- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
FinAutoRubric is an expert-guided framework that automatically generates evidence-grounded, context-specific rubrics for evaluating financial research agents. It combines reusable expert guidance, a Task Bank, query contextualization, and writer–reviewer validation loops to produce adaptable rubrics without per-item expert authoring. The accompanying FinAutoRubric Benchmark contains 100 analyst-derived queries spanning 78 tasks and eight asset classes, enabling broad evaluation of finance agents. Experiments show that FinAutoRubric rubrics closely match expert scoring, improve criterion coverage, align with human judgments, and support effective benchmarking of financial research agents.
Critical strengths
- The authors identify the problem of automatic rubric synthesis in the financial domain and incorporate expert knowledge into the process.
- The rubrics generated by FinAutoRubric are more highly recognized by financial experts compared with previous works.
- The authors construct the FinAutoRubric Benchmark based on questions from financial analysts.
Critical weaknesses
- Although the involvement of financial experts improves the quality of rubrics generated by FinAutoRubric, it also reduces the efficiency of the overall system and makes generalization more difficult. The authors do not compare FinAutoRubric with previous works in terms of efficiency and cost, including the time required for financial expert annotation.
- I am curious about how the quality of rubrics generated by FinAutoRubric compares with the built-in rubrics provided by BigFinanceBench, FrontierFinance, and Finance Agent Benchmark when used to evaluate models.
- Does the improvement of rubrics lead to significant changes in model performance, ranking, or gradients, or does it only introduce minor score perturbations? Can rubrics generated by FinAutoRubric identify certain model behaviors or weaknesses that previous rubrics fail to detect? The paper lacks related discussions.
Questions for authors
- I would like the authors to provide more information about the financial expert annotation process, including the number of experts involved, the annotation time, and whether annotations were conducted independently or followed by agreement/reconciliation.
- Since involving financial experts may increase the cost and reduce the efficiency of the rubric generation process, could the authors provide a detailed comparison of the time and computational/human costs between FinAutoRubric and previous rubric generation approaches?
- Does FinAutoRubric-generated rubric evaluation reveal different model behaviors or failure cases compared with existing benchmark rubrics? Specifically, can the authors provide examples where FinAutoRubric identifies weaknesses of financial agents that previous rubrics fail to capture?
Thank you for the response and the new analyses. The authors made a good effort to address my comments. But if I understand correct, several points are not empirically resolved. The cost table and the expert assessment are helpful, but my main concerns remain. Under the same budget ceiling, the full method reaches 60.8% expected-value coverage versus 57.9% for the closest ablation. This ablation also removes several components at once and does not match actual compute, so the contribution of expert guidance remains unclear. The incremental benefit of the Task Bank is statistically inconclusive. In addition, evidence for adaptation to new cutoffs remains limited, and adaptation to modified guidance and repeatability have not been tested. The expert assessment covers only 20 of the 100 released rubrics, and it is unclear whether the two experts are independent of this work. I will maintain my score.