acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Reducing Hallucinations in Generative Models through Truncated Statistics

Abstract

Hallucinations—where generative models produce invalid or nonsensical outputs—remain a critical challenge for reliable deployment. We present the first computationally and query-efficient algorithm that provably addresses the hallucination problem by actively querying the model’s own invalid outputs. Specifically, we control the hallucination rate up to an arbitrarily small multiplicative slack while approximately maximizing the likelihood of valid target examples via projected stochastic gradient descent. Our method works in very general settings with arbitrary validity sets and valid observations, within fixed powerful exponential families satisfying stated regularity and sampling assumptions. Our approach is enabled by a novel connection to the field of truncated statistics and settles an open problem posed by Hanneke et al. (2018).

Primary area:
learning theory
Keywords:
Hallucinations, Generative Models, Truncated Statistics, Exponential Families, Constrained Optimization

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_GYuzOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies hallucination reduction in generative models by minimizing empirical negative log-likelihood (NLL) subject to a constraint on the probability of invalid outputs. Building on a connection to truncated statistics, the authors develop a projected stochastic gradient algorithm over nested likelihood sublevels. Under a structural condition called powerfulness, together with covariance, tail, and computational oracle assumptions, the algorithm achieves approximate likelihood optimality and validity guarantees. The paper also establishes an NP-hardness result and presents a synthetic Gaussian experiment.

Critical strengths
  1. Reducing hallucinations while preserving generative quality is an important problem, and the constrained optimization formulation is meaningful.

  2. The paper develops nontrivial technical arguments, particularly the connection between powerfulness and convex sublevel optimization and the construction of approximate boundary minimizers. The mathematical analysis appears largely sound under the stated assumptions

Critical weaknesses
  1. My main concern is the limited applicability of the main theorem.

    • The global covariance lower bound is incompatible with powerfulness whenever the sufficient statistics are bounded. Powerfulness forces the natural-parameter domain to be unbounded, and along any ray in it the variance of a bounded statistic cannot stay bounded away from zero. This excludes even categorical softmax models, which the introduction cites as motivation.
    • The augmentation in Proposition 12 does not resolve this either. The variance of the added indicator vanishes with the invalid mass. Moreover, since no observation lies in SS, the NLL decreases monotonically as the coefficient of 1S\mathbf{1}_S tends to −∞-\infty, so the assumed interior NLL minimizer does not exist.
    • Even if the covariance bound were required only locally, this construction would give λ≲α\lambda \lesssim \alpha. That introduces polynomial dependence on 1/α1/\alpha and undermines the claimed polylogarithmic truncated-sampling complexity.
    • The only example verified to satisfy all assumptions is a one-dimensional Gaussian whose constrained optimum has a closed form.

    The paper therefore does not exhibit a nontrivial setting where the main theorem applies and the proposed algorithm is needed.

  2. The claim to settle the open problem of Hanneke et al. (2018) is overstated. The original question concerns statistical learning with valid outputs under an agnostic population-loss guarantee, given an optimization oracle. The present result instead establishes empirical NLL optimization within a restricted exponential family under additional structural and computational assumptions. No population generalization guarantee is provided, and the oracle model differs. Although the main text qualifies the claim, the abstract should describe the contribution as addressing a restricted variant of the open problem rather than settling it.

  3. The experimental evidence is limited and largely illustrative. It consists of a single one-dimensional Gaussian example, without baselines or measurements of the likelihood–validity trade-off; no NLL values are reported. Specific concerns:

    • Appendix H does not specify whether the full algorithm was implemented or how the projections were computed.
    • The final invalid mass (0.034) lies consistently below the target α=0.05\alpha = 0.05. Since Lemma 13 implies the constrained optimum has mass exactly α\alpha, this raises the question of whether the reported procedure attains the constrained optimum.
    • The illustrated Gaussian appears to have a changing variance, whereas the verified example has fixed variance. The experiment therefore likely lies outside the setting of the theorem.

    Given that computational efficiency is a central contribution, the algorithm should be demonstrated on a nontrivial setting satisfying its assumptions, with actual computational and oracle costs reported.

