- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
VISTA predicts gene expression across tissue depth from morphology and a small number of spatial transcriptomics measurements. It combines a frozen UNI2-h encoder with multi-scale features, depth attention, graph propagation, and a bridge-matching loss. The paper evaluates the model on HER2+ serial sections, Open-ST, and two holotomography (HT) samples. The strongest result is on Open-ST: with the two outer sections revealed and 17 interior sections withheld, VISTA achieves a depth correlation of 0.4223, compared with 0.2713 for TRIPLEX.
Critical strengths
VISTA outperforms all reported baselines in depth correlation, gene correlation, and MSE (Table 4). The depth-correlation gap over TRIPLEX, 0.4223 versus 0.2713, is the clearest reason to take the method seriously. This result carries more weight than the visual smoothness of a predicted volume.
The Schrödinger-bridge loss between revealed planes is novel in this context and conceptually stronger than heuristic smoothness priors, enabling non-monotone axial variation while remaining anchored to endpoints.
Use of a noise ceiling on Open-ST and explicit discussion of why per-site correlation can be misleading for depth are commendable.
Critical weaknesses
Appendix A.8 defines the loss between two revealed planes and averages over locations strictly between them (Eqs. 8-9). In the single-section HER2+ protocol and the HT experiments, there is no second measured endpoint. Under the written definition, the set P is empty. Does the implementation turn the loss off, construct a second endpoint, or use another loss? The paper does not say, yet repeatedly states that the objective is unchanged across settings.
The paper shows that the full model predicts better, but does not establish which depth components produce the gain.
The component ablations are on HT, where depth-resolved expression is not measured (Table 9). Smoothness and alignment with morphology cannot, by themselves, establish that gene expression is correct at a given depth.
Questions for authors
-
What is the exact training objective when only one section is revealed? Please specify how the empty-P case is handled, where any second endpoint comes from, how is obtained, and how physical depth intervals enter the loss.
-
What physical tissue does the HT pooling operator represent?
Section 3.8 says the measurement integrates the entire depth column, while Section 4.3 describes a single measured plane. Please give the HT volume thickness, axial spacing, and the position and thickness of the Visium section. Why should expression pooled over all 65 HT slices match that measurement? If the measurement covers only part of the volume, does restricting supervision to that support change the results?
- How exactly is depth correlation computed and averaged over genes and trajectories, including centering, missing depths, and constant predictions?