- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates when learned temporal distance improves planning in latent world models. The authors train a temporal representation on top of a frozen LeWorldModel and propose an offline diagnostic that measures improvements in temporal ordering using rank correlation between trajectory step separation and representation distance. The primary claimed contribution is an empirical observation that improvements in temporal ordering can serve as an indicator of potential planning gains from replacing the original latent distance. The authors evaluate this relationship through experiments on navigation and manipulation tasks.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
The main diagnostic is simply the difference in rank correlation between trajectory separation and representation distance. While intuitive, this metric does not establish a principled connection to planning performance. Moreover, from a control perspective, temporal separation along recorded trajectories is not equivalent to optimal cost-to-go, and the diagnostic does not explicitly account for the underlying dynamics.
The experiments are largely restricted to a single world model framework and a small set of relatively simple environments.
Consequently, the central claim remains largely empirical without a clear characterization of when improved temporal ordering leads to better planning.
Please correct the author ordering in references "Contrastive Learning as Goal-Conditioned Reinforcement Learning" and "Decision-Metric Alignment in Latent World Models" to match their official publications. Also, I think the citation to Table 1 in the Figure 7 caption should be corrected to Table 3.
Questions for authors
Since temporal separation along recorded trajectories does not necessarily reflect optimal reachability, what justifies using its rank correlation with representation distance as an indicator of planning performance? Under what assumptions would this diagnostic be informative?
To what extent does the observed relationship between temporal ordering and planning improvement depend on the specific world model or environments? What evidence supports its applicability beyond the evaluated settings?