Questions for authors

see above

2 comments

Concern 1. Covariance and MLE

Thank you for pointing this out. We agree that the capacity construction should also admit an interior MLE when the original MLE is interior. As stated in Theorem 8, we assume a prescribed powerful family satisfying the regularity and access conditions. We will revise Proposition 12 to illustrate this capacity through the more natural operation of mixing with valid mass: qθ,w=(1−w)pθ+wδzq_{\theta,w}=(1-w)p_\theta+w\delta_z, where zz is a new valid atom. The regularity bounds for this augmentation depend on the base family and mixture weights.

The lower covariance bound is needed only on the enclosing NLL sublevel; the upper bound remains global. For pθ(x)∝eθxp_\theta(x)\propto e^{\theta x} on {−1,0,1}\{-1,0,1\}, observation 00 and invalid set {−1}\{-1\}, the MLE is 00, projections clip intervals, and FS=L+log⁡pθ(S)=−θF_S=\mathcal L+\log p_\theta(S)=-\theta proves powerfulness. The minimum variance there is of order α\alpha, giving polynomial cost in 1/α1/\alpha.

Concern 2. Examples and powerfulness

Tilt the product of two mixtures 12N(−1,1)+12N(1,1)\frac12N(-1,1)+\frac12N(1,1), with observation (0,0)(0,0) and S=((−2.5,−0.15)×(0.05,2))∪((−1.8,−0.30)×(−2.2,−1.6)).S=((-2.5,-0.15)\times(0.05,2))\cup((-1.8,-0.30)\times(-2.2,-1.6)). Covariance is diag⁡(1+sech⁡2θi)\operatorname{diag}(1+\operatorname{sech}^2\theta_i), between II and 2I2I; centered tails are uniformly sub-Gaussian, sampling and evaluation are explicit, and the MLE is 00. Projections use scalar solves and multiplier bisection. Increasing θ1\theta_1 sends invalid mass to zero and decreases FSF_S, since ∂1FS=Eθ[X1∣S]<0\partial_1F_S=\mathbb E_\theta[X_1\mid S]<0. This proves powerfulness.

An immediate corollary needs powerfulness only at one sufficiently small level β<α\beta<\alpha. For each θ\theta with s=pθ(S)>βs=p_\theta(S)>\beta, the family need only contain θ′\theta' with mass β\beta and L(θ′)≤L(θ)+log⁡(s/β)+ξ,\mathcal L(\theta')\le\mathcal L(\theta)+\log(s/\beta)+\xi, for sufficiently small accuracy-dependent ξ\xi. Invalid mass need not approach zero. Keeping pθp_\theta with probability β/s\beta/s and returning a known valid output otherwise gives this bound with ξ=0\xi=0. The approximate comparison does not require exact mixture closure.

Concern 3. Scope and population risk

We answer Hanneke et al.'s computational question (2018, §5.1) for empirical log loss in prescribed exponential families: under our assumptions, the algorithm is polynomial-time and proper, without their model-fitting optimization oracle. We will state this scope in the abstract. Any finite collection of generative laws embeds in one exponential family after arbitrarily small smoothing (Bickis, 2015, §2.2).

The population guarantee is an immediate corollary using the same algorithm. If the sufficient-statistic mean error is at most η\eta, population excess NLL is at most ε+2Rη\varepsilon+2R\eta, provided risks are finite and the output and a feasible population optimum lie in a common radius-RR ball. The data law need not belong to the family.

Our strengthened reduction proves worst-case NP-hardness of near-optimal NLL with relaxed validity even given a strictly feasible parameter. Every other hypothesis of Theorem 8 holds: Gaussian statistics with identity covariance, an explicit interior MLE and projections, and efficient sampling and exact membership. Only powerfulness fails, including its approximate form at the required level. Both results use the same sampling-oracle model.

Concern 4. Gaussian experiment

Appendix H fitted mean and variance with a valid-conditioned update using only 20 of the 40 valid observations. It did not implement Algorithms 1–2; covariance bounds and Euclidean projection accuracy were not verified.

At target 0.050.05, seed 0 reduced estimated mass from 0.5016650.501665 to 0.026200.02620, while all-data NLL rose from 2.11872.1187 to 5.22685.2268. A feasible Gaussian attains 3.478253.47825, close to the numerical constrained benchmark 3.478143.47814. This run incurred excess loss. The reported 0.0340.034 averages ten seeds; the notebook records seed 0. We will correct Appendix H.

