acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

PATHTAIL: Calibration Attribution from Finite Forecast Samples

Abstract

Calibration audits often estimate a specified prediction error from a finite set of forecast trajectories. When that error is defined by a population projection, fitting the projection on the forecast sample can change the audit target. We give an exact counterexample in which the intended residual component is zero, yet a residual fitted to only eight forecast paths has nonzero mean. PATHTAIL constructs a score and companion statistic whose expectations preserve the original residual component and its tolerance. On finite domains, we characterize the minimum fixed forecast budget required by bounded exact scores and show that it depends on the target even within a fixed nuisance space. These scores support anytime-valid sequential auditing. A paired study further shows that exact score choice matters: a pooled-count construction substantially improves detection under rare-state predictive laws while losing under uniform laws, demonstrating that maximizing the mean signal does not maximize detection. Controlled feedback from four native forecasting models across eight data sources verifies target preservation, while a replayable count archive exposes the remaining limits of detection and sampling efficiency.

Primary area:
probabilistic methods (Bayesian methods, variational inference, sampling, UQ, etc.)
Keywords:
probabilistic forecasting, calibration auditing, finite-sample inference, sequential inference, anytime-valid inference, forecast sampling, time series foundation models

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_KmXrOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
1
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper considers the problem of calibration audits which attempt to test whether the predictions made by some system are calibrated. The authors show that standard calibration auditing methods can themselves be biased on some examples even though these examples are actually calibrated, and then introduce PATHTAIL, a calibration auditing method that does not have these same issues.

This submission is very far from my area of expertise, so I would assign very little weight to my assessment of its technical contributions.

Critical strengths

None

Critical weaknesses

The only thing I can reasonably comment on is the writing which, as someone not from this field, I found quite technical even from the first page (e.g., as a non-expert reader of the sentence "In a four-state example, ordinary least squares fitted to eight paths produces a residual of mean −.01814 although the population component is zero.", I do not know what I am supposed to take from this sentence: does the example have 4 hidden states in some Markovian process? why is ordinary least squares relevant here? what is a residual mean? is -0.1814 supposed to represent a large number or is the point only that it is nonzero? finite sample sizes often diverge from their population means, so is it surprising that that happens here as well?). Perhaps these are trivial for people who are more well-versed in this field and it is just too far from my area of expertise, but I could not make ends of the paper.

Questions for authors

None

Reviewer_QgZNOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

Suppose a probabilistic forecasting model generates sample future trajectories. One wishes to check whether its predictions are calibrated against real outcomes, but in particular, when calibration errors occur jointly versus them occurring independently of each other. The idea is to create a function which captures both the effects, and project the function onto a subspace created out of the errors, which isolates the additive effects of the errors. After this, the projection is subtracted from the original function, and the residual thus created carries joint effects of the errors. It is this quantity's mean that one attempts to estimate from sample trajectories. PathTAIL is an algorithm that uses a score and companion to collect statistical evidence against the null hypothesis that the joint effect of the errors is below a certain threshold. While experiments validate the algorithm, the main theorem gives a lower bound for the number of paths required and the dimension of the nuisance space, for a score and companion pair to exist.

Critical strengths

The ideas are very interesting. The idea of separating joint effects from individual effects using projections may not be novel, but exploring it using a score and companion idea is quite interesting as well. Their main result is simple to understand if explained properly, and the mathematics has been checked to hold without errors.

Critical weaknesses

The writing is all over the place: multiple statements are misplaced and not where they should be. The writing fails to motivate the problem sufficiently, and some calculations that were placed into the Appendix or not even in the article, should be there so that those slightly unfamiliar with the field can follow the write-up. A number of technical terms are thrown around without introduction.

The score and companion idea is not motivated sufficiently: only the final form σU−τB\sigma U - \tau B is motivated. There are also some fundamental organizational issues in the article.

Questions for authors

a) On the first page "a four-state example, ordinary least squares fitted to eight paths produces a residual of mean −.01814−.01814 although the population component is zero". This has no context.

b) At the start of Section 2.2, the subspace N\mathcal{N} needs to be specified much, much better. When you say that x1x_1 indicates a high trajectory mean, what exactly does this mean mathematically? I had to look up externally that x1x_1 is a sequence of 00s and 11s of the same length as the trajectory, indicating when the mean exceeds a certain threshold, likewise x2x_2. But they really should be written out in at least the appendix, leave alone the main body where I think it should be. Without them, I don't then know what N\mathcal{N} is, and couldn't have figured out why Δf=0\Delta_f = 0.

c) "If gg assigns trajectories to cells and NN spans their indicators, then ..." This is just relating conditional expectation to projections, but what's written seems overly complicated.

d) I think the entire idea of a score and companion matrix has to be motivated much better. Why is a score and companion necessary, or suitable for calibration? While the literature review is kept separate, I genuinely think having references for these ideas (using a nuisance space, the score and companion matrix etc.) right next to them would have helped.

e) Figure 1 has a lot of technical terms that are completely unexplained. The reference to the figure is a full 3 pages later, so the figure itself plays no role where it is placed. The same is true of Figure 2.

The writing and presentation is the sole reason for my weak rejection; I think the idea is strong and could be greatly enhanced with improved presentation. I do not expect to upgrade this since the fix is too substantial.

Reviewer_9vDUOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how to audit probabilistic forecasting models when the predictive distribution is only available through a limited number of sampled trajectories. The authors show that estimating the population projection using finite samples can introduce bias and lead to incorrect conclusions about the target error. To address this, they propose PATH TAIL, which constructs exact score-companion pairs and uses them for sequential testing. The paper also characterizes the minimum number of forecast samples needed for exact scores on finite domains. Experiments evaluate the validity of these scores, compare their detection performance, and study the cost of forecast sampling.

Critical strengths
  1. The problem is well-defined and the counterexample provides a clear motivation. It shows that using an empirical projection can introduce bias even when the true population component is zero. This makes a convincing case for preserving the original target during auditing.
  2. The proposed score-companion construction is interesting. The theoretical result on the minimum forecast budget is also useful.
  3. The experiments are carefully designed and cover several aspects of the method, including false alarms, detection performance, and sampling costs.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The practical usefulness of the proposed auditing framework is unclear. Most of the main experiments use synthetic outcomes generated under controlled settings, rather than real observations collected over time. It would be helpful to see how the method performs on a held-out period of real observations.
  2. The paper provides the minimum number of forecast samples needed for exactness, but it is less clear how many samples are needed for effective detection. More details on how to choose the score and forecast budget would make the method more useful in practice.
  3. The scalability of the method to more complex targets needs further evaluation. Most of the main experiments focus on two binary features. For the complete binary interaction setting, the required number of samples grows exponentially with the number of features. It would be useful to understand how the method performs with more features or more complex target functions.
Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors evaluate the method on a held-out period of real observations? It would also be helpful to report how long it takes to detect an error.
  2. Is there a simple way to choose between Monomial and Pooled based on an independent pilot? Would this improve detection performance after accounting for the additional sampling cost?
  3. Can the authors provide more analysis of how detection performance changes with the forecast budget, the error magnitude, and the number of outcome updates?
  4. Can the authors include experiments with more than two binary features or multiple target functions, and report the corresponding detection performance and computational cost?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.