- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents Attribution-guided Semantic Evolution (ASE), a modular framework for text-augmented time series forecasting. It consists of three modules: semantic factor construction, conditional combination evaluation, and validation-controlled deployment. Through a predictor-consistent feedback loop, it evaluates the conditional contribution of each textual factor and selects effective predictors. The method is validated on four TESS datasets and a dynamic CSI 300 stock ranking task, with controlled module-level analyses.
Critical strengths
One key strength is the feedback-based semantic evolution mechanism, which links textual factor revision to measurable conditional gains from predictor refitting. This provides a principled way to quantify textual feature utility.
Critical weaknesses
- The main TESS benchmarks only compare point estimates without paired statistical tests
- The CSI 300 numerical reference confidence interval includes zero.
Questions for authors
- Introduction mentions "We study a different feedback question: what information should a forecast model return to the language model that proposes its textual measurements?". Why cannot existing text forecasting methods answer this question, and what is the specific research gap?
- The scoring function of combination search in Section 3.2 introduces block standard deviation penalty and subset size penalty. What is the basis for the values of the weight coefficients of the two penalty terms, and has parameter sensitivity analysis been conducted?
- Section 3.1 mentions "Six raw factors and eight event–state products are compiled per generation; after five rounds the accumulated library has 70 feature slots.". What is the basis for this hyperparameter setting, and is there a risk of factor redundancy?
- The main leaderboard in Chapter 4 Experimental Setup mixes published TESS scores and results of locally adapted models. Given differences in implementation and tuning degree between the two, how to ensure the fairness of direct comparison?
- The confidence interval of the numerical reference in the CSI 300 experiment includes zero. Does this affect the statistical robustness of the text fusion gain?
- Section 5.3 Module Analysis only selects partial tasks to verify component benefits. Why are systematic cross-task ablation experiments not designed?
- Full names should be given for all English abbreviations at their first occurrence. Many English abbreviations such as LLM lack full names. There is a lack of linguistic rigor.
As the authors have not responded to the review, my concerns remain unaddressed. I therefore maintain my original score.