Concern 5. Measured cost

Our central efficiency guarantee is theoretical: polynomial running time and oracle complexity. We ran invalid-conditioned PSGD with random tilts, averaging, Euclidean projections and grid/bisection on the instance in Concern 2.

Across five seeds at target 0.100.10, mass fell from 0.2015940.201594 to 0.1000440.100044–0.1001760.100176, and NLL rose from 2.8378772.837877 to 3.0341583.034158–3.0347323.034732. The numerical benchmark at mass ≤0.10\le0.10 is 3.0349223.034922. Gaussian CDFs checked masses; slight validity relaxation explains the lower NLLs.

Each run used 76,800 conditional draws and 4.25 million ordinary draws for mass estimates. Including rejection, the median was 5,074,647 membership queries and 2.54 seconds (AMD EPYC 9V74, one thread), for search, projections and oracle calls; benchmarking excluded. We used three tilts, 6,400 steps per tilt, grid 0.160.16 and tilt strength 0.0180.018. These empirical budgets do not establish the theorem's confidence guarantee.

Thank you for your response. I maintain my score.

Reviewer_aK7fOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper casts hallucination control as constrained maximum likelihood: given valid observations and an invalidity oracle, find a member of a fixed exponential family that minimizes the empirical NLL subject to invalid mass at most α\alpha. Without a capacity assumption, deciding feasibility is NP-hard even for Gaussian location families (Claim 1), so the authors assume powerfulness (Definition 2).

The key observation is that L(θ)+log⁡pθ(S)L(\theta)+\log p_\theta(S) is convex in the natural parameters, with stochastic gradients given by the model's own invalid samples, which links the problem to truncated statistics. A PSGD inner loop on a perturbed proxy and a grid-plus-bisection outer search with mass checks (Algorithms 1 and 2) give near-optimal NLL, invalid mass at most (1+ε)α(1+\varepsilon)\alpha, and a conditional KL bound with polynomially many oracle calls (Theorem 8).

A one-dimensional Gaussian illustration reduces the hallucination rate from 0.52 to 0.034.

Critical strengths

The formulation is well motivated: it asks for the best likelihood at a prescribed hallucination rate and explicitly sets aside the trivial fix of mixing in a valid answer. The central idea, that L+log⁡pθ(S)L+\log p_\theta(S) is convex in the natural parameters and that its gradients come from the model's own invalid samples, is a simple and clean bridge to truncated statistics. The boundary proxy addresses a real gap, since a small objective error does not by itself place a point near the sublevel boundary that determines the invalid mass, and the random linear perturbation combined with the common-direction argument closes it neatly.

The capacity assumption is motivated by the hardness result (Claim 1) and made concrete by the augmentation in Proposition 12. The accounting is careful: the guarantees do not assume that the data come from the family, truncated samples, ordinary samples and invalidity queries are costed separately, and the scope statements are candid.

Critical weaknesses

My main concern is that the assumptions of Theorem 8 appear jointly satisfiable only in narrow cases; as stated, they exclude every finite output space. Theorem 8 requires powerfulness for every α\alpha together with a global lower bound λI⪯Covpθ(T)\lambda I\preceq\mathrm{Cov}_{p_\theta}(T) on all of Θ\Theta. The proof of Proposition 9 shows that powerfulness produces parameters with pθ(S)→0p_\theta(S)\to0 that escape every bounded set, so Θ\Theta must be unbounded. Since Θ\Theta is open and convex (Section 2), it then contains a ray θ0+td\theta_0+td. On a finite output space, pθp_\theta concentrates along this ray on the outputs maximizing d⊤Td^\top T, so d⊤Covpθ(T) d→0d^\top\mathrm{Cov}_{p_\theta}(T)\,d\to0 and no λ>0\lambda>0 can work. This excludes the token-level categorical families that the paper cites as motivation. The augmented family of Proposition 12 fails the bound as well: Appendix A notes that the variance of the added indicator, q(S)(1−q(S))q(S)(1-q(S)), tends to zero as q(S)→0q(S)\to0, and a powerful family must contain members with arbitrarily small invalid mass. The only family shown to meet all assumptions is the one-dimensional unit-variance Gaussian with V=[0,∞)V=[0,\infty). The stated role of the lower bound, strong convexity of the NLL on the search sublevels, suggests that a bound on CHC_H might suffice; if so, the theorem should be stated that way and a non-Gaussian example verified, and otherwise its scope is quite narrow.

Part of the difficulty may also be absorbed by the assumption. Powerfulness implies feasibility at every α\alpha, whereas deciding feasibility is NP-hard without it (Claim 1). Powerfulness depends on both SS and the observed data (Definition 2), and beyond the two worked examples the paper gives no procedure or sufficient condition for checking it, so it is unclear how far the positive result reaches in practice.

The claims are broader than the result. The abstract states that the method "works in very general settings" and "settles an open problem posed by Hanneke et al. (2018)". It does add a qualifier about powerful exponential families, but the first concern suggests that the families satisfying all assumptions are narrow. The comparison with Hanneke et al. (2018) and Rittler and Chaudhuri (2024) is also purely qualitative, with no side-by-side comparison of assumptions, query counts or properness.

Complexity is stated only as "polynomial". Neither the main text nor Appendices D and F give explicit end-to-end exponents, and the stated parameter choices imply large ones: under Section 4.1 and equation (15), the proxy accuracy ξ\xi scales with q2q^2, the number of PSGD iterations with ξ−2\xi^{-2}, and qq with ε2\varepsilon^2, so each sublevel solve uses on the order of ε−8\varepsilon^{-8} truncated-sampling calls. Ordinary samples and invalidity queries additionally scale with 1/α1/\alpha, and small α\alpha is exactly the regime of interest.

The empirical evaluation is minimal: a single one-dimensional synthetic example with n=40n=40, in which VV is built from the data. The island half-width d0d_0, the exact algorithm run (Appendix H describes only an "illustrated update"), oracle-call counts, baselines and the NLL cost are not reported. The NLL cost matters here: the final rates (about 0.034) are well below α=0.05\alpha=0.05, whereas a constrained optimum has invalid mass exactly α\alpha whenever the unconstrained fit is infeasible (Lemma 13, Appendix C), so the returned models are strictly feasible and may give up more likelihood than necessary. The authors note that the example does not verify the assumptions of the theorem.

Two further points limit interpretation. The KL guarantee compares the conditional distributions on the invalid set; it falls out naturally from FSF_S but says little directly about the quality of the valid outputs. The validity oracle is also assumed noiseless (Section 4.3), whereas in practice validity is usually judged by noisy verifiers, and robustness to such noise is not analyzed.

Overall, the paper contributes an elegant convexity insight and a careful oracle-efficient analysis, but as stated its assumptions appear to exclude the finite-output models that motivate it, the only verified instance is a one-dimensional Gaussian, and the experiment is too limited to establish practical relevance. Clarifying whether a local covariance bound suffices, together with a verified non-Gaussian example, would considerably strengthen the paper. In its current form I lean toward rejection.

Questions for authors
  1. Is the covariance lower bound needed on all of Θ\Theta, or only on CHC_H, where strong convexity and the diameter bounds are used? If a local bound suffices, does a log-linear family over a finite output space satisfy all assumptions of Theorem 8, and can you give a non-Gaussian, ideally multi-dimensional, family that provably does?

  2. How can powerfulness be verified for a given family, validity set and data set? Would powerfulness at the target α\alpha alone suffice, or is the all-α\alpha version essential, given that Proposition 9 uses pθj(S)↓0p_{\theta_j}(S)\downarrow0?

  3. Can you state explicit exponents for the numbers of truncated-sampling calls, ordinary samples and invalidity queries, and compare them with the query complexities of Hanneke et al. (2018) and Rittler and Chaudhuri (2024)?

  4. For the Gaussian illustration, what are d0d_0, the algorithm that was run, the number of oracle calls, and the NLL of the initial fit, the final fit and the constrained optimum? How does the result compare with mixing in a valid atom at the same α\alpha?

  5. Can the conditional KL guarantee be translated into a guarantee on the valid part, for example KL(pθα⋆V∥pθ^V)\mathrm{KL}(p^V_{\theta^\star_\alpha}\|p^V_{\hat\theta}) or total variation, and how do the guarantees degrade under a noisy invalidity oracle?

2 comments

Q1. Local covariance and examples

Yes: localize the lower bound to the enclosing NLL sublevel; retain the global upper bound and other assumptions. For pθ(x)∝eθxp_θ(x)\propto e^{θ x} on {−1,0,1}\{-1,0,1\}, observation 0 and invalid outcome −1, the MLE is 0, projections clip intervals, and FS=L+log⁡pθ(S)=−θF_S=L+\log p_θ(S)=-θ proves powerfulness. Local variance is of order αα, allowing polynomial 1/α1/α cost.

For any dd, tilts of products of 12N(−1,1)+12N(1,1)\frac12N(-1,1)+\frac12N(1,1) have covariance eigenvalues in [1,2], uniform sub-Gaussian tails, explicit sampling, interior MLEs and scalar projection solves. For observation 0 and positive-measure S⊂{x1<0}S\subset\{x_1<0\} with efficient membership, increasing θ1θ_1 decreases FSF_S and sends invalid mass to zero.

Q2. Verifying powerfulness

Thank you for pointing this out. We agree that the capacity construction should also admit an interior MLE when the original MLE is interior. As stated in Theorem 8, we assume a prescribed powerful family satisfying the regularity and access conditions. We will revise Proposition 12 to illustrate this capacity through the more natural operation of mixing with valid mass: qθ,w=(1−w)pθ+wδzq_{\theta,w}=(1-w)p_\theta+w\delta_z, where zz is a new valid atom.

We also have added another hardness result to show that the problem in general is not polynomial solvable. Our reduction supplies strict feasibility and every other assumption: identity covariance, interior MLE, efficient exact queries, sampling and projections. At α=1/4α=1/4, NLL error 1 and a small fixed multiplicative validity slack yield 0.99-Max-Cut. Only powerfulness fails; hardness uses the same oracle model unless NP⊆BPP\mathrm{NP}\subseteq\mathrm{BPP}.

Q3. Query bounds and prior work

We should note that since in our construction we do not use optimization oracles the amount of queries is larger than it would appear in other works.

For fixed covariance/tail constants, dimension dd: conditional draws O~(d2ε−8)\tilde O(d^2ε^{-8}); mass-check draws/queries O~(α−1ε−4)\tilde O(α^{-1}ε^{-4}); total ordinary draws/queries with rejection O~(d2/(αε8)+1/(αε4))\tilde O(d^2/(αε^8)+1/(αε^4)). Tildes hide polylog factors in d,1/α,1/ε,1/δd,1/α,1/ε,1/δ; δδ is failure probability. Rejection costs O(1/α)O(1/α) per conditional draw. Local curvature can add cost; the smaller powerfulness level is never sampled.

Hanneke et al. (2018, Thm 7): O~(M3log⁡2∣Q∣/(a3b3))\tilde O(M^3\log^2|Q|/(a^3b^3)) queries, convex population loss ≤M\le M, class QQ, loss/validity slacks a,ba,b; here b=αεb=αε. But these were not including the oracle's computational complexity or the validities oracle complexity.

Rittler–Chaudhuri (2024): Lemma 5 gives proper zero-query TV/validity ERM under realizability/full validity; Thm 1 gives smoothed, generally improper log-loss learning with density bounds. Thm 3: O((Dlog⁡(1/(γu))+log⁡(1/δ))/(γu))O((D\log(1/(γu))+\log(1/δ))/(γu)) queries, bounded decreasing loss, fully valid data/comparator, generally improper output; DD is validity VC dimension, γγ minimum candidate valid mass, uu target invalidity, δδ failure probability. Our abstract will specify proper empirical NLL and structural/access assumptions.

Q4. Gaussian experiment and baseline

Appendix H fitted mean and variance using a valid-conditioned update with only 20 positive observations in its gradient although all 40 were valid, not Algorithms 1–2. Settings: d0=10−5d_0=10^{-5}, grid 0.3, 20,000 steps/level, 1/t1/t reset per level, warm starts, 50 levels. Projection used a penalty method and radial bisection without certified Euclidean accuracy.

At target 0.05, seed 0 changed estimated mass 0.501665→0.02620 and all-data NLL 2.1187→5.2268. The numerical constrained benchmark is 3.47814; a feasible Gaussian gives 3.47825. Mixing the initial Gaussian with a known valid unobserved output gives NLL 2.1187+log⁡(0.501598/0.05)≈4.42452.1187+\log(0.501598/0.05)\approx4.4245, using numerical initial mass and a common reference measure. The iterate is worse than both baselines. Reported 0.034 averages ten seeds; the notebook records one.

Costs: one million valid-conditioned requests, 1.2 million mass-estimation draws, at least 2.2 million queries. Rejection counts/runtime were not logged. We will correct the description.

Q5. Valid-output KL/TV

Invalid-set conditional KL alone gives no valid-output control. If feasible q∘q^\circ has KL(P∥q∘)≤A\mathrm{KL}(P\|q^\circ)\le A for valid-data law PP, empirical statistic-mean error is ≤η\le η, and comparator/output parameters lie in a radius-RR ball, finite risks give KL(P∥q^)≤A+ε+2Rη\mathrm{KL}(P\|\widehat q)\le A+ε+2Rη by NLL optimality. Conditioning on validity decreases KL. Pinsker gives TV ≤(A+ε+2Rη)/2\le\sqrt{(A+ε+2Rη)/2} for both distributions.

Q6. Noisy membership

For fresh independent errors of probability ≤η<1/2\le η<1/2, conditional on point/history, cap decisions at BB and take an odd m≥2log⁡(B/δ′)/(1−2η)2m\ge2\log(B/δ')/(1-2η)^2 judgments per decision. Hoeffding and a union bound give correct majority votes with probability ≥1−δ′\ge1-δ'. Calls increase by mm, failure probability by at most δ′δ'. Persistent errors are not covered.

Thank you for the response.

The localized covariance bound and the examples address my main concern.

However, the experiment did not run Algorithms 1–2. If they are too costly to run, the paper should say so and report the actual computation (e.g., samples, queries, and NLL against the baselines). In addition, powerfulness still seems hard to verify.

I will maintain my score.

Reviewer_aLuyOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies likelihood maximization subject to a bound on the probability of generating invalid outputs, given access to a binary invalidity oracle. For a fixed exponential family, it combines the convex objective FS=L+logpθ(S) with projected stochastic gradient descent over nested negative-log-likelihood sublevel sets. A capacity condition called powerfulness and a boundary perturbation argument connect this optimization to the original constraint. Under the stated regularity and oracle assumptions, the method approximately minimizes empirical negative log-likelihood, keeps invalid mass below (1+ε)α, and bounds KL divergence between distributions conditioned on invalid outputs. A one-dimensional Gaussian experiment illustrates the reduction in invalid mass.

Critical strengths
  1. The boundary argument provides a useful connection between the convex objective and the nonconvex validity constraint. The proof explains why minimizing the objective alone is insufficient and why the algorithm also needs boundary and mass checks.
  2. The analysis carefully separates conditional-sampling calls from ordinary samples and invalidity queries. The hardness result also helps explain why some structural assumption on the family is needed.
Critical weaknesses
  1. It is unclear how broadly Theorem 8 applies beyond the simple Gaussian half-line example. Proposition 12 establishes powerfulness, but its added indicator can have vanishing variance. Thus this construction does not satisfy the theorem's assumptions. The authors acknowledge the covariance limitation, but a more substantial worked example is needed to show the reach of the result.
  2. The abstract's claim to settle Hanneke et al.'s open problem is broader than the result shown. Theorem 8 concerns empirical NLL in a fixed powerful exponential family with additional regularity and oracle assumptions.
  3. The original question concerns population learning under bounded loss over broader model classes. The introduction makes this distinction more carefully than the abstract.
  4. The Gaussian experiment shows reduced invalid mass, but does not establish the claimed likelihood-validity tradeoff or practical efficiency. Appendix H omits d0, optimization settings, projection implementation, and runtime or query counts. It also gives no initial/final NLL or comparison with the constrained optimum. It is unclear whether the experiment implements Algorithms 1–2 or a simplified update.
Questions for authors
  1. Beyond the Gaussian half-line example, can the authors give a worked instance satisfying all assumptions, including an interior NLL minimizer and efficient projections?
  2. Could the abstract specify the restricted version of Hanneke et al.'s problem that is resolved?
  3. Which algorithm was run in Appendix H? Please specify its settings and projection procedure, report NLL, runtime, and query counts, and compare with the constrained optimum in this simple setting.
1 comment

Q1. Worked example and scope of powerfulness

Thank you for asking us to clarify the assumptions' reach. Your question prompted an immediate corollary of the proof: for a prescribed hallucination rate, powerfulness is needed only at one sufficiently small level. Invalid mass need not approach zero. Also we agree that the capacity construction should also admit an interior MLE when the original MLE is interior. As stated in Theorem 8, we assume a powerful family satisfying the regularity and access conditions. We will revise Proposition 12 to illustrate this capacity through the more natural operation of mixing with valid mass: qθ,w=(1−w)pθ+wδzq_{\theta,w}=(1-w)p_\theta+w\delta_z, where zz is a new valid atom. If the original nn observations have interior MLE θ^\widehat\theta, adding one observation at zz gives MLE (θ^,1/(n+1))(\widehat\theta,1/(n+1)). The regularity bounds for this depend on the base family.

For target α\alpha, choose a sufficiently small β<α\beta<\alpha. A parameter with invalid mass s>βs>\beta must admit another parameter in the prescribed family with mass β\beta and average empirical NLL at most L(θ)+log⁡(s/β)+ξ\mathcal L(\theta)+\log(s/\beta)+\xi, where ξ\xi depends on the requested accuracy. Retaining the original model with probability β/s\beta/s and otherwise returning a known valid output explains this bound. The approximate condition requires the mass and likelihood comparison within the family, without exact mixture closure.

For a worked example, exponentially tilt a product of symmetric mixtures 12N(−1,1)+12N(1,1)\tfrac12N(-1,1)+\tfrac12N(1,1) on Rd\mathbb R^d, with statistic xx and valid observation 00. Its log partition is A(θ)=∥θ∥2/2+∑ilog⁡cosh⁡θi.A(\theta)=\|\theta\|^2/2+\sum_i\log\cosh\theta_i. Covariance eigenvalues lie in [1,2][1,2] globally; centered statistics are uniformly sub-Gaussian; evaluation and sampling are explicit. The MLE is 00, sublevels are compact, and Euclidean projections reduce to scalar coordinate solves and a multiplier bisection. For a positive-measure invalid set S⊂{x1<0}S\subset\{x_1<0\} with efficient membership, ∂1(L+log⁡pθ(S))=Eθ[X1∣S]<0\partial_1(\mathcal L+\log p_\theta(S))=\mathbb E_\theta[X_1\mid S]<0. Increasing θ1\theta_1 also sends invalid mass to zero, proving powerfulness.

Q2. Open problem and abstract

We will revise the abstract to specify: “We give a polynomial-time proper algorithm for the empirical log-loss formulation of Hanneke et al.'s relaxed-validity problem in prescribed exponential families, under stated regularity and access assumptions, without their model-fitting optimization oracle. Powerfulness at one sufficiently small level suffices.”

Hanneke et al. (2018, p. 3; §5.1) ask about bounded population loss over broader classes. Our algorithm uses sampling, invalidity queries and NLL-sublevel projections. A population corollary follows if the sufficient-statistic mean error is at most η\eta and the returned parameter and a feasible population optimum lie in a common radius-RR ball: excess loss is at most ε+2Rη\varepsilon+2R\eta, assuming finite risks. The data law need not belong to the family.

For representation, smooth any finite collection of laws with their average by a fraction hh. The log-density construction of Bickis (2015, §2.2) embeds them in one exponential family. Invalid probabilities change by at most hh and finite log loss increases by at most −log⁡(1−h)-\log(1-h). Efficient fitting still requires the stated assumptions.

We will also state the stronger hardness result: near-optimal NLL with relaxed validity is NP-hard in the worst case even with identity covariance, explicit interior MLE and projections, efficient sampling and exact membership, and a supplied strictly feasible parameter. Only powerfulness fails, including its approximate form at the required level, in the same sampling-oracle model.

Q3. Appendix H: algorithm, settings and results

Appendix H fitted Gaussian mean and variance with a simplified valid-conditioned update using only 20 positive-valued observations, although all 40 observations were valid. It did not implement Algorithms 1–2.

At target 0.05, seed 0 reduced estimated invalid mass from 0.501665 to 0.02620, while all-data NLL rose from 2.1187 to 5.2268. An explicit feasible Gaussian attains 3.47825; the numerical constrained benchmark is 3.47814. Thus the run sacrificed more likelihood than necessary. The paper's 0.034 is a ten-seed average; the available notebook records only seed 0.

There were one million valid-conditioned sampler requests and 1.2 million ordinary draws for mass estimates: at least 2.2 million membership queries. Exact rejection counts and wall time were not recorded. We will correct Appendix H and add the two-dimensional non-Gaussian experiment satisfying the assumptions. All five runs at target 0.10 attained invalid mass 0.100044–0.100176 (at most 0.176% above target) and NLL 3.034158–3.034732, near the numerical exact-constraint benchmark 3.034922. Median cost was 2.54 seconds and 5,074,647 queries.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Summary

We thank the reviewers for their constructive criticism. Their questions have helped us broaden the positive result through an approximate powerfulness corollary, strengthen the hardness result, and replace the capacity construction with a more natural mixture construction. Together, these revisions clarify both the scope of our contribution and the role of the assumptions.

Hanneke et al. (2018, Introduction, p. 3; §5.1) ask whether relaxed-validity generative learning can be computationally efficient even with access to an optimization oracle. Given samples of valid examples and an invalidity oracle, the goal is to achieve nearly optimal population loss among candidate distributions of invalid mass at most α\alpha, allowing a small validity slack. They give polynomial sample and query bounds for bounded convex loss, but leave polynomial running time open. The model-fitting oracle used in their full-validity result minimizes empirical loss while excluding supplied invalid examples.

We address the empirical log-loss formulation in prescribed exponential families. Under approximate powerfulness and our stated regularity and access assumptions, the algorithm returns a member of the family in polynomial time, with polynomial sample and query complexity, without their model-fitting optimization oracle. Its NLL is within ε\varepsilon of the best α\alpha-feasible value, and its invalid mass is at most (1+ε)α(1+\varepsilon)\alpha. It uses sampling, invalidity queries and ordinary NLL-sublevel projections. The same algorithm has an immediate population corollary: sufficient-statistic mean error η\eta gives excess log loss at most ε+2Rη\varepsilon+2R\eta, assuming finite risks and a common radius-RR bound for the output and a feasible population optimum. The valid-data law need not belong to the family. Under sub-Gaussian concentration of its sufficient statistics, this gives polynomial sample complexity.

Exponential families include standard generative models and admit a general embedding construction. Using Bickis's (2015, §2.2) log-density construction, any finite collection of generative laws embeds in one exponential family after mixing each law with a fraction hh of their average. Invalid probabilities change by at most hh, and finite log loss increases by at most −log⁡(1−h)-\log(1-h). Efficient fitting still depends on the dimension, regularity and computational access of the chosen family.

The principal revisions are:

  1. Approximate powerfulness. An immediate corollary of the proof requires the comparison only at one sufficiently small level β<α\beta<\alpha. Each parameter of invalid mass s>βs>\beta need only admit a family member of mass β\beta with NLL increase at most log⁡(s/β)+ξ\log(s/\beta)+\xi, for sufficiently small accuracy-dependent ξ\xi. Invalid mass need not approach zero. This extends the positive result beyond families satisfying full powerfulness.

  2. Stronger hardness. Near-optimal NLL with relaxed validity remains NP-hard in the worst case even when a strictly feasible parameter is supplied. Every other hypothesis holds: Gaussian statistics with identity covariance, an explicit interior MLE and projections, efficient sampling and exact membership. Only powerfulness fails, including its approximate form at the required level. This complements the original feasibility hardness by showing that supplying feasibility does not remove the difficulty of optimizing likelihood under the validity constraint.

  3. Revised Proposition 12. We will replace the selective augmentation with ordinary mixing with valid mass, qθ,w=(1−w)pθ+wδzq_{\theta,w}=(1-w)p_\theta+w\delta_z, for a new valid atom zz. Adding one observation at zz gives an interior MLE for the augmented objective whenever the original MLE is interior. This is a capacity illustration; its regularity bounds depend on the base family and mixture weights. As already stated, the theorem assumes a prescribed family satisfying its hypotheses. The non-Gaussian worked examples verify those hypotheses together.

These revisions leave the main algorithm and proof strategy unchanged. The approximate and population results are direct corollaries of the existing analysis, and Proposition 12 needs only the mixture comparison and a short MLE calculation. We will add the strengthened reduction alongside the existing feasibility hardness result and revise the abstract and introduction to state this scope precisely.

References

Hanneke et al. (2018), Actively Avoiding Nonsense in Generative Models.

Bickis (2015), The Geometry of Imprecise Inference.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.