- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The compact evidence is import in digital pathology field, it can help trace the interpretable evidence. In the paper, the author makes an framework evaluation report across different tasks, MIL models and feature extractor.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
- The paper is difficult to understand, especially the methodology and overall workflow. Although the authors raise a potentially meaningful research question, I find it hard to follow how the proposed method and experiments are connected to the main motivation. The writing also feels somewhat AI-generated, with repetitive descriptions and a lack of clear explanations, which makes the paper even harder to follow.
- Some sections are not well organized, such as the contributions in the Introduction. For example, the authors directly introduce without clearly explaining what these variables mean, making it difficult for readers to understand the contributions. Similar problems appear in other sections, where technical concepts are introduced without sufficient explanation.
- In my opinion, the current version of this paper does not meet the standards of ICLR. While the research question is worth investigating, the methodological contribution is relatively limited, and the experiments do not provide a sufficiently clear and convincing story. I would suggest that the authors carefully revise the manuscript, particularly its motivation, methodology, and experimental presentation, before submitting it to a more suitable conference or journal.
Questions for authors
In my view, a high-quality research paper should address a well-defined and meaningful problem with a reasonably innovative method. Such innovation does not necessarily need to be groundbreaking, but it should be closely aligned with the research problem, supported by clear motivation, and reflected in a coherent methodological design. The proposed method should then be thoroughly validated through convincing experiments, with the overall work carefully organized and refined into a logically structured and well-supported paper. However, although this paper addresses a potentially meaningful research problem, I find it difficult to identify a clear and consistent narrative throughout the methodology and experimental sections. In particular, the motivations behind individual methodological components, their relationships, and the extent to which the experimental results support the central claims are not sufficiently clear. Despite my efforts to carefully follow the technical details, I found the paper difficult to understand and struggled to develop a coherent picture of its main contributions. Given these concerns, I encourage the authors to substantially revise the manuscript by clarifying the central research narrative, strengthening the connections between methodological choices and their underlying motivations, and providing more convincing experimental evidence. I would recommend thoroughly refining the manuscript before submitting it to an appropriate conference or journal.