- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
DDS uses changes in localization predictions between consecutive epochs to weight evidential regularization and localization residuals. It retains single-pass inference and improves uncertainty–error alignment across three backbones, two grounding datasets, and zero-adaptation evaluation on Ref-Adv-s.
Critical strengths
-
The method is simple and requires only a previous-epoch prediction buffer during training, with no additional inference sampling or models.
-
Uncertainty improvements are consistent across backbones and datasets while largely preserving localization accuracy. The zero-adaptation OOD results provide additional evidence of usefulness.
Critical weaknesses
-
Novelty and attribution are limited. Equation (6) dynamically weights the existing evidential regression regularizer, while Equation (8) adds a weighted L1 loss. The ablation enables both terms together, without constant-weight or shuffled-dynamics controls. The gains could therefore reflect stronger regularization or additional localization supervision rather than the dynamics signal itself.
-
The key control is unclear. The no-dynamics row in Table 3 reports Pearson 0.3363, versus 0.5081 for the same backbone’s NIG baseline in Table 1, without explaining the loss or configuration differences. Dropout sampling counts, ensemble size, and variability across independent training runs are also missing.
Questions for authors
-
Clarification: Does the no-dynamics configuration in Table 3 retain standard evidential regularization? What is its full loss, and why does it differ substantially from the NIG baseline in Table 1?
-
Additional validation: How do distribution shaping and residual correction perform separately? With matched average loss weights, does actual IEPV outperform constant weights and shuffled IEPV?
-
Clarification and additional validation: What are the dropout sampling count and ensemble size? Are the main improvements consistent across independent training seeds?