acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Tracing Low-Level Linguistic Properties Through Sparse Representation to Behavior

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Language models (LMs) are built on human languages; therefore, the structural properties of languages are deeply embedded in a model's representations, affecting output-level behaviors. The relationship between these effects (as well as their nature) and the linguistic information remains largely unclear. We study this relationship through a combination of approaches across 40 low-level linguistic variables represented by 20,000 controlled contrast pairs across eight languages. In XGLM-564M, we compare supervised linear probes with features derived from a BatchTopK sparse autoencoder trained independently on multilingual natural text. Through evaluating these features across a set of metrics, performing ablation, and steering, which is then followed by next-token-level behavior evaluation, we find a set of six variables that show significant and consistent results across most tests while major subsets survive across different assessments. In this study, we aim to highlight the possibilities behind the broader intersection of computational linguistics and mechanistic interpretability, while showcasing how not just the features themselves, but the methods and approaches we use also produce significantly overlapping evidence and localization of representations.

Primary area:
interpretability and explainable AI
Keywords:
mechanistic interpretability, sparse autoencoders, computational linguistics, linguistic representations, linguistic features

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_WPRjOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates whether linear probes and SAEs identify low-level linguistic information encoded in human language across several languages. They train probes and SAE on XGLM-564M and find that they can each recover a reasonable fraction of the 40 linguistic variables they test for. They also test whether ablating or steering with these features/probes influences the model's generation in a meaningful way.

Critical strengths

None

Critical weaknesses

The paper is poorly written, confusing, and difficult to understand, including using undefined phrases/terms or strange AI-coded language. It is not quite clear what the actual contributions of this paper are or how they relate to prior work and the related work is quite sparse in general, which could also be improved. Additionally, many experiment details are unclear or lack justification, such as using an arbitrary letter ranking system without defining how the rubric was applied, or steering/ablation methodology, among others. Many details are left to the appendix, but this does not help the readability. I would recommend rejection based on the lack of clarity of the submission.

Questions for authors

Can you clarify the rubric/process by which you assigned letter-grades to SAE features, and what the various letter grades mean?

Reviewer_iLXUOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper traces 40 linguistic contrasts in XGLM-564M from linear probes and SAE features through ablation, steering, and next-token behavior, using synthetic contrast pairs. It reports broad recoverability, fewer causal effects, and behavioral effects for six variables.

Critical strengths

An end-to-end chain from representation to behavior across a typologically broad set of contrasts, with a released dataset. The finding that recoverability, interpretability, causal effect, and behavior diverge is a useful caution.

Critical weaknesses
  • it's a bit hidden in the appendix (Figure 4, Table 4) but it seems that several probes peak at the embedding layer, the surface-text control is excluded from the robustness criterion, and several contrasts differ by specific words by design. In Fig4, mean held-out AUROC is already about 0.71 (sentence probe) and 0.79 (pair-difference probe) at index 0, and rises only slightly with depth. This suggests that much of the reported recoverability may reflect lexical or surface differences between the paired sentences (which tokens are present) rather than abstract linguistic properties computed by the model. Because the SAE features and the downstream causal and behavioral analyses are selected from the same contrasts, they likely inherit this confound. The authors should require probes to beat the surface-text baseline, report results excluding the embedding layer, and test whether effects persist on contrasts matched for lexical content.

  • The behavioral effects seem very small: the six “full-chain” effects range from about 0.0007 to 0.02 logits in next-token margin (Table 2; Table 8; Fig. 3). With 50 pairs and bootstrap inference, such shifts can be statistically significant while remaining negligible in practice. A change of 0.02 logits moves the relative probability of two continuations by at most about half a percentage point, and the smallest effect by about 0.02 percentage points. Statistical reliability alone therefore does not support claims of “behavioral influence”; at most it shows a detectable contribution. The paper also provides no reference scale to judge these effects, such as the baseline margin between continuations or the effect of patching in the full basis–changed difference. The authors should report such references or reframe the claim accordingly.

  • Features pass through several filters, and some are swapped after human inspection, without statistical accounting.

Questions for authors

How many variables remain robust when probes are required to beat the surface-text baseline and the embedding layer (index 0) is excluded?

Do the SAE, causal, and behavioral results hold on contrasts matched for lexical content?

What is the baseline logit margin between the two continuations, and how large is the effect of patching in the full basis–changed difference?

How many of the six full-chain variables survive when the original statistically selected features are used instead of the inspection-swapped ones (Table 5)?

Reviewer_MEGkOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper trains linear probes and an SAE to recover low-level linguistic features from XGLM-564M. They show that many features are recoverable from hidden states, with substantial overlap between probes and the SAE in recoverability. However, some SAE features capture narrower or surface-level patterns rather than the intended linguistic concepts. Feature recoverability does not consistently align with semantic interpretability, and features that support causal changes in downstream representations do not necessarily yield changes in next-token preferences. These findings suggest that recoverability and intervention results alone are insufficient to validate the semantic interpretations assigned to features in some of the conventional interpretability research.

Critical strengths
  1. The coverage of 40 low-level linguistic variables is decent, and the 20,000 contrast pairs and coverage across eight languages are strong aspects of the study.
  2. The experimental design includes separate training and test sets for probing and SAE feature identification, with the SAE itself trained on an independent corpus.
  3. Having both ablation and steering experiments is good, and the matched controls and statistical corrections strengthen the evaluation.
  4. Section 3 is written very clearly, and many experimental design choices reference prior work, grounding the methodology in established approaches.
  5. The paper raises a fair concern about the gap between what interpretability experiments establish and the semantic interpretations researchers assign to the features.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The central claim is not clearly communicated. The abstract is ambiguous about the main research question, and the intended message about the gap between interpretability experiments and their semantic interpretations only becomes clear in the discussion.
  2. Evidence of generalizability is limited. While using a small 2021 model is reasonable for studying low-level features, the experiments examine only one model and train the SAE at only one hidden-state layer.
  3. The behavioral evaluation is narrow. The experiments study next-token logit margins, but do not examine actual continuation generation, whether generated tokens change, or whether effects persist across tokens. Some linguistic properties may not be expressed by the immediate next token.
  4. The semantic-misalignment claim needs stronger evidence. The claim that statistically robust features capture narrower patterns relies largely on qualitative inspection, without a clearly specified grading rubric or controlled tests of the proposed proxies.
  5. The scientific contribution appears limited. The methods largely follow established probe and SAE approaches. Although the concern raised is fair, the experiments do not clearly distinguish semantic misalignment from limitations of the intervention setup or behavioral metric. The paper might be better suited as a position paper advocating that interpretability researchers pay more attention to what they intend to interpret versus what their methods actually establish.
Questions for authors
  1. Do the main findings hold on a newer model or with SAEs trained at different layers?
  2. What evidence beyond qualitative inspection supports the claim that statistically robust features capture narrower patterns rather than the intended linguistic concepts?
  3. Do the intervention effects change the actual generated continuation, and do they persist across generated tokens?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.