model-dependent layer-wise dynamics (Finding 2), while downstream associations (Finding 3) support its behavioral relevance (Sec. 4.3). [1] Wang et al. Same Attention, Different Truths: Put Logit-Lens over Visual Attention to Detect and Mitigate LVLM Object Hallucination. CVPR, 2026. [2] Belrose et al. Eliciting Latent Predictions from Transformers with the Tuned Lens. arXiv:2303.08112, 2023.
3. Robustness to Alternative Visual Controls.
Our visual-null implementations preserve text, sequence length, and visual-token positions (Sec. 4.1.2). Under additional blank and unrelated natural image controls, onset, peak, final-layer, and all-layer support gaps remain positive across models, with all 95% CIs excluding zero (Appendix D.3, Tables 14–15), suggesting that preferential PAC support is not specific to our visual-null implementation.
4. PAC–imPAC Matching and Semantic Confounders.
PACs and imPACs are matched within the same image, with lexical frequency and token length considered during benchmark construction. To further address potential confounders, we conducted three additional analyses:
5. Association with Downstream Hallucinations.
Our revised analysis includes all 313 pairs (186 images), including zero-gap pairs (55.9%/82.7%/95.2%), yielding correlations of 0.494/0.433/0.191 (Table 4). After text-only prior adjustment, associations remain significantly positive in LLaVA and DeepSeek-VL but are inconclusive in Qwen3-VL. Onset-layer support shows no reliable incremental predictive value beyond final-layer signals. Importantly, Findings 3–4 motivate examining prefill and decoding separately. Qwen3-VL retains substantial prefill support gaps, yet its low PAC (1.25%) and grounded concept (44.41%) mention rates suggest that conservative decoding may suppress hallucinations at the cost of concept coverage (Sec. 4.3, Table 6). Thus, fewer hallucinated PAC mentions do not necessarily imply reduced prefill susceptibility. Our contribution is to characterize concept-level prefill susceptibility that output-level evaluation may overlook, rather than establish a universal predictor or causal mechanism (Appendix F).
6. Reproducibility and Completeness.
We apologize for the incomplete appendix. The revision details benchmark construction (Appendix A.1), prompts and scoring (A.2, C.3), visual-null implementations and controls (Sec. 4.1.2, Appendix D.3), image-disjoint splits and layer selection (D.2), and statistical procedures (A.3). We also consolidate experimental observations into four key findings and discuss their implications and limitations (Sec. 4.3, Appendix F).