- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
ANSM is an production networking layer for sandboxes for agents in a cloud environment. ANSM operates in two nodes, sandbox and gateway to solve the challenge of fast setup, high density, connectivity, isolation and identity of running agents.
Critical strengths
This is a valuable experience paper with practical measurements and potential real-world impact.
Critical weaknesses
- My main concern is venue fit. This paper mostly reads like a very valuable experience report, and I think this fits much better and will receive more attention in a networking-oriented conference like NSDI/SIGCOMM or some other industrial tracks.
- The evaluation setup is narrow. The setup seems limited, and while targeting at agent, there seems to be no end-to-end measurement on any of the agent turnaround time. There is also no objective measurement against other baselines for main results like Figure 2-3. Only a qualitative comparison with existing work is provided.
- From the writing, it is unclear to me how the design requirements deviates from existing cloud workloads like serverless (which seems to be also demand the traits laid out by the paper).
Questions for authors
Please see weakness
We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback. We would like to clarify two points.
(1) Relevance to ICLR / agent systems.
We agree that ANSM is a systems paper, but its relevance to ICLR comes from the fact that agents are becoming an important component of modern AI systems, and their practical performance increasingly depends on the underlying infrastructure. Networking is a core part of this infrastructure. It directly affects sandbox startup latency, concurrency, connectivity, and therefore the range of agent workloads that can be deployed in practice. From this perspective, sandbox networking is not merely a generic cloud-operations issue, but an important systems problem for large-scale AI agents. We will revise the paper to make this connection more explicit.
(2) Relationship to serverless workloads.
We agree that sandbox networking shares many similarities with serverless networking, and we believe serverless workloads could also benefit from the ANSM architecture. The main differences lie in the workload requirements. First, sandboxes typically require stronger network isolation: serverless code (e.g., Lambda functions) is usually human-written and reviewed, whereas sandboxed agent workloads are often less predictable and may execute more arbitrary or untrusted code. Second, sandbox lifetimes are often shorter than those of conventional serverless pods/functions, which places stricter demands on high-density, highly elastic network provisioning. These differences motivate our focus on an architecture that decouples network-resource lifetime from sandbox lifetime and supports rapid, isolated, large-scale sandbox creation.