- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes CAST for zero-inflated sequence learning. It separates inactivity from active values, learns temporal structure, embeds it in hyperbolic space, and uses the structure to guide a KAN-based predictor. CAST shows strong results across several real-world sparse-sequence tasks.
Critical strengths
-
Well-motivated design: Treating zeros as inactivity rather than ordinary low values is reasonable and well integrated into the model.
-
Strong performance: CAST achieves the best average F1 among the compared methods, and the ablations support the importance of structural learning.
Critical weaknesses
-
The reliability of the learned temporal structure is not sufficiently validated. The real-world experiments mainly evaluate downstream prediction, while structural recovery is only examined in controlled synthetic settings. It is therefore unclear whether the learned graph captures meaningful and stable dependencies on real data.
-
The real-world evaluation is limited to retail and e-commerce datasets. This makes it unclear whether CAST generalizes to other types of zero-inflated sequential data.
Questions for authors
-
Can the authors provide additional evidence that the learned temporal graph is stable and meaningful on real-world data, for example through graph stability, perturbation, or structure-recovery analyses?
-
Can the authors evaluate CAST on zero-inflated sequence datasets outside the retail/e-commerce domain to demonstrate broader generalization?
6 comments
Gentle Follow-up on Our Rebuttal
We sincerely appreciate your insightful comments. We have carefully addressed your concerns and submitted our rebuttal. We would be grateful if you could take a moment to review our responses and share any further comments. Thank you so much for your valuable time and consideration.
Official Comment
Thank you for the detailed rebuttal and additional experiments. I appreciate the authors' efforts to address my concerns.
The new cross-domain experiments largely address my second concern. The additional graph stability and ablation results are also helpful. However, the relatively moderate subsample stability, particularly on CDNOW, leaves some uncertainty about the reliability of the learned temporal structure. The stability metric, edge selection criteria, and appropriate reference baselines would also benefit from further clarification.
Could the authors clarify the graph stability metric and provide an appropriate reference baseline to help interpret the reported stability values?
We sincerely appreciate the reviewer, have carefully addressed all the concerns raised.
We have thoroughly revised the manuscript in response to the reviewer's insightful comments and uploaded the updated version.
Q1 We assess three complementary properties of the learned temporal graph: real-world reproducibility, predictive relevance, and structural recovery.
Real-world stability. We evaluate graph consistency across random initializations and training-data subsamples.
The learned graphs show consistent structural agreement across initializations, with lower stability under subsampling. Instacart exhibits the highest stability, while CDNOW is more sensitive to perturbations. We will document edge selection criteria, perturbation protocols, and repetition counts for reproducibility.
Predictive relevance. Graph-source ablations compare ZI-SEM with Gaussian SEM, randomized graphs, and removal of structural learning. CAST achieves the highest F1 across Retail, CDNOW, and Instacart, demonstrating that learned temporal dependencies provide predictive value beyond simply introducing a graph. Figure 3 and Appendix M (Additional Structural Analyses) of the revised paper further illustrate their influence on downstream representations.
Structural recovery. Appendix J (Empirical Evaluation of Theoretical Mechanisms with Synthetic Data) evaluates recovery against known synthetic graphs under varying zero-inflation levels, using structural distance, edge F1, and true positive rate.
Together, these experiments demonstrate that the learned structure is recoverable under controlled conditions, reproducible on real-world data, and informative for prediction.
Q2 We extend CAST to three distinct domains: neural spike counts (Allen Brain Observatory Neuropixels), daily precipitation (NOAA GHCN-Daily), and urban mobility (NYC TLC). Zeros respectively indicate intervals without detected spikes, recorded precipitation, or pickups. These settings test whether separating event occurrence from active-state magnitude generalizes beyond transactional data.
As summarized in Section 5.3 (Main Results), CAST achieves 68.17 ± 0.69 F1 and 74.77 ± 0.53 accuracy on Neuropixels, outperforming MambaSL by 2.35 F1 points. The complete Neuropixels baseline comparison, graph-source evaluation, and component ablations are reported in Appendix N (Cross-Domain Evaluation) of the revised paper. We further evaluate twelve statistical and neural baselines on NOAA and NYC TLC.
Table. Additional cross-domain evaluation (%, mean ± standard deviation).
CAST achieves the highest F1 and accuracy on both benchmarks, exceeding MambaSL by 2.44 F1 points on NOAA and 2.09 on NYC. Together with Neuropixels, these results demonstrate consistent advantages across three distinct domains.
Neuropixels ablations further support structural learning: replacing ZI-SEM with Gaussian structural learning reduces F1 from 68.17% to 65.23%, while randomized graphs reduce it to 61.70%. These results further support the predictive value of zero-inflation-aware structural learning.
Across all three domains, observed zeros represent inactivity rather than low-magnitude active observations. CAST explicitly separates event occurrence from conditional magnitude, allowing temporal dependencies to be learned under this shared observation structure. The consistent improvements demonstrate the effectiveness of this structural inductive bias beyond retail applications.
We sincerely appreciate the reviewer's great efforts, insightful comments, and valuable suggestions for improving our paper.