- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes the Hawkes-Augmented World Model (HAWM), which augments DreamerV3's recurrent state-space model (RSSM) with explicit event-occurrence variables, event types, and a Hawkes-style exponentially decaying event memory. An observation-conditioned posterior infers events from observed trajectories, while a latent-conditioned prior predicts events during imagination. An auxiliary future-reward objective encourages the event representation to capture information relevant to subsequent task progress. The method is evaluated on seven robotic manipulation tasks from ManiSkill3 and MS-HAB.
Critical strengths
-
The paper is reasonably motivated by the influence of consequential interaction events on long-term prediction and control. The overall approach offers some novelty.
-
The integration of posterior–prior event modeling with world-model imagination is natural and coherent. Event history continues to inform prediction and policy learning throughout imagined rollouts.
-
The empirical evaluation is relatively thorough. The main experiments, ablations, and generalization results consistently show substantial advantages for HAWM on multi-stage robotic manipulation tasks.
Critical weaknesses
-
The experiments primarily focus on robotic manipulation tasks with distinct stages and temporally clustered events. These tasks naturally involve phases such as contact, grasping, alignment, and insertion, making them well matched to the proposed Hawkes inductive bias. The current evaluation does not provide sufficient evidence that the method is also effective on tasks without a pronounced clustered-event structure.
-
Event discovery relies heavily on future-reward supervision. When rewards are very sparse or substantially delayed, consequential interactions may fall outside the fixed prediction horizon, weakening the learning signal for event discovery.
-
Parts of the paper, particularly the experimental section in Appendix C.4, show clear signs of AI-generated writing or experimental reporting. This substantially undermines the manuscript's professionalism and credibility.
Questions for authors
-
The current evaluation primarily covers robotic manipulation tasks with distinct stages and temporally clustered events. Could the authors include broader visual-control benchmarks, such as Atari-100K, to determine whether HAWM remains effective in environments without explicit event structures such as contact, grasping, and alignment?
-
Could the authors clarify the description of the experiments in lines 1194–1195 of Appendix C.4?
Overall, I basically agree with the overall approach proposed in this paper for event history modeling. However, some of the experiments and textual descriptions in the paper, especially in Appendix C.4, have significantly affected my judgment on the overall professionalism and credibility of the manuscript. For this reason, I give a rejection